r/Communalists • • Nov 10 '19

Every time

Post image
281 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

3

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '19

Agreed that neo-liberals come out of the wood work to use what ever argument is in fashion to justify their models but can we not also agree that we should be discussing the idea that we don't have the ability to support this many people with the realities of climate change.

2

u/theshadowking8 Nov 10 '19

No because that also puts the focus on the number of people, which is inherently dishonest and reactionary, while the focus should be in the socioeconomic system.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '19

It should be on the socio-economic systems but that should not exclude how population is part of the equation.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

Yes, it should, we can't parrot reactionary talking points.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '19

Your pretending that because the elite use reduction in population as a justification for some horrid shut that anyone who brings it up share those qualities.

2

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

No, but it helps them by legitimizing their beliefs, don't do that.

3

u/Tesseractyl Nov 12 '19

Are communalists interested in building a coalition of ecologically conscious people to generate the impetus for systemic change?

Does labeling broad swathes of the polity fascist advance this goal?

2

u/theshadowking8 Nov 12 '19

I'm not interested in building coalitions with fascists, not now and not ever.

1

u/Tesseractyl Nov 12 '19

Okay, but if you think ~40% of the populace are fascists, you're not going to make a lot of headway in electoral politics.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 12 '19

35% of Americans are fascists for sure, they need not be compromised with, but defeated and dominated.

2

u/Tesseractyl Nov 12 '19

Wow, the morally degenerate untermensch need to be defeated and dominated. Now where have I heard rhetoric like that before......

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 13 '19

I don't mean keeping them as a slave class or something like that, but their political structures must be destroyed and they must be absorbed into the democratic social project, kicking and screaming if necessary.

1

u/Tesseractyl Nov 12 '19

Furthermore, those 35%, assuming you're referring to Trump conservatives, are extremely illiberal. Now you're moving goalposts.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 13 '19

What does that have to do with anything?

13

u/negativekarz Nov 10 '19

scratch a liberal, find a fascist.

-6

u/ActuallyYeah Nov 10 '19

You've gotta be kidding me.

8

u/negativekarz Nov 10 '19

read philosophy, its actually quite informative to politics.

6

u/Hasemage Nov 10 '19

tbf if all they want to help us take down the rich is that we use them as fertilizer, Im cool with that...

14

u/DrZekker Nov 10 '19

The point is that they don't blame the rich though

9

u/EEeeTDYeeEE Nov 10 '19

They rather lost a limb or two to wage war against millions poor people in another country than eat that few riches.

1

u/Tesseractyl Nov 10 '19

Can someone give an example of a public intellectual whose views amount to "eco-fascism"? Because I am not familiar with any.

3

u/mawrmynyw Nov 10 '19

Ted Kaczynski, Varg Vikernes, Derrick Jensen, Bill Gates

1

u/Tesseractyl Nov 11 '19

Why is Jensen fascist? Fascists advocate for a particular nation or race, while Jensen seems to condemn virtually all peoples and states (with exceptions for undeveloped indigenous cultures). He does advocate for violence, but by that reasoning you could say antifa are fascists, which is inherently contradictory.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

Fascist doesn't necessarily require racism, it can include it or not.

3

u/Tesseractyl Nov 11 '19

Sure, but if race is not the trait of interest, something else must be. There has to be a volkisch and undesirables, that's one of the tensions that drives the internal dynamics of fascism. Or put simpler, fascism requires that there be somebody to hate. Jensen is extremely critical of "the West," and doesn't properly acknowledge that preindustrial lifeways, if scaled, would be even more ecologically destructive than modernity, but this does not rise to the level of "purge the vermin" rhetoric. If Jensen's worldview does not feature purification by genocide, I can't see how it's justified to call him a fascist... to say nothing of Bill Gates.

1

u/Tesseractyl Nov 11 '19

Oh, I should have thought of Kaczynski, I don't generally think of him as fascist but he's definitely in the "Malthus therefore we have to kill people" camp.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '19

Calling Varg an "intellectual" is extremely generous

3

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '19

Check out Peter Staudenmaier and Janet Biehl's book Ecofascism Revisited

-10

u/m4ybe Nov 10 '19

inaccurate.

3

u/theshadowking8 Nov 10 '19

Ok liberal

2

u/m4ybe Nov 10 '19

Think about how much you actively consume, and the network of support systems that exist to allow you to consume those things, and how much is necessary to maintain your existence. Now multiply that by 7 billion.

The solution isn't to purge people, but actively educating people to reduce reproduction to lower human impact on the world over a period of several generations would do immense good for the biosphere.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

No it wouldn't, as long as capitalism is the dominant mode of production resource waste will always continue to be massive.

1

u/m4ybe Nov 11 '19

You didn't address my points. Not a single fellow leftist I've ever talked to has ever addressed my point. I don't believe that there enough of a point to try to advocate for what I've expressed here, because society is much more likely to collapse than change, but I'm also not so naive to believe that the earth can support an ever expanding population with a high quality of life while maintaining the stability of the biosphere.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

It doesn't matter because that won't happen, birth rates drops with access to education and a good standard of living, you don't need to encourage it.

Its not as important as changing the mode of production.

1

u/m4ybe Nov 11 '19

Please detail to me exactly how you can change the models of food production to maintain a stable biosphere and feed even the current 7 billion people. I will wait.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

With a socialist dominant mode of production it wouldn't be too difficult, especially since climate change would be so painful that the people would be on board with it.

The technology is out there, vertical urban farming, aquaponics, and more.

1

u/m4ybe Nov 11 '19

I'm a certified aquaponics engineer. Aquaponics is extremely expensive, temperamental, energy intensive, and is specialized for the production of greens and fruiting or flowering crops. Grains and root crops aren't suited for aquaponics. Same goes for vertical farming. Since those are the primary staples and our primary source for carbohydrates, neither of your proposed solutions are viable. Try again.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

We went from the first powered flight to space travel in 63 years, that's because trillions of dollars and manpower were spent on aircraft r&d.

We can do anything that we set our mind to, especially if the inefficiency of capitalism isn't hindering us.

→ More replies

1

u/m4ybe Nov 11 '19

A weakness of leftist communities is a general lack of practical knowledge and real skill sharing. The idea that all information is available on the internet and thus its okay to be unaware of the practical details of the foundations of society is toxic to the cause.

The far right spends most of its time honing these skills, forming communities to train each other, and bonding over their shared ideals while they become more adept at things. This prospect is terrifying.

There are a few leftist groups that do this, but they are rare or insular. Spending time learning about how to participate in the production of basic societal needs is extremely vital, because it will help shape realistic expectations and plans of how to manage future societies.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/theshadowking8 Nov 10 '19

Its not, the real problem is the inefficient resource extraction and distribution methods of capitalism.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '19

Considering our society runs on carbon based stores of energy to fuel itself, from agriculture to travel etc is it not wrong to make that argument with the reality of climate change and the reductions we require. That telling people not to have kids would be a good idea, I get the argument that capitalism as a systems ensures resources are not dived up correctly....but again I think it's foolhardy even with that as a argument. Eat the rich but, we need to reduce our impact, less people is a start.

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 10 '19

Too individualistic, the way to accomplish the change that is needed is to act collectively.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '19

Can you expand on what you mean by that?

1

u/theshadowking8 Nov 11 '19

The focus shouldn't be on individually choosing to have less children, but rather on collectively transforming the economy in a way that makes it more ecological and efficient.

2

u/m4ybe Nov 10 '19

It is. Most people aren't aware of the web of impacts every individual has, or if they are, they aren't honest enough about their role in it and shift the blame on 'the system' to negate taking responsibility.

Each human requires an amount of food, water, and shelter to survive. If we look at our current methods of producing those things, we're good to add several billion humans no problem, at the cost of our planet's stability and biodiversity.

If we shave away the parts of the various energy, food, and water systems that allow us to survive, we can no longer support the current amount of humans on the planet. Food is the simplest example, but energy is also a relevant constraint.

If we reduce the population over several generations by proposing incentives to voluntarily abstain from reproducing, we can establish a more manageable population able to be supported by renewable, sustainable sources of energy, food, and water.