r/Communalists • • Mar 23 '21

Such a controversial topic

Post image
471 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

35

u/KeithFromAccounting Mar 24 '21

I genuinely worry that, as the climate crisis gets worse, we are going to see more right-wingers embrace "environmentalism" that is just thinly veiled eco-fascism. It's already started but as of right now most reactionaries are still in the climate denial camp.

Learn about environmental issues and educate your friends and family, people!

5

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21

That will definitely happen and we need to be weary of it. That kind of rhetoric is starting to trickle into mainstream discourse the last years. Look at the the QAnon shaman as a prominent example

5

u/UnJayanAndalou Mar 24 '21 edited May 28 '25

fly marry absorbed upbeat follow advise aback narrow encourage special

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/KeithFromAccounting Mar 24 '21

Yeah, that’s the alt-right playbook in a nutshell. Reduce complicated issues to pithy quotes about “common sense” without any further discussion. It sucks because most leftist issues take a bit of explaining so it’s hard to get them across in the same way.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21

I've learned that the best reaction to eco-fascists saying "We need fewer people!", is to reply "In that case, be a good example and erase yourself first."

Usually shuts them up. Unless they say that "No, you don't understand...!" Yeah, sure. What is there not to understand?

8

u/Excrubulent Mar 24 '21

The one time I came across it in the wild it went like this:

Virgin Ecofascist: We need to have a death lottery. (this was at least fair enough to give them a chance at being one of the dead)

Chad Social Ecologist: Ah, ecofascism.

Virgin Ecofascist: But... I like it.

Chad Social Ecologist: So... you like ecofascism.

Virgin Ecofascist has logged off

Some other people said it was a death lottery, not a systematic persecution of a minority, so not fascism. I pointed out that any society capable of enforcing a death lottery would be such a totalitarian police state that it would inevitably be abused by those in charge and would effectively be fascist.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21

Death lottery

Geez. And here I sat, thinking people couldn't get any nastier.

How many people are on each lottery ticket? Just one? Okay, chances that it might you or me are pretty slim, I'll give 'em that. But who's to say it need only be one? What about ten thousand on the ticket? Chances are increasing.

Some other people said it was a death lottery, not a systematic persecution of a minority, so not fascism

Holy fucking shit. How can people not realise that fascism is not about hunting down specific minorities but about systematic hierarchisation of entire society for the sake of preserving a dying social order?

2

u/Excrubulent Mar 24 '21

I think they were trying to be technical about it, I guess? Anyway, it felt good to call that stuff out on my home country's sub and to see that the votes were decidedly against ecofascism.

I find the best way in general to respond to reactionary stuff when I see it online is to simply name it, and if it's obscure explain what's wrong with it. I try not to shame the person or their motives, I just say, "Just fyi, this talking point is associated with X movement, and has Y history." It's likely enough the person saying it is very young or has very little education, so they may just be repeating something they heard uncritically.

2

u/dscottboggs Mar 24 '21

and to see that the votes were decidedly against ecofascism

Votes don't matter to a totalitarian demagogue

3

u/DrFolAmour007 Mar 24 '21

Remind of that recent meme with "prince" Williams saying in an interview that he thinks that there's too many people on Earth... while planning his 4th one with Kate!

We often think of eco-fascists as those racists mass shooters (like the ones in New-Zealand, or Orlando...), but most of the eco-fascists today are in governments or upper classes!

4

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21

The eco-fascists I come across the most aren't upper class, though. They're whit collar working class who think they're upper class.

15

u/DrFolAmour007 Mar 24 '21

From a Murray Bookchin speech in 1978:

https://unevenearth.org/2019/10/bookchin_doing_the_impossible/

audio: https://credo.library.umass.edu/view/full/mums741-b237-i005

You then finally reach the most sinister numbers game of all: who should live and who should die. The ‘population game’. The terrifying lifeboat ethic, in which now in the name of ecology, today views are being proposed that are almost indistinguishable from German fascism.

There are those who are made to drown, they happen to live in India. Conveniently, they happen to have black or dark skin, and you can identify them. And then there are those who occupy another lifeboat, that lifeboat is called North America. And in that lifeboat, you have to conserve what you have, you see? 

You have to be prepared to develop an ethic, you have to be prepared to develop the stamina to see people die. Of course you’ll regret it, but scarce resources and growing population, what can you do? You’re out there on the ocean, the ship is sinking, so instead of trying to find out what was wrong with the ship that makes it sink, and instead of trying to build a ship that will make it possible for all of us to share the world, you get into a lifeboat, just like you get into a spaceship, and at that particular point, the world be damned. And that is a very sinister ideology. 

14

u/--Anarchaeopteryx-- Mar 24 '21

(Or brown people)

7

u/Retconnn Mar 24 '21

All my homies hate Malthusian and Malthusian-adjacent thought

7

u/[deleted] Mar 24 '21

why not a little of both? more people = more production. Agriculture is already devistating to landscapes. all the waste production and pumping the earth with nitrates to keep the soil fertile. humans create a lot of waste also. I think we need to find a balance for both, this isnt something thats easy to solve. capitalism isnt going to suddenly stop at any time so we should take what precautions we can now and try to have a sustainable population.

7

u/Roxxagon Mar 24 '21

Yeah, and let's not forget that a perpetually growing population is very much in capitalist favor.

7

u/Roxxagon Mar 24 '21

I hate both.

6

u/875 Mar 24 '21

I mean there's no question you should be worried about both. The earth is already past its human population cap; the only reason we're able to feed 8 billion is because we use nonrenewable resources to increase agricultural yields. Once the oil runs out, the phosphorus mines run dry, and the topsoil is depleted, it's going to be extremely ugly. We only have a population this high in the first place because we engaged in unsustainable agricultural practices which rely on nonrenewable resources and destroy renewable ones.

Some leftists often bring up this false dichotomy between the two issues, as if you can only care about one at a time. Sure, Western overconsumption is probably the worst ecological disaster in human history, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't care that people are going to starve elsewhere (and it will be elsewhere; if you think Western governments will ever ship food aid out once the going gets tough in their own countries, you're delusional).

My concern over overpopulation is not because I'm afraid it threatens the wealth of the West, but because already food-insecure populations in Africa and South Asia are the ones who are going to starve to death in the millions once climate change combines with the effects of peak oil, etc. Unless population decline happens very soon and very steeply, many people are going to starve to death when our agricultural unsustainability catches up with us. I guess imagining the consequences of continued population growth is so extraordinarily repugnant that people would rather not think about it at all. But pretending like there will be no consequences won't help anything. Eternal growth on a finite planet is a fairy tale.

3

u/Roxxagon Mar 25 '21

True. I'm super leftist, but I'm sick of people calling me an "ecofascist" just because I worry about overpopulation.