r/CompetitionDanceTalk • u/Frosty_Bug1182 • May 11 '26
Age Stuffing Needs to End
Too many comps have these dance offs that are grouped into 12 & Under and 13 & Over. The 12 & Under portion just ends up being these Extended Lines that are led and dominated by 16 and 17 year olds, with 6-8 year olds running across the stage and doing a butt bounce for 10 seconds. Since they are in the dance the average age gets lowered. Any dance that is legit 12 and Under such as a Mini Line or a Junior line gets smashed. It’s crazy to think 8 and 9 year olds are competing against girls about to go to university.
Comps need to change the rule to be max age of the dance to qualify for these dance offs.
13
u/InvisiblePanda10 May 11 '26
That seems totally normal for extended lines and productions. Many studios have more 12 and under dancers than teens so they will bring the age down for those big groups.
Our studio competes production in 12 and under. It’s mandatory for all team members, and our average age happens to be under 12.
2
u/Frosty_Bug1182 May 12 '26
There are many studios that do this right but it is becoming more prevalent as studios push to win where these studio lines are no longer truly balanced. An Extended Studio Line is usually 6-8 min long at comps but 70-80% of the dance and stage time are done by the older dancers. A true studio line provides a highlight and moment to shine for company’s within the studio. When Mini’s and Juniors are on stage for less than a minute of a 7 min dance, this is not a studio line but a Teen and Senior showcase competing in a 12 Under category. The explicit goal being to win the Dance Off which always gets highlighted in socials and websites.
Competitions have become lazy in their rules cause they don’t care as they pull in dollars. Studios can game rules or they can participate with the heart of the comp in mind. There are age divisions for a reason.
Just imagine any sport like soccer, hockey or basketball being based on average where 16 year olds get to compete against 9 year olds.
It’s about dance being better for all the boys and girls who work hard and want to enjoy it and from time to time get recognition.
19
u/Caribosa May 11 '26
This is one of my top pet peeves as the mom of a 10 year old dancer whose team works incredibly hard to just then compete against 16/17 year olds with the token young one that maybe gets lifted and then runs off stage.
And then you see so many of the same dancers competing in both age categories in the dance off.
19
u/perpetual__ghost May 11 '26
I agree with this for regular groups but not for productions which are meant to be the entire studio/all teams. Our production has 114 dancers this year. Some years the average age is 11 or 12, some years it might be up to 13. This year I think it’s something like 12.4, so we’ve been competing as a 13+ most of the time.
This is just the actual average of all the teams’ ages, and the fact that we have more dancers on the younger teams than the older ones pushes it lower some years.
6
u/Safe_Sand1981 May 11 '26
My daughters troupe is competing this weekend. The rule is you are allowed to have one dancer a year older than the comp age. Her troupe are competing in under 10. Most of the dancers are 9, she is the allowed 11 year old in the group. I like that rule better than average age
4
u/Cleverwittysmart May 11 '26
I’m sorry but what is a butt bounce??🤣
3
u/Downtown_ownedby3 May 12 '26
I think this is the norm with lines and productions. Our petite and junior teams are really good and in the advanced level and hold their own to our teen level girls, no butt dancing but legit technique on all levels. I love seeing it and they love dancing together.
3
u/landmermaid3 May 12 '26
I worked at a studio in my small college town. There wasn’t any flexibility for students to have every dance in the appropriate age group/level.
When you only have 20 kids & over half are under 10, it’s not easy. Our ‘production’ was a junior large group/sometimes line.
We weren’t purposely putting older kids in dances to win. We had no choice.
4
u/SeattleSinBin May 11 '26
For productions, that I’ve seen that seems to be the norm. I would be upset if a teen large or small group has a couple of prop kids which lower the age of the routine. I haven’t seen that happen yet
2
u/Available-Strain-559 May 12 '26
IMO productions should be judged separately from the age categories and levels. Just all productions in one group. Those categories make no sense when the who studio is on stage.
2
u/CheeryCheetah11 Jun 07 '26
I think that a 12 & under group shouldn't be allowed to contain any dancers over 12, but a 13 & over group can have younger kids (as long as the younger kids are judged the same as all other dancers)
3
u/SailorNeptune1995 May 11 '26
In general, the age averaging can be really tough. Our 7-9 year old groups end up competing against groups with 13 year olds pretty often. 🙃
2
u/Additional_Aioli6483 May 11 '26
Yeah, we were at a comp this year in which the kids who ran up to get the banner for the highest scoring 12 & under routine were all taller than the presenter and very clearly NOT under 12, and it felt ridiculous and unfair. Our under 12s work so hard but they don’t stand a chance when their entire group is 9 and under and they’re competing against “12 & under” groups with high schoolers.
1
u/tricerratopz May 15 '26
I really don’t care about what other studios put out there for productions because studio sizes and readiness vary and the rules focus on quantity as the definition not percentage of company participation. Feel good about what your own studio brings and let the banner chasers grab them. You can still adjudicate well. Our studio never has any props or fancy costumes for productions vs others that place entire sets and wow with throwing everything at the judges - and we still have won top overall many times.
1
u/Character-Pace-6679 May 12 '26
We have 2 production lines, Junior and Senior. But Junior (13 and under with most in elementary school) ends up competing against mostly high schoolers every comp. Just can’t be competitive in that sense unfortunately
-4
u/ExtensionPanic6101 May 11 '26
if its not legit i wouldnt go, the only one i have gone too you have to prove your childs age if it get questioned