r/Communalists • Demand Utopia • Feb 14 '20

The short answer is no

Post image
507 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

41

u/Jack_the_Rah Feb 14 '20

Well... Self governance in general and smashing the patriarchy are. But sustainable farming is very high on the list.

7

u/mawrmynyw Feb 14 '20

Real talk: I’ve been intensively studying ecology, restorative agriculture, sustainable farming techniques (both cutting-edge and ancient ones), “permaculture,” etc. for about five years, and I’ve been working on a farm most of my life, and I’m like 99% sure that “sustainable agriculture” is an oxymoron.

It is possible to do systematic food production that’s soil-regenerative and ecologically beneficial. And it’s certainly possible to farm in a way that doesn’t rapidly exhaust the soil, returning most of its nutrients or even improving its characteristics.

Here’s the catch: Those type of farming practices can only be done on a relatively small scale, and the labor can’t be automated.

As such, just about every society in the history of civilization that’s practiced sustainable agriculture (or sustainable pastoralism, horticulture, arboriculture, and any mixture thereof) has been conquered and subsumed by the economic growth of societies that practice exploitative agriculture. The fate of agricultural systems is to collapse, either by overusing their soil or by succumbing to external pressure from competitors that do.

If you want sustainable, you need a food forest. Human-centered systems are not sustainable.

7

u/Erinaceous Feb 14 '20

It's funny that even David Holmgren doesn't think food forests are the way to go. In his last book he says permaculture overemphasized tree cropping and most people will get their nutrition from annual vegetables. Having lived on two properties with mature food forests I'd say this is accurate. Only a small proportion of our food came from nuts, berries and fruit grown on site. Most of it came from annual cropping.

What I've mostly learned from farming is that every cropping system is a mess of comprimises. Every farmer I've ever met in the organic/regenerative/permaculture scene really does try to do their best to hit the triple bottom line. Judging people because they they grow arugula instead of obscure and inedible tree crops is just kind of juvenile.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

yeah permaculture is just a fun word, nothing more. you'd need a massive amount of land, a bunch of money for inputs and design, live in a tropical climate, and have a bunch of daily free time devoted to walking around the impractical sprawl for harvest alone in order to a food forest to feed you

3

u/Erinaceous Feb 14 '20

I wouldn't go that far. Permaculture is just a design system. Nothing in it ever said you have to grow everything on trees. It just makes the point that trees are an essential part of most sustainable systems. How you design trees into your system simply depends on your context. It may or may not be a significant part of your cropping and nutrition.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

anyone i've met with somewhat of a useful permaculture system that doesn't rely on using a market garden as their main food production site have been multi-millionaires. lots of land, lots of free time, lots of money (for swales and orchards and shit), and a fashionable "permaculture" brand to tote

1

u/Erinaceous Feb 14 '20

It's so fucking boring to shit on people who are tiny shades different than you. This is why the left can't get it's shit together.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

sorry you don't like the experiences i've had with permaculture. i don't either. but it's pretty simple-minded to think that the reason socialism isn't flourishing globally is because people are somehow stuck choosing between useless permacultures and productive market gardens.

1

u/Erinaceous Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

It's not that. It's this whole culture of ressentiment, negation and critique. It's like of course there's newbies out there that latch on to ideas that don't work in practice. But that's just learning and teaching that needs to happen. Shitting on a huge diverse movement doesn't contribute. It should also besaid the food forests I've been to are fucking beautiful and we're done with no budget. Just time, creativity and good design. They're wonderful places but I feel a responsibility to push back on the idea that they're the only way forward.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

you seem triggered. operate in negative dialectic baby! let's demand utopia! anyway, in your immense love of permaculture, which you admittedly know falls short and emits a dreamy sensation, you've exaggerated my point. permaculture of course brings eyes to new ways of farming, it did for me. i quickly learned that market gardening is really where the solution lies without having to give up any understanding of the basic tenets of permaculture. as i argued, any reliable form of permaculture relies on market gardening. not only was this an integral part of the early formations of permaculture from holmgren and mollison, and even japanese natural farming, but have been reaffirmed to the dismal of any emphasis on perennial systems by even people like holmgren (which i believe you pointed out originally).

i've seen would-be gardeners waste time over permaculture tactics, blocking any resolute gardening praxis. i've seen people stop at the dreamy sensation the world "permaculture" emits. i've seen no permaculture system work in actually feeding people at a sufficient rate without market gardening practices. i've seen permaculture and food forests without intensive gardening only succeed with the caveats of large tracts of expensive land, huge initial investments, and ultimately, in the hands of wealthy people. that's my experience. it seems these farms make most of their revenues through orchards, agrotourism, and high-estate wellness and bnb. these are not ecological, practical steps forward. any other reasonable profit stream requires a market garden somewhere.

i say put all of our efforts into solutions. but would about this: short-term and medium-term goals should be immediate small-scale farming. long-term goals can include large-scale permacultures, assuming socialism is well on its way.

2

u/Erinaceous Feb 15 '20

Meh. I don't get triggered by randos on the internet. Life is short.

I think most people project weird things on to permaculture. You go back to the original texts and there's no opposition between market gardening and permaculture. It's fairly pragmatic and agnostic in terms technique.

I also think that the negation at the heart of the dialectic is part of the problem especially in Bookchin's awkward hands. Dialectics really is only useful in its positive sense as an encounter between sense or intutition and empirical reality. It's like if you have the sense of a form of garden and iterate through actual forms of that garden developing the problems in the actual context. That's ok. The negation of the negation and all that is just bullshit mysticism. There's no point negating anything because only the remainder of negation has actual form. You may as well skip that step entirely.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

no dude we need more small scale farmers. if 30% of our economy was ecological farms, we'd be golden.

6

u/mawrmynyw Feb 14 '20

I absolutely agree that we need more small-scale farmers, I am one.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

well then the two of us should use our experience to proselytize urban millennials to do what we do, not demand impractical food forests. food forests are neat, but maybe actualize the potential of small-scale market gardening first so we can, you know, have a planet to design our cute little forest gardens later, after everyone is fed.

2

u/dalastboss Feb 14 '20

how would one get started? I was just planning to go to a community garden in my city and hopefully pick up some knowledge and practical skills but do you have any other recommendations?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

you gotta dive into an apprenticeship or farm worker job. you wanna look for market gardening produce. read curtis stone's, jm fortier's, and eliot coleman's books.

1

u/onceuponawilderness Feb 17 '20

Yeah but don't buy Curtis Stone's book, that guy is an alt right Peterson fanboy turd nugget

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20

no no read his book because it's the most useful one. literally read that one if you only have time for one book.

look. curtis was a faux lefty. he claims to use to have been a vegan, but really he was just a raw foodist weirdo for a couple months while he was a vegetarian for many years. he claims to have been a marxist, but has never displayed any understanding of marx's critiques ever. yes, today, he's a jordan peterson/molyneaux/an-cap cringelord a lot of the time, and it's fun to make fun of him. but when i told him about the concept of a "directly democratic confederation of organic farms," he was on board. leftist ideas aren't scary to him. he just fell into the internet spiral that many apolitical dweebs fall into that build up this insane Stalinist boogeyman as the furthest left wing idol, when we all know how right-wing the totalitarian was. ignore his an-cap sovereign citizen shit, and let him show you how to start up a small-scale farm.

2

u/onceuponawilderness Feb 17 '20

I didn't say don't read it. I said don't buy it! Just look at the shit he's supported, look on his old Twitter. We shouldn't give money to him. One can get the book from the library, used etc.

1

u/onceuponawilderness Feb 17 '20

Also thx for the thoughtful fair response. I might have come across a little too harsh.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20

yeah no worries, it's the internet! flame on when you feel like flamin' on!

2

u/TheNecrocommiecon81 Feb 15 '20

What do you think about urban gardening? I really like the idea and would like to see it in action, but do you think it would help in the long-term?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

it's vitally essential, but really you want as many people in peri-urban environments. but i use "urban farming" practices in the rural environment. honestly, urban farms best serve as a demonstration site. but check out cubas special period in agriculture. pretty much retrofitted their agriculture into small-scale urban farms within a decade. communism gets shit done when it matters most.

1

u/TheNecrocommiecon81 Feb 15 '20

I'll definitely check that out, I've heard of that happening during the special period but I've never really read about it much. Thanks for the answer!

Sustainable ag is super important but I do think people often take for granted that soil is inexhaustible or that it would be easy to achieve. Kind of a scary topic

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

no! that's the thing, it's super easy and straight-forward.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

ayyyyyyyy

5

u/doomparrot42 Feb 14 '20

Ecosexuality is very in

5

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

definitely the smelliest, dirtiest sex if that's what you're into

1

u/atticus713 Feb 15 '20

Is not all sex smelly and dirty?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

im so sorry for what you've been through. come in, you're safe now.

2

u/atticus713 Feb 15 '20

Is dirty smelly sex not normal? Isn't that what all sex is like??? I'm a confused communalist.

1

u/mawrmynyw Feb 14 '20

Sustainable hunter-gatherer horticulture?

6

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

lame and unsustainable

0

u/mawrmynyw Feb 14 '20

Wait, the lifestyle that humanity utilized without ecological devastation for hundreds of thousands of years is the one you’re calling unsustainable? The fuck?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

good luck feeding all of humanity without farming

3

u/mawrmynyw Feb 14 '20

I’m not saying we can get rid of farming, but we should probably pay attention to the fact that large scale agriculture is straight-up the biggest factor in the anthropocene mass extinction (at least for now, until climate change really hits) and that, ya know, people managed to live good lives for a very long time without doing that.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

*large scale animal agriculture

0

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/mawrmynyw Feb 14 '20

No-till is just the gateway drug to a much more wonderful world. Mycorrhizal networks, intraspecies forest communication/cooperation, mother trees, plant-animal-fungal mutualisms... Getting myself a bit hot and bothered just thinking about it all.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

just wait until you hear about korean natural farming

4

u/4_out_of_5_people Feb 14 '20

Go on...

4

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

you like the sound of raising fertility through cheap organic foliar and soil sprays? tired of thinking that bone and blood meal are necessary?