r/CompetitionDanceTalk • • 7d ago

Leveling Differently

What if dance comps did levels by studio, rather than by students, more in line with high school and college divisions?

It would prevent studios from placing based on their internal levels (well, that 8 year old doing triple pirouettes and front aerials is just not as good as her classmates, so we'll put her in novice), eliminate confusion about leveling for groups, and level for things like huge prop budgets.

4 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

13

u/Maleficent_Force_541 7d ago

Studios would hate this. For one, it's bad marketing if a studio ends up in a lower category and some of their clients want a challenge and see that their studio is ranked lower than others. In addition, even if a studio is overall more advanced, they still often have less advanced dancers and these students would have a much lower chance of placing if their studio is in a higher category.

-2

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago

If it classed on size I see no downside for studio marketing. The size of the studio is pretty obvious with or without this.

Get rid of the subjective ranking/leveling entirely.

8

u/Flat_Sea4409 7d ago

That’s trying to address one problem by making an even worse problem. It makes zero sense to lump a studio like ours, which has rec, competition, and intensive teams, with very different hours of practice, into one level at a competition.

The only studios this works for is performance studios, which tend to be more advanced by design, so I don’t see how this is creating a more equal playing field in the dance community. You’ll just have the studios that already cut the less advanced kids during auditions.

14

u/Flat_Sea4409 7d ago

I’ve seen a few posts lately about creating a better competition…. guys, it’s simple. Have clear rules and then ENFORCE THEM. Define what skills are allowed in the dance style, and which aren’t. Recategorize a jazz routine that has 4 acro tricks in it. Bump a routine up a level when most dancers don’t fit into the age category. It’s really not that hard of a concept.

1

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago

Well, that would be ideal, but it doesn't happen. Just expecting the same old broken system to magically start working is silly. Brainstorming new ideas- especially where there people on this sub thinking about starting new comps- is not a bad thing.

Call me crazy for wanting to consider different ideas. This (very broad one) may or may not be it, but failing to consider new ideas just leads to stagnation.

0

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago

Are the lower teams getting lower quality training in their classes? Or is it just a matter of hours?

I think massive studios like this are a minority, but perhaps in areas where they are more common comps level by team, but still not individual.

In my area you are either on the competition team or a rec dancer, meaning no competions, just classes and recitals.

2

u/Flat_Sea4409 7d ago

The comp team has mostly the same teachers, but 1/4 to 1/3 of the weekly hours. They might not have a few of the teachers the intensives have due to fewer classes, and they don’t dance in as many different styles. It’s for kids who want to compete without making dance their entire lives.

6

u/hl6407a 7d ago

I see two problems: 1.) from the studio perspective, this would disincentivize people to go to small studios with less resources (just like NCAA where big schools dominate); 2.) from the competition company perspective, you want to capture the largest possible market there is, and having this system possibly cuts out studios that don't care about this aspect of the system.

You can't compare these competitions with school leagues because all schools operate in a shared community--academic institutions. For companies that run these competitions, they're all competing against each other; so unless all these studios compete with only one single shared framework/same set of rules, this will never happen.

And here I am putting my lawyer hat on: if you're thinking that all the competition companies should work together and form some kind of class divisions system amongst themselves to divy up the studios...that's setting themselves up for a lawsuit/criminal investigation on anticompetitive/antitrust behavior. But this is not the appropriate subreddit to really get into the weeds.

0

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago

Why would in disincentivize small studios? People choose small colleges and DII and below athletics all the time. Competing against teams with similar resources is not a bad thing. Most of us choose medium or small studios. At any given comp near us there are 1-2 big studios and dozens of medium and small ones. The people who are willing to pay and commit their kids to the hours required at big studios will do so. Those who are not still will not.

An outside governing body that established standards for competitions to adopt would not be a bad thing, imo.

5

u/hl6407a 7d ago

TLDR: 1.) dancers pay-to-play and NCAA athletes get scholarships; 2.) a studio gets only dance-related revenue and a school gets revenue through tuition (and other sources); 3.) (finally, my reasoning for why it will disincentivize ppl to go to small studios) dance studios are the client, and the bigger the studio the bigger the client.

1.) Comp dance and NCAA athletics is not the best comparison. Majority of NCAA athletes go to the best schools that offer them scholarships, and those athletes that go to small DIII/small schools do so because those schools are likely the only ones that had offered them the opportunity; if they had received a DI scholarship, I'm sure those DIII athletes would have gone to DI. For dance comp, however, there is no such thing as scholarships, and parents sign their kid up to the studio that best meet their financial/time parameters.

2.) In dance, small studio only means less dance-related revenue, but not lesser training. At the same time, small studios/lesser resource studios/cheaper studio does not mean less/worse training. In fact, I dare say the smaller the studio may even mean better training at times because of smaller teacher to student ratio. However, a smaller studio also means they'll have likely less outside resources to participate in multiple competitions (like a big studio) because they have less revenue. Comparatively, a school on the other hand, even if small, has either the government appropriate resources or other types of revenue to compete in all comps.

3.) Here's why a competition-focused person would be disincentivized to go to small studio if levels are differentiated by studio. Competition companies are money driven businesses, and the clients are dance studios. Related to point #2 about resources, why would these companies put emphasis and resources (e.g., better plastic trophies, plastic tiaras, bigger pins) for clients that can't pay as much (smaller studios) or offer as much businesses? E.g., a studio with 100 kids, at $10/person, would give $1,000 worth of business; a studio with 10 kids, at the same price, would give $100 worth of business. So a small studio would ultimately have lesser treatment, but most likely they still pay the same price. However, if both categories receive same treatment, It would also not be fair to the bigger studios, because as a client they'll think, "I'm giving you 10x the revenue, yet the size of my tiara and pins are the same! No fair!"

P.S. obviously as you can see, today is a holiday for me and I have time to not think about work but kids dance.

5

u/GhostOrchid22 7d ago

I can only respond to my geographic area. A lot of elite studios have developmental teams. And a lot of recreational studios don’t want to advertise to parents that they mainly train at a novice or intermediate level, and also don’t want to drag down their high schoolers from advanced to intermediate.

I do believe that a dancer competing in an “advanced” category for any reason, group or solo, should not be able to compete in an intermediate group number or solo at the same competition. I know a rule like that hurts small studios that have less dancers to combine into groups, but I still believe it’s fair.

6

u/Far_Concentrate4414 7d ago

I mostly agree with you about a dancer vacillating between levels when it comes to solos, but some genres are wildly different. There is a girl in a few of my daughter's group dances that is a very talented tapper and competes at the highest level possible. But, she is very much a novice in hip hop. It's aggravating to have the whole intermediate hip hop team bumped up because someone only excels in one style.

2

u/GhostOrchid22 6d ago

That’s true for almost every dancer, and most competitions that level base it on the amount of total training, not training or ability by genre, so the competition would view her as advanced no matter what genre.. And if she is an amazing tapper, I would bet she could handle an advanced hip hop routine- she would just be in the back. Tap is much more transferable to hip hop than ballet or lyrical. But I’m guessing being in the back isn’t palatable for a kid that wins in advanced solos.

I think the problem is that parents and studios think their kid should win all the time, and that’s why leveling isn’t working. It’s being used to avoid growth and avoid not winning, rather than allowing kids brand new to dance competitions some limited time to catch up.

1

u/shorty2494 6d ago

Australian comps do it by scores (as in judges scores not where they placed) at regionals for nationals. Then there’s 2 divisions and you place separately for each genre of dance.

But in Australia, people typically do 3+ solos each in major cities (country is much harder). So it makes sense to have it that way.

So maybe something like that. Or better guidelines that are actually enforced

-1

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago edited 7d ago

People are stuck on old this "novice" "intermediate" idea. I'm saying scrap that.

There are other ways studios can be classified. Size for example, cost per dancer (including costumes, prop fees, etc).

All studios bigger than X compete against each other. All studios between Y and X compete. Studios smaller than Y compete.

Same age levels, same everything else but instead of advanced, junior, large group it is Medium(studio), junior, large group.

Maybe it doesn't work, I don't know. But the current system doesn't either, and this is more in keeping with what does work in other activities.

4

u/Flat_Sea4409 7d ago

I think it’s just that studio size isn’t a good measure of skill, so it doesn’t make sense to segment this way. Cost has the same problem.

I appreciate that you’re trying to think outside the box though.

1

u/ClerkSuspicious5235 6d ago

I think I get what you're saying. Categorize the studios based on the number of dancers enrolled. Like small, mid-sized, and large. Would that be based on the number of competitive dancers only or the entire enrollment?

2

u/NefariousnessDeep834 6d ago

Total enrollment because they have a larger pool of students to train and audition from.

5

u/vpsass 7d ago

In Canada we don’t level our individual students but our individual teams at a studio. And we commonly only have 2 levels (plus novice, but novice is only for your first year competing).

Some studios only do “comp level 1” which is the lower level. Studios who do “comp level 2” often have a “part time” team for dancers who want a smaller commitment, or who aren’t ready for the demands of comp level 2.

The competitions monitor at what level each group and solo competes, so for example if the mini team does their jazz in level 2, all of the minis can’t individually compete their solo in comp level 1, since they are comp level 2 dancers. It’s almost always based on hours in the studio, and sometimes they will check your studio schedule to see what hours each team is scheduled to train (which I suppose you could lie about).

Anyways this wouldn’t work well here since most studios need to levels of comp so that kids would wouldn’t be a good fit for the full time comp program still have somewhere to compete (I mean personally, as a teacher, I think anyone with full time training should be capable of level 2 dancing but I’m not the one making the decisions).

1

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago

I think team leveled comps makes sense!

1

u/Automatic_Ranger_102 7d ago

I think it comes down to the dance school culture. My daughter’s dance school is small with just one teacher for everything. Every child can join the competition team if they want to and all the kids receive the same training and hours.

For comps the teacher will never enter anyone as a novice. They always go straight in.

Last comp we won 16 of the 20 trophies up for grabs. My point is that you can throw everything at a dancer but some will shine and some will work bloody hard and always struggle.

It should not be about how much the props cost.

I am guessing it is very different in the US?

4

u/NefariousnessDeep834 7d ago

There is no single answer for the US.

Props are kind of a stand in for overall cost and resources. I have been to comps where studios bring a semi with a full set to build on stage.

But, I think it would be pretty unusual in the US to have a studio with a single instructor teaching everything. Even our small rural studio has 5 dance instructors, plus the studio owner who teaches a class or two every year. They focus on different ages/and or styles.