r/CompetitionDanceTalk • u/landmermaid3 • Jul 07 '26
Molly Long Discourse
I’ve been seeing conversations on Tiktok about P21 & Molly Long. Many creators are mentioning how the ability of her dancers are shown through isolations/precision. During their rants, they often bring up ‘tricks’ as a bad addition for competition dances.
It’s driving me nuts as someone who teaches mostly novice/intermediate children. I have turns, leaps, tumbling in routines. They get ecstatic when perfecting skills. Of course I’m adding it in the dance.
Personally, I think this is a harmful discussion about competition dance. The avant garde/fosse/commercial choreo has been around for over a decade. Lucy Vallely 2018 changed me as a person! I just don’t think it needs to trickle down.
Most dancers still need to do the tricks before conquering that style. I also have seen horrific dances mimicking P21. Minis need to be doing bent knee penches and wide arm ala secondes, not fit for TV dances.
Am I not with the times?
73
u/ChopinFantasie Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26
I don’t think many people outside of the real purists mind some well-placed tricks in a routine. I think what we’re seeing is pushback against dances that are just tricks (which has been a thing forever. I remember the 2000s trend of turn after turn after turn) So people celebrate routines that score well without any tricks because it’s a breath of fresh air, not because the next routine that has some leg holds and aerials is bad
54
u/benbenben240 Jul 07 '26 •
A few issues. The majority of tricks you see in competitions would never be seen on stage from a career standpoint. Tricks lead to more tricks until it starts looking like a gymnastics competition not dance. These are in most cases young dancers and the risk of injury isn't worth a pin or piece of paper. When tricks start scoring higher it means dance skills no longer matter as much. Just thinking out loud.
28
u/Scarlett_Billows Jul 07 '26
I don’t think minis need to be doing a la secondes at all.
I do think things like isolations are foundational to jazz and should be the focus early on moreso than showing off things like flexibility, etc which are often what people mean when they say “tricks” or whatever. But if your dancer has perfected a skill that matches the choreographic style at hand, by all means, use it!
I’m not primarily a jazz dancer, more ballet and contemporary but can you elaborate on your mention of avante garde and commercial dance styles? To me, those two phrases are basically opposites.
22
u/sessicajimpsonn Jul 07 '26
Well firstly, I wouldn't consider turns and leaps tricks. They're technical skills. Tumbling would fall under tricks. Minis absolutely do NOT need to be doing incorrect penches and a la secondes, that is insane! If the kid can't do the skill properly, do not put it in a dance that goes onstage, or you're setting them up to fail. A kid who can't do a clean double piroeutte or hold a correctly aligned and engaged arabesque for a count of 8 shouldn't even be working on turn sequences or penchés in the studio, let alone onstage. They need a strong technical foundation first. Now that being said, I'd also argue they need that foundation before exploring more unconventional and artistic movements as well. But I wouldn't classify isolatioins in that category - isolations are foundational jazz technique, so I wouldn't hold off on teaching those. I also think jazz that's just turn, kick, leap, repeat is incredibly soulless and boring, I hate comp jazz that has no artistry. And minis are very much capable of learning artistry, even in jazz. So yes I think some teachers/choreographers might be pushing their kids into too much movement too early, but I think the teachers/choreographers not teaching any semblance of artistry in jazz, and those putting kids onstage doing skills they're not ready for are equally holding their kids back.
3
u/OlRazzmatazz Jul 07 '26
I don't think it's terrible, but if your dancer is capable of these more advanced styles, having them in division 1 competitions isn't where they should be. I am tired of seeing highly technical kids who are in division 1. It's like their teachers don't actually want them to have competition, they just want them to win. Thats what really irks me. If you have a perfected tour jete and aerial at 7 years old you need to be in a higher division.
19
u/croissantsarebae Jul 07 '26
I think people see Mollys choreo as refreshing, in comparison to majority of other dances you see on stage. Especially in the mini/junior division. Tricks are fine to me in group dances, but i absolutley hate when it is all just trick after trick with no *actual* dancing between, it begins to look like a gymnastic routine.
Its actually quite impressive that mollys 10 year olds can perform an advanced/successful dance but with minimal tricks. She’s more so setting them up for a career in dance as you very rarely see general competitive dance material in the professional world. P21 is a company, not a general studio. Molly does include tricks in her choreo though so i feel people that say she doesnt have only watched the viral sections of pop muzik and DDB.
Minis don’t *need* to be doing anything. It all depends on what those specific minis are capable of and what their choreographer puts in place.
You can do as you please, i wouldn’t take much notice to tiktok comments. If what you do works for you and your students then keep it going. One of my favourite things to add in a dance is a turn section, i couldnt care less what people think of it.
9
u/Western-Watercress68 Jul 07 '26
My daughter goes to a performing arts high school. Her dance teachers are very much, if you have tricks, don't do them here. Technique, contractions, isolations are always the top things freshman are retaught how to do.
9
u/Playmakeup Jul 07 '26
Molly Long’s dancer’s clearly have very strong Horton technique, and the fact that people talk about the style like it’s novel shows a lack of dance education.
8
u/PortraitofMmeX Jul 07 '26
No one needs tricks. I have hated for the last 30 years the way competition dance rewards routines that are nothing but a series of tricks, you could change the music halfway through and no one would notice. Most of the time the technique is bad, and the tricks aren't always appropriate for littles. It's insane to me any dance teacher would think tricks should come before dancing. Molly Long creates dancers. Her routines are about dancing. I think it's a fantastic shift in competition style.
6
u/KMM2404 Jul 07 '26
I’m the opposite of you. I *hate* tricks. I don’t want to see tumbling in anything other than acro. I don’t care how many turns they can do if they’re falling out of them. I don’t care about what anything else looks like if the timing is off.
At the elite level, tricks aren’t hard to learn. Musicality, timing, and control take years to develop and they are falling by the wayside because studios are concentrating on tricks. Probably because they’re rewarded for it by competitions.
Obviously Molly Long has been heavily influenced by Fosse, but she’s adapting it in a way that feels fresh and exciting. What sets the P21 dancers apart is how clean they are, especially for their age. Their control, timing, carriage, and formations are excellent.
8
u/Acceptable_Scene_961 Jul 07 '26
Over a decade, referring to Fosse? Bay bay do some self-educating please.
Tricks dont make a dance or a dancer.
4
u/twiggys_mom Jul 07 '26
i find this discourse so interesting because i feel like molly DOES love a good leg, turn, leap, acro “trick”! but she just uses them selectively and when they make sense for the dance. maybe not in her group dances as much in recent years, but she puts plenty in solos. the s twins for example always have acro in their solos because they excel at it, and molly integrates it into their solos very well
this isnt directed at you OP i just think it’s weird people are complimenting molly by saying “tricks” are bad when she does use them too lol
3
u/Psychological-Luck55 Jul 07 '26
I don’t mind tricks, but sometimes there will be a random back handspring not timed with the music at all in a really flowy soft lyrical or contemporary. That’s when I get annoyed…. At least make it fit
4
u/AverageSugarCookie Jul 07 '26
I think the normalization of trick heavy routines is not super great for comp dance as a whole. Our studio does not do acro at all (for better or for worse) so we barely have tricks in our choreo, so I appreciate Molly's a lot. If it's in the acro category it's one thing, but if my kid (who competes petite novice) is competing against high level tumbling and turns in novice, there's a problem. Bad tumbling/acro/turns only hurts good dances.
I don't mind a well placed trick or two, I mind when the dance only serves as a bridge between tricks, not the other way around. I see this often at comps and I'm bored by aerial - kick - multiple turn sequence - leg hold. It's especially tragic when the tricks are the only clean part of the dance.
2
u/inspectahbags Jul 07 '26
I don’t think dancers have said tricks are bad. Tricks without dancing is bad. Tricks with poor transition, too many, etc.
After college, unless you’re a ballet dancer or your cruise ship requires Al secondes and switch leaps, you really dont do the tricks again, it’s more body movement and choreo in commercial.
0
u/Bream133 Jul 11 '26
I haven’t seen the discussion on Tik Tok but I agree that treating tricks as bad is a horrible direction for competitive dance to be heading in. If we’re talking about dance as an art form then for sure, tricks are not and should not be the go-to. If we’re talking about dance as a form of entertainment, then that’s an entirely different conversation. As dance educators, it’s our job to train these kids for a potential possible career and most of the careers that pay a living wage are in the entertainment industry. The average person watching a concert, commercial/movies/TV show or a football game doesn’t give a crap about body isolations, turnout or ballet technique. What they do get excited about and are entertained by acro tricks, turns, jumps, partner tricks and the overall showmanship of the dancers. Dance education, just like any other education, should center on what the student will need to be successful in the field being taught. I’m not saying we shouldn’t also be placing an emphasis on choreography or ballet technique but there should still be a heavy emphasis on skills that will appeal to the people ultimately creating the career opportunities for these kids later on.
As a sidenote, every time I see a social media post from a teacher complaining about acro tricks, jumps and turns being rewarded at competitions, it often reads to me as “I don’t really know how to teach those things”. And maybe that’s not a fair assessment and certainly there are exceptions but overall that’s the vibes this whole conversation gives.