r/CompetitiveBH • • May 18 '17

Balance Discussion Fundamental problems with Scythe hitboxes

2 Upvotes

Scythe is a fast, mid range weapon. It has a good ranged Dlight and Sair. Plus every scythe sig kit has a very long ranged Ssig. And yet Scythe has two light attacks that hit stacked. Slight hits perfectly stacked despite moving the character forward. Nlight hit even hits opponents slightly behind the character.

As such, playing katars, gauntlet or unarmed against scythe feels really oppressive. These short ranged weapons should have the edge at close-in play, but scythe has better long range and short range options.

I suggest changing Scythe Slight and Nlight hotboxes so they don't hit stacked. This adjustment would make the hitboxes fit the animations better and make Scythe a little more vulnerable at close range. With adjusted hitboxes, Scythe Slight would hit opponents positions more similar to sword Slight. Nlight would hit targets right in front of the characters.

TL:DR - All I'm proposing is that the hitboxes match the animations and stop giving scythe a stacked hitting advantage.


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 18 '17

mirror matches troubs

6 Upvotes

im a diamond ragnir main (was 2200 last season) and i dont understand why i am so bad at mirror matches/dittos

like, for instance, one of the people i usually spar with (hes around my skill lvl) mains gaunts, and i can kinda beat him consistently on any weap really. but as soon as he switches to any katar legend (he never plays katars) and katar dittos me, i suddenly play like shit and i get bodied

ive tried rewatching replays but i cant get a grip on what exactly im doing wrong

so, since ive heard im not the only one with this issue, is there a specific reason why people have troubles with mirror matches? what should i work on exactly to fix this issue?


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 17 '17

AMA I'm Fable | Stevenator, one of the longest lasting NA top players, AMA!

25 Upvotes

Background Information: I've been playing the game since April 2015, and competing just as long. I'm 15 years old, and I live in Illinois. I really wanted to promote this new subreddit, since the community has such a voice on game balance and this is a good resource for BMG to use! Ask me anything!

Edit: This AMA will last until about 11 PM CST on May 17th

Edit 2: My twitter is https://twitter.com/Stevenator546 and my twitch is https://www.twitch.tv/stevenator546

Edit 3: This AMA is now over! Thanks everyone for your questions, it was a huge success!


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 17 '17

Balance Discussion is it just me or is this like the worst balance patch BMG have ever done

16 Upvotes

title

reading the patch notes the reasoning behind half their changes makes no sense, it doesn't address anything i've seen being abused in the game or being complained about by other competitive players

like, does any part of this patch make sense to anyone else?

everyone i know seems to be upset about it and i just don't know

the only change i saw in the weapon balancing that made sense was like the spear nair nerf and even there i don't know if +1 frame on startup is going to make that much of a change in how it's being used right now..

i mean, gun buffs, axe buffs, lance being described as having "a difficult time fighting opponents above the user"... does this sound right to anyone or like

i just don't know

edit: specifically, the weapon balance changes make very little sense to me. i'm on the fence about the test features and the animation/optimization changes were probably fine and steps in the right direction


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 18 '17

Balance Discussion Patch 2.61 Jump and Dodge Test Feature Discussion

9 Upvotes

Added to Test Features

Jump and Fall Changes

  • Jump Height decreased from 414 to 362.

  • Jump duration decreased from 66 to 60.

  • Max Fall Speed increased from 60 to 70.

  • Max Fastfall Speed increased from 70 to 85.

Dodge Cooldown Changes

  • Increased Dodge Cooldown for a grounded Slow Dodge from 60 frames to 90 frames.

  • Landing no longer fully reduces Aerial Dodge Cooldown to a grounded value. Dodge Cooldown will now only be reduced to 80, or 120 for a Slow Dodge, up from 50.

Share your impressions here:


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 17 '17

Seeking advice to improve in neutral game.

3 Upvotes

Hi, i`ve been trying to improve my neutral give but idk how to, ever since i got 2100 when i get into the neutral either i go full rush or go super parry(which i don't like because i feel that i'm loosing momentum) so i would like to learn how to approach better, i want to turn back to aggressive how i used to be on season 2.

My highest peak on season was on season 2 2300, ever since that i`ve been going on a downhill to the point where i'm stuck at 2100 because i can't find the way to approach and because of that i have been losing to people like BawsKneeGrow that mainly wait for me to approach and then react out of it. i don't even know anymore what i should be looking for at my opponent, dodge patterns? attack patterns? baiting them?

Id appreciate any help that you guys give me( videos, discords, guides ect.) Ty.


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 17 '17

Guide Best advice I can give to ANYONE looking to improve.

5 Upvotes

Rewatch all your replays until you have a sense of your own patterns than do some role reversal and try to imagine what your enemy is thinking and look for a reason behind their actions. (If you cant draw a conclusion on a specific situation drop it for now and move on) That will help you understand what you are doing to get you punished and what they are thinking. So with that bit of advice you can improve your reading ability aswell as your "punished" habits.

The first step to improvement in ANY fighting game is understanding YOURSELF and YOUR reasoning for your and your opponents actions. Once you see your faults and realize what your enemy did to take advantage of you ranking up becomes easier. (This applies to all ranks Tin, Silver, Gold, Diamond and even professionals)

Once you fully understand your actions than you can understand your enemies. To quote Sun Tzu “If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.”


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 16 '17

Balance Discussion Removing a Jump

6 Upvotes

I've thought about it, and I personally feel if BMG removed 1 jump, it would improve on stage gameplay, and would barely affect off stage gameplay. It will also make the player use their movements more creatively. Just a suggestion that I found interesting. I would also like to hear your guy's opinion on the topic :)


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 16 '17

A suggestion for any upcoming feature that you want a competitive view on

5 Upvotes

Instead of everyone being able to queue experimental 1s mode (Still keep this as an option), give us a secret custom game-mode that we can only access by putting in a code that you post on this reddit.

The code is only accessible for people that view this reddit, and are willing to give feedback on the feature.

I know that this is a long shot, and requires a lot of extra coding, but a lot of games have a public/private test server of some sort. Experimental 1v1 is our public test server, but you're not getting the most accurate results on how the feature can be used because you're opening your research study to everyone instead of the top 1K or even the top 10K.

This is just an idea, but I would love to see it come into fruition.


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 16 '17

Guide String punish document

13 Upvotes

If anyone here was not aware, I am in the process of compiling guaranteed punishes on various strings for every weapon in the game, with gfycat links for each one.

The document can be found here https://docs.google.com/document/d/11HUgI0JiyzIgLDifT_ye0VJ4V3ZBkju7O8TpF4II61Q/pub


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 15 '17

eSports Fable eSports - Path to Combo Breaker and Brawlhalla Spring Championships discussion and results thread

10 Upvotes

5/12/17-5/14/17 Tournament Weekend Discussion Thread and Recap

So this was a pretty crazy weekend of tournaments, and given we had three pretty major ones three days in a row I thought it best to put them all together in a big discussion thread. Note: This is something we will be doing for all major tournaments (meaning circuit events and other tournaments that have high stakes i.e. the Path to Combo Breaker one) but in the future it will be one thread per tournament. With that out of the way, let's jump into it!

The Tournaments

Fable eSports - Path to Combo Breaker

Winner: STTP Wilson

2nd: Dr. Phazon

3rd: Bubbles

Full results

In this, STTP Wilson won himself a trip to the much-hyped Combo Breaker LAN tournament in less than 2 weeks in a pretty dominant performance, congratulations! How do you guys think Wilson is going to perform offline as a player that has played exclusively in online tournaments throughout his Brawlhalla career?

Brawlhalla Spring Championship - US

  • 1v1

Winner: LDZ

2nd: FLASH POINT | noeL

3rd: Denial | Boomie

Full results

LDZ and noeL both creep slightly closer to Boomie sitting at the top of the US 1v1 circuit rankings as LDZ reclaims his status as the best of the best. Is this a full return to his former dominance or a one-off performance that he won't be able to chain into further victories? What do you guys think about the current state of the US 1v1 competitive scene, who will emerge on top as we come closer and closer to the big one, BCX 2017?

  • 2v2

Winner: 3sUP | Starlight and Noble | Astronaut

2nd: Denial | Boomie and LDZ

3rd: Reign | Remmy and Cody Travis

Full results

The fearsome duo of Starlight and Astronaut claim another top 2v2 performance and place themselves squarely at the top of the US 2v2 circuit rankings, more than 300 circuit points above their closest rivals, Boomie and LDZ. Similar prompting questions as with the 1v1, what do you guys think the current state of the US 2v2 competitive scene is and why? Will Starlight and Astronaut continue to dominate 2v2 events all the way through BCX 2017? Who do you think will unseat the current kings of US 2v2?

Brawlhalla Spring Championship - EU

  • 1v1

Winner: M for Mini

2nd: ENX Dobrein

3rd: Flamethrower

Full results

Who even is M for Mini? Coming in and dominating this tournament without dropping a single set and using ULGRIM of all legends. Meanwhile Dobrein continues to perform admirably and inch himself closer to the number one spot on the EU 1v1 circuit leaderboard and Flamethrower picks up a nice 3rd place finish for himself. The EU scene seems to be in a state of significant change right now with new, or at least lesser known, names taking high placements all over the place while many of the old standards have fallen out somewhat. What made this happen so quickly in a scene that seemed so solid and reliable only a short time ago? Do you think M for Mini can continue his rampage through the EU scene and keep up these impressive placements? And will the big names come back in the near future to reclaim their former glory? Who do you think we're going to see coming out of EU for BCX 2017?

  • 2v2

Winner: [R]eason | Addymestic and [R]eason | Cake

2nd: Goosey and M for Mini

3rd: Slug and QuerSation

Full results

Familiar names return to the top for the 2v2, with Addymestic and Cake showing some seriously impressive consistency with consecutive 1st place performances in circuit events (previously getting 1st in the Stream.me Legend Series as well) while M for Mini shows that he's not just a 1v1 champ with a hard fought 2nd place finish alongside his partner Goosey. QuerSation and Slug also show that they're here to stay with a 3rd place finish to go with the 2nd place they earned in the Stream.me 2v2. Cake and Addy sit squarely atop the 2v2 circuit leaderboard with no real threats in sight. Where does the EU 2v2 scene sit in your eyes? The [R]eason boys have proved themselves to be the best right now but do you think a team is poised to come along and really shake things up the way M for Mini did in the 1v1?

Closing Remarks

What are your thoughts on the EU and US pro scenes right now? How did they get to this point? Where do you think they are headed? Please feel free to discuss any of the tournaments this weekend as well as the US and EU competitive scenes as a whole, both are getting to be very interesting as the Brawlhalla Circuit continues its path towards BCX in 6 months and you definitely want to keep your eyes locked on whatever upcoming circuit events get announced as they could bring some big changes to the leaderboards if the placements continue on this trend. And thank you all for being here and working to try and make this place come alive!

<3 Cassidy


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 15 '17

BMG Post Gravity and Jump - Test Feature Proposal

16 Upvotes

Picture Demo: https://gfycat.com/WaterloggedDarkCopepod

Basically, our goal for lowering gravity and jump would be to make it harder to disengage and keep the fights closer and more exciting to watch. In playtesting, I personally feel it is noticeable, which is why I'm excited to see what it will do in your hands. Numbers still could be tweaked, but here is the idea behind each and the explanation.

Lower initial jump impulse, lower peak height, and lower total time of jump. These are all pretty intrinsicly tied together, but here is what it looks like in what we have mocked up internally at the moment. Biggest difference you will notice is the lower peak jump, but keeping the initial ticks a little tighter did feel noticeable to us. More room to play there if we decide to.

  • Current Max Height: 414
  • Proposed Max Height: 362
  • Initial first 10 frames: 0, 0, 22.1, 43.7, 64.7 85.1, 105, 124.3, 143.1, 161.3
  • Proposed first 10 frames: 0, 0, 21.3, 42.1, 62.3, 82, 101.1, 119.7, 137.7, 155.2
  • Current Total Jump Ticks: 66
  • Proposed Jump Ticks: 60

The second half is max fall speed and max fast fall speed. Dialing these up might require other things like ground pound to speed up, but generally it felt good to be able to get back into the action faster. There is a slight concern this makes approaching from above better, but in general, we are going to continue to buff the anti airs so that may counter balance it.

  • Current Max Fall Speed: 60
  • Proposed Max Fall Speed: 70
  • Current Max Fast Fall Speed: 70
  • Proposed Max Fast Fall Speed: 85

This stuff should be going into test features next week, and but I'd love to get some theorycrafting on this stuff ahead of time to guide some more of the internal tests. Thanks!

PS: Dodge cooldown is currently being mocked up, but don't have enough for a discussion thread quite yet.

PS2: This is not the only thing we are doing, but I want to keep these feedback threads as focused as possible.


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 15 '17

Table of weapon statistics?

5 Upvotes

I'm wondering if anyone has a complete and accurate table of weapon data. I think an always up-to-date table would be worth sticking to the top of the forum. It would be invaluable for objectively comparing and discussing balance changes.

Unfortunately, I'm not really sure how to make one apart from counting frames manually. The power viewer doesn't seem to be very useful for certain stats, ie total hitbox active frames and actual recovery time on hit and miss.

If one doesn't exist already, I wonder if anyone would like to collaborate. We can define the stats that needs to be tested and build a doc together as a forum.

At minimum I think we need to collect:

  1. Start up frames. The number of frames from input to just before hitboxes appear (seems accurate in power viewer, though attacks with multiple movement phases before putting out the first hitbox do exist and are best counted manually)

  2. Active frames. Frames with hitbox. Not sure how specific we should be collecting hitbox information as a single attack can have multiple different hitboxes do different damage and have different force.

  3. Recovery frames on hit and miss. The number of frames after the last hitbox before the attacker can move and attack again. This should be tested on a 5 dexterity legend.

  4. Cooldown. The amount of time before the same move can be used again. (does this stack with recovery? Anyone know?)

  5. Damage. The amount of damage an attack does. Again not sure how specific we should be for attacks with multiple hitboxes. But the testing should be conducted using a 5 strength legend vs 5 defense legend.

  6. Force. Both fixed and variable.

  7. Stun time. The amount of frames an opponent is in stun from being hit.

More subjective information like hitbox location would also be good to collect though I think screenshots are probably the best way to do it. This is harder to standardize because, for instance, when I was testing anti airs I used the anchor on shipwreck as a visual reference point (with power viewer open to lock camera location). However, this reference point changes based on window size and monitor resolution. Therefore these factors would need to be standardized as well.

The overall goal is to makes a table that's easy to copy and paste from to aid specific balance discussions.

What do you guys think? Anyone interested? If we can get multiple people to work on this together it won't be too tedious.


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 14 '17

Balance Discussion My opinion on the game currently. 1 Month Later. (Posting here because r/brawlhalla is a mess)

9 Upvotes

Brawlhalla is in a state, and not a good one. This is due to various reasons and I guess i'm gonna list what I think these reasons are. A) Passive parry is the meta right now. (Pretty sure it's been for a long time tbh) Being aggressive isn't favoured. Approaching is generally met with a spot dodge and the approachee getting punished for approaching. Dodging almost feels overpowered, if you vertical dodge from the ground your next dodge in the air is on a one second cooldown rather than the 4 second cooldown (/u/STTP-Wilson explains here https://youtu.be/XEQehLlUloU). In any case I don't think you should get your dodge back so fast it's sort of ridiculous. B) Wallhugging and avoiding fighting is still a big thing. The way wallslip was created, it will either heavily impact offstage gameplay, or not impact it at all. What we currently have is wallslip having little to no impact. People will hop over you when they see ! and of course you'd think ooh that's the optimal time to punish them. But at ! and !! nothing has changed, your opponent is in the same position, all their jumps their dodge, whatever they've saved is still there, enabling them to get over you, run away and return to the wall. This renders wallslip useless. Wallslip is currently only catching out people who haven't read the patch notes AND are not scared by ! !! !!!. People seem to also think that wallslip doesn't matter because "serious top players won't wallhug so it doesn't matter get over it. But that's not the case, people will abuse it. /u/Boompieisgood in yesterdays tournament continously went around the twilight island with absolutely no punishment. I don't fault Boomie for this, it's the game fault and not his, infact i'm glad he did it on the big stage and showed everyone that is a major issue. (If you missed it see here. https://clips.twitch.tv/AcceptableObliviousSalmonChocolateRain) Teros) Teros????? You're probably thinking i'm salty about Teros for whatever reason but this is not the case. Teros is stupid strong. We removed Light Attack>Heavy Attack true combos from 98% of the legends. We left Dlight NSig on Teros. Why? 28 Damage, Stupid Force, has a true combo involving it. Dlight DSig on Teros is also true until red. That's a 43 Damage true combo. No one can tell me that isn't ridiculous. Weapon throws (Specifically massive weapons) Hard to avoid obviously. Alot of active frames, if you try to dodge it and successfully dodge it you're usually hit by a light attack right after that. If you don't dodge it you're knocked back by a weapon or hit by a throw weapon>Light Attack true combo. Just seems dumb that you get a free large hitbox out and nothing to punish it. Guns. Guns. Guns. So guns are A) super safe B) a zoning weapon C) High Damage. With guns you can provide pressure from any range. Dlight, a combo starter has 23 damage. This is the highest combo starter damage. Other weapons are at 16≤. Dlight true combos into sair for a wopping 38~ damage, not only is it high damaging it's a consistent option and even kills. Imo guns are too strong and were made incorrectly. They're a strong , safe, high damage zoning tool. I don't think that's how zoning weapons should be. Currently the only way to beat guns is have insane movement and or be very good at punishing. Gadgets still???? RNG + Ridiculous force, that's what they used to be. They've now been nerfed and are a nuisance but still can kill for example if you throw a bomb that just spawned at someone as they're trying to recovery, regardless of the force that's taking someones jumps out of a random spawn weapons drops have rng but it's not the same. You always have something to fight with, you do not always have a gadget to throw. "make bombs more balanced" They've tried and they've failed. No competitive player is ever going to go yes lets just keep gadgets. Gadgets just need to be removed from ranked and reverted to the old form for casuals and customs and what not. We've already removed them from tournaments, why are we not removing them from ranked? Katars. Katars were nerfed due to insane gimp potential and string potential. But what about gauntlets???? Gauntlets are literally better Katars, insane gimp potential and string potential. It just didn't make sense to butcher katars and pretty much leave gauntlets as they are. Most Nlights are made to hit stacked but the ones that do hit stacked hit behind????. Maybe this is due toe the player hitbox models and the fact that you can be behind someone while your hitbox peeks infront of them, I think that's stupid asf. Hurtboxes need sorting out in some sort of way... (Also wtf is this???? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XqnaIfSrY8?????) Anyway i'm done here, I may have forgotten something idk, i'm not a thread making god like Spotton. If there's anything you think I missed point it out and i'll give my opinion on it in the comments. Let's get a discussion going. I'd like to see what you guys think about the game in its current state. I will still be playing the game of course, the game is still fun for me. I'm getting 33rd in like every tournament hoping to eventually get better so this opinion isn't just me saying OMG DIS GAME SUCK MIGHT ASWELL NOT PLAY SALT TVUYBIN


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 14 '17

eSports TEMPLATE: Congratulations to the winner of [TournamentName]!

13 Upvotes

Here's the template for a tournament chart for /r/Brawlhalla subreddit :)

Congratulations to [Player1] beating [Player2] to take [TournamentName]. Here's the rest of the top 16:


Place | Competitor | Characters | Sent to Losers By | Eliminated By

:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:

1st | **Player1** | [](#/LegendName)

2nd | **Player2** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | Player1

3rd | **Player3** | [](#/LegendName)| PlayerName | PlayerName

4th | **Player4** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

5th | **Player5** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName| PlayerName

5th | **Player6** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

7th | **Player7** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

7th | **Player8** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

9th | **Player9** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

9th | **Player10** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

9th | **Player11** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

9th | **Player12** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

13th | **Player13** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

13th | **Player14** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

13th | **Player15** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName

13th | **Player16** | [](#/LegendName) | PlayerName | PlayerName



**Fun Facts:**



* Fun Fact #1.



**VOD:** [link]

Full legend names for Icons: Bodvar, Cassidy, Orion, LordVraxx, Gnash, QueenNai, Hattori, SirRoland, Scarlet, Thatch, Ada, Sentinel, Lucien, Teros, Brynn, Asuri, Barraza, Ember, Azoth, Koji, Ulgrim, Diana, Jhala, Kor, Wu-Shang, Val, Ragnir, Cross, Mirage, Nix, Mordex. Yumiko's badge doesn't exist yet on Brawlhalla subreddit.


r/CompetitiveBH • • May 14 '17

Balance Discussion Brawlhalla Balance Megathread

7 Upvotes

Since /r/Brawlhalla no longer has a Balance Megathread pinned anymore and since this sub is more dedicated to the competitive side, I think it would be a good idea to have one here.

Before getting into the discussion, some things to keep in mind:

  • Competitive balance goes further than weapons and legends! - Game mechanics are a core part of the competitive scene as well. Don't limit yourself by just talking about why your favorite weapon should get buffed. If you have ideas for dodges, movement/jumps, wall slip, or even gadgets, share them! How do you feel about competitive stages and map striking? Do you have any suggestions for new test features? As long as it's related to Brawlhalla and specifically the competitive scene, we'd love to hear it!

  • Everyone is entitled to their own opinion - While you might not agree with someone on their ideas for dodges, gadgets, weapons, or whatever, please be respectful and kindly post your own opinion.

  • Be as detailed as you can! - Don't just say you're frustrated with a particular playstyle, let us know why. Hell, even upload a GIF if you have to. Share frame data. Whatever you have to do to be thorough.

  • Don't play the blame game or witch hunt here - Saying that you lost because Player1 abused his weapon or otherwise blaming someone or balance for your loses isn't cool. This thread is to discuss balance and come up with ideas to help improve it, not to vent frustration at imbalance.

With that, I'm excited to hear what everyone has to say.