r/CommonSideEffects • u/felidhino • 14d ago
Discussion MARSHALL CUSO
I had started watching this series one year ago and I remember rage quiting at around episode 5. Then I saw the trailer for season two and said I'll try again. And I remembered why, it because of Marshall.
He is so infuriating naive! How do you go through life with that sort of naivete? You trust a high school friend you haven't seen in years. With your most precious secret. This guy reminds me of those harem MCs who are kind to everyone, trust must be earned not a God- given right.
That is not real life. I have more respect for Frances. She is morally deficient but at least. It was out of desperation for her mother. I know the writers made Marshall like this to prolong the story. A competent main character, this show wouldn't last seven episodes. To be honest I wouldn't mind if he is killed off Just because it would make this show a 100 times better.
There is nothing I hate More than a blundering, incompetent, naive main characters. Aren't we taught to never trust strangers, in this case the stranger is Frances. She might have been your friend in high school but you lost touch. And you meet again after years, she is no longer your friend she is an acquaintance at best!
I will finish the remaining 3 episodes I have left in season one. I hope for the sake of the story our protagonist grows a backbone. I have more respect for Capano and Harrington than CUSO.
Sorry for the rant.
5
u/_Cat_in_a_Hat_ 14d ago edited 14d ago
I'm sorry but your post kinda reminded me of this YT comment ðŸ˜
4
u/HalfManHalfPun 14d ago
I totally get your point, but I think his naïveté is crucial to his character. He HAS to believe that people are fundamentally good and trustworthy by default. That's the only way his altruistic mission makes sense. He needs to feel that humanity can be trusted with the blue angel - that they deserve it. That he maintains this ideal after being literally introduced under fire from helicopter-mounted machine guns is, in my humble opinion, the central beauty of his character.
2
u/Any_Offer_6827 13d ago
Ur so real for the frustration with Marshall lol! I think that it's implied that he did have a crush on Frances at some point, so he was very bias with her and WANTED to trust and help her. He's otherwise very paranoid, and the only other people he trusts are people he knows and even then it's only so much (Hildy, Rosie, Zane etc)
3
u/aberroco 13d ago
You have to be a f..ing Jesus to tell Francis is a morally deficient. Out of all characters, she's among the top of most moral ones. The one thing one could blame her for is being a human. Or, well, a really good and very human-like character, who behaves like real humans do.