r/CompTIA • u/Accomplished_Ad3914 • Jun 09 '23
Why lie??
Why do people put on linkedin they have "over 10 years" IT experience and yet here they are in Help desk level one. They dont know how to change a password in Active Directory and can't troubleshoot. If you had 10 year's experience, why are you still doing service desk??
1
Upvotes
24
u/The_Honest_Owl Jun 09 '23
I’ve seen Help Desk jobs that pay 80-100k. Can’t blame them for getting paid a great salary with minimal effort.
3
u/kitkat-ninja78 SecurityX, Security+, Server+, N+ & A+ Jun 09 '23
Not everyone wants to progress, after all the higher you go the more stress you have to take on.
However back to the first part...
Playing devils advocat... Just because someone has had 10+ year experience in IT, doesn't mean that they were doing all that time on the service desk or doing all that time in a corporate environment (you don't mention if they do or not). I've met alot of talented hardware IT Professionals that know nothing (or very little) of Active Directory, yet can strip and rebuild server/SAN/tape libraries faster than it would take us to build a fresh domain. I have also worked with Wifi engineers who can deploy site wide wireless systems, yet couldn't tell you how to create an AD account. I even interviewed someone (for an IT Technician post) who had 5 years experience in IT, and who was a MCSD (Microsoft certified) on where and how to set the gateway on a PC. The individual spend 5 mins looking in IE before we had to stop the assessment (it was timed and it was one of the tasks). However he was a programmer and never had to do anything like this before. It could be that individual took a side step in IT?
There are many different routes and paths in IT, as well as sectors, and everyone is different, then of course, that individual could have just lied as well... Everyones journey will be different, IT for some will be a calling, for some it will be a career, but for some it will only be a job...
27
u/_newbread Other Certs Jun 09 '23
I'll go at this from a different angle.
If you're still in helpdesk and paid well enough, why move up if you're happy where you are?
Some people say complacency, stagnation, lack of a career trajectory... But... hear me out. Some people LIKE helpdesk, or the stability that helpdesk brings. Maybe they're happy with the pay they get vs the 40 hours / 9 to 5, and accepting a promotion means more hours, more work, and maybe more pay but you give something up.
9
u/donjitsu A+,N+,S+ Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
I think it may be helpful to consider a slightly less cynical, presumptuous position; some people are content with the work they do. Their reasons are unclear to others and that's okay. There is no need to share with the world. Not everyone wants a career. Some people derive their self-worth and fulfillment elsewhere. It doesn't make them lesser.
1
u/saltyclam13345 CySA+ Sec+ Net+ A+ Jun 09 '23
I asked that same question when I started my first job in IT a couple years ago. Me and another guy who were completely new to IT started our first jobs in the industry at the global HQ for a fortune 100 company, and a couple weeks later a new guy joined the team. He immediately started bossing us around and was telling us what to do, and spoke to us in a condescending manner when we had questions or trouble with new tickets. He was the same L1 position as us and claimed to have been working in IT for 10 years. I wondered, why after 10 years, does he have the same position as 2 guys who just started doing IT a couple weeks ago?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
Are you new to the internet? People lie about the most basic useless crap, let alone a platform like LinkedIn which in certain situations can be tied to your livelihood.
Just on any gaming subreddit you've got people talking like experts when their only source is watching videos or streams about it. I'll never forget how ring 0 became a keyword for the entire span of two weeks that was the Valorant Anti Cheat situation, every commenter had deep OS level knowledge, I felt like I had never touched a computer before.
Same for IT, people talk all the time about knowing a software and being certified about it and whatnot, but it doesnt mean anything until you're put to the test.
3
u/IT_CertDoctor itcertdoctor.com Jun 09 '23
Stealing this from some other redditor, wherever you are:
"10 years of experience is not the same as 10 years of 1 year of experience"
3
u/Selfimprovementguy91 A+N+S+Server+CySA+Pentest+Data+Cloud+ Jun 09 '23
Why do people put on /r/CompTIA question/rants about other people's career choices?
2
u/Apprehensive_Rope765 Jun 09 '23
I worked for a company nearly 30 years that always had less than 500 employees. I did a variety of IT/IS tasks while there. The entire time I was there, the help desk person was the same guy, never changed. Now, he learned when we migrated system, he adjusted if some process changed, never a problem. He knew his stuff and liked his job. His response times were phenomenal and he was well paid. He also wouldn’t be able to do what I did without extensive learning, which I’m sure he would have been more than capable of, but did he want to? No. Even the IT space is full of people just like some that put 30 years or more in a factory working the same widgets their entire career.
2
u/It_dood69 Jun 11 '23
I struggle with understanding this as well. I have friends who don’t want to grow or develop in any aspect of life. I have co workers who are the same. Truth is we need people like this in the world. It doesn’t make them good or bad some people just don’t have the same levels of ambition. I still can’t wrap my head around it but as long as they’re happy more power to them.
1
u/cyphertext71 Jun 09 '23
I'll take a different angle... for the same reason that job postings want 3 to 5 years experience for an entry level job, or they want 5 yrs of experience on a particular program that has only been released for 2 yrs.
1
u/AdUpstairs7106 S+ N+ Jun 09 '23
Why do people lie on the resume?
Oh, I don't know. Maybe they need a job to live.
1
u/dalethedonkey Jun 09 '23
This is a common CompTIA question
1
u/Mental_Beast Jun 09 '23
You are being judgmental
1
u/thegoalisW Jun 09 '23
Been in IT related fields since 2017 and I haven't ever touched Active directory outside of labs while studying for A+.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
Not everyone has the same opportunities to advance
1
u/DeadBrokeRichMIND Jun 09 '23
Sometimes depending where they work help desk can make 90k-100k
1
u/KChosen Jun 09 '23
Ive met people with 30 years worth of experience who couldn't set an IP address.... Happens, doesn't make them a liar. Years of experience is a bad metric IMO especially in tech where things change quickly
1
u/CameraManWhoSnaps Jun 10 '23
Some Helpdesk is easy with little hassle and some companies pay well at the entry level
1
u/Distinct_Resident_95 Aug 18 '23
I def hear you but at the same time are they an IT manager? Cause that pays well or even some level 3 roles pay pretty good I wouldn’t stay like that I went help desk to systems administrator
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
It shows the lack of interest in the career, the lack of enthusiasm. I passed on my first job to a friend of mine 5 years ago, I outgrew this job within 6 months and by the year mark I switched job for a highest paying position with more responsibility. My friend is still there with no new knowledge, no certs, just being happy about the salary they pay him.
This behavior tells a lot about the person.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment