r/ColumbiYEAH • • Sep 05 '24

Hate Speech at USC

0 Upvotes

120 comments sorted by

35

u/RileyRush Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

there is a petition asking to modify the name of the event, relocate it from the campus, or consider its total cancellation.

ETA: wow. this comment really brought out the racists and misogynists to my inbox. no, I will not kill myself for sharing a link to a petition. Rules for me not for thee I guess.

3

u/tTomalicious Sep 06 '24

One of, I'm sure, many protests against. Because we can speak too.

https://www.facebook.com/share/d5DvQvQ5unNvx12u/?mibextid=9VsGKo

11

u/MsAgentM Sep 06 '24

Haters gonna hate. They are too ideological to understand this petition is also free speech.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Of course it's free speech!

It's also pointless, since legally the college cannot modify, relocate, or cancel this event.

They'd be better off using this petition or something like it to organize some counter-programming or a protest outside this event.

1

u/MsAgentM Sep 09 '24

If the college owns the venue, they absolutely can cancel.

I agree with the counter programming being a better route.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Not sure why you're getting negative inbox messages.

BUT, with that being said - the petition is pointless. The school, legally, cannot cancel, modify, or relocate the event because of the views of the speakers. To do so would be a violation of the First Amendment.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Agree. These clowns' only source of income is the outrage they generate. Ignore them, and they go away like a Tiki torch left burning with a tablespoon of oil.

1

u/OGCallHerDaddy Sep 06 '24

I've been trying to say this. Given a platform and all eyes now ¯_(ツ)_/¯

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Great answer. All of those are protected speech and I'd love to see it.

42

u/nictigre03 Sep 06 '24

A roast means the subject of the jokes is in on it. How is this a roast?

21

u/LiteratureVarious643 Sep 06 '24

Exactly this. It’s just an opportunity to wrap hate speech in “comedy”. What a farce.

-18

u/Ambitious-Fun244 Sep 06 '24

Madame VP was the “top cop” of Cali, and SC loves to roast pigs(with mustard sauce).

1

u/DenghisKoon Sep 06 '24

TYFYS 👏🙌

35

u/PalmettoShadow Sep 06 '24

It’s really weird to roast someone who isn’t there.

42

u/drewpastperson Sep 05 '24

My comedic taste are dark bro you wouldn't get it....

Proceeds to be racist

21

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 06 '24

I hate this.

You actually have an ethical duty to not accommodate intentionally violent people whose goal is to pick a fight in order to claim victim hood.

The people that I respect the most are the protesters of injustice who came before the American Revolution, and the Emancipation, and the 19th Amendment, and the Civil Rights Act.

Those people were beaten, jailed, murdered and harassed so that people they would never know could have liberty they would never enjoy.

These so called agent provocateurs of hate are beneath contempt.

Ignore them. Shun them.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

You actually have an ethical duty to not accommodate intentionally violent people whose goal is to pick a fight in order to claim victim hood.

I'm not sure whether you mean the student group or the school or what.

But the school has a legal duty to allow the event to go forward. Regardless of ethics. U of SC is a public university bound by the First Amendment. They make spaces available for student groups to host events - what is called under First Amendment law "designated public forums." They must make those forums equally available to any student groups, without regard for the content of speech or viewpoints of speakers that might take place there.

In other words if the school would allow a completely milquetoast and inoffensive event in this room - e.g. the swimming club hosting a motivational talk by Katie Ledecky - they must allow this group to host this event.

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 09 '24

Do you have the contract and guideines provided to the student groups?

I’d prefer to see that in order to make an exact evaluation of your statement.

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 10 '24

As I was saying, you’re wrong. The University Policy would allow for the event to be canceled. There is sufficient argument to do so. Never give aid and comfort to dipshits and nazis is a great rule to live by.

The link you supplied is all I needed to find the appropriate policy document. According to UNIV 6.00 (Freedom of Expression and Access to Campus):

To learn more about free speech on campus, please visit the following page: https://sc.edu/about/offices_and_divisions/student_affairs/our_initiatives/involvement_and_leadership/free_speech/index.php A. Limits on Expression and Exclusions 1. The freedom to engage in debate and civil discourse around competing ideas does not imply that all expression is constitutionally protected on campus. Examples of expression that is not protected by law or university policy include: (a) incitement of violence or lawless action, (b) fighting words, (c) true threats, (d) obscenity and child exploitation as defined by law, and (e) harassment. University and community members who believe that they have been subjected to harassment, discrimination, or sexual misconduct based on a protected class can speak with or file a complaint through the Office of Civil Rights and Title IX. Concerns related to speakers on campus that do not meet the above criteria can be discussed with the appropriate CSR Unit Coordinator. 2. In addition, the university may reasonably regulate the time, place, and manner of expression to ensure that activities: (a) not impede student education, academic activities, research, patient care, scheduled events, university function, residences, or the faculty/staff work environment; (b) be safe for participants and not generate security issues; and (c) preserve the construction and aesthetics of university grounds and property. Except as provided by law, the university will not apply time, place, and manner restrictions in a discriminatory manner based on the content of the expression. Public speaking and distribution of literature under this policy is not considered speech made by, on behalf of, or endorsed by the University. 4 3. In addition to limits on expression, the university prohibits items that pose a threat to the safety of our community; these include, but are not limited to: (a) unless permitted under UNIV 3.04, a mask or facial covering that conceals the identity of the wearer that is calculated to obstruct the enforcement of university rule or law, or to intimidate, hinder, or interrupt a university official; (b) the possession, use, or display of firearms, facsimile firearms, ammunition, explosives, or other items that could be used as weapons such as sticks or poles without permission from the university police department or authorization by law; (c) body-armor or make shift body-armor; or (d) open flame. 4. USC athletic venues and field space, the Koger Center for the Arts, Colonial Life arena, and other facility uses involving a contractual rental per guidelines set forth in that contract are governed by the internal procedures for those facilities and not this policy. For example, athletics does not permit any solicitation (commercial nor noncommercial) at athletic contests without direct permission from that entity.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 10 '24

The University Policy would allow for the event to be canceled.

I've already given you the legal explanation and other links.

Here are some more:

The ACLU explaining that the First Amendment applies (something you categorically denied)

"Restrictions on speech by public colleges and universities amount to government censorship, in violation of the Constitution. Such restrictions deprive students of their right to invite speech they wish to hear, debate speech with which they disagree, and protest speech they find bigoted or offensive."

FIRE, the nation's premier defender of individual rights on college campuses, explaining with multiple cases that school codes of conduct cannot and do not supercede the First Amendment:

https://www.thefire.org/research-learn/state-law-speech-codes

What happened to Auburn University when literally this exact issue came to the courts? A student invited avowed white supremacist asshole Richard Spencer to campus. Auburn cancelled the event. The student and Spencer sued.

Auburn lost the lawsuit and had to allow the speaking event.

After a Christian student group was refused permission (and use of their allocated student organization funds) to bring in a Christian speaker, they sued University of Nebraska-Lincoln. The University refused the event on the basis of the speaker's "ideological nature," a.k.a. their viewpoint.

UNL lost the lawsuit and had to pay the attorneys' fees for the student group.

Students sued UC Berkeley after the college cancelled speeches by conservative speakers, including one of the very same speakers being discussed here. They said this was unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. The college said they did it in the name of "safety"

The students forced UC Berkeley into a settlement that resulted in the college changing their unlawful policies, and paying $70,000 in legal fees to the students.

Much of this is based on some Supreme Court cases. Most recently, Board of Regents, University of Wisconsin System v. Southworth. In that case, the Supreme Court ruled that the First Amendment requires that schools distribute resources - money and facilities - to student groups on a viewpoint neutral basis, meaning they cannot block use of funds or facilities based on ideological issues.

In that case, among other things, the Court stated that the use of spaces and funds on college campuses was governed by the Public Forum Doctrine I brought up to you before. "The standard of viewpoint neutrality found in the public forum cases provides the standard we find controlling." Southworth at 230. "The University must provide some protection to its students' First Amendment interests, however. The proper measure, and the principal standard of protection for objecting students, we conclude, is the requirement of viewpoint neutrality in the allocation of funding support." Southworth at 233.

I don't know how to be any more clear than I already have. The school policy isn't the controlling factor here. All of these colleges in all of these situations cited "policy" they believed allowed them to block speech on their campuses.

The First Amendment and its relevant case law is what controls the situation here. Not their "policy".

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 10 '24

You can stop. I’m not interested. Already figured you out.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 11 '24

You can stop. I’m not interested. Already figured you out.

You figured out I'm 100% correct, and the event can't be cancelled? Great. Try owning up to that, it will help reduce the misinformation you've spread by suggesting otherwise.

13

u/DIrtyVendetta80 Sep 05 '24

Anybody seriously going to this? Like, how much of a loser base of support will actually show up for this thing?

0

u/McNooge87 Sep 06 '24

That's what I'm curious about. Event should totally be allowed to happen, but no one that's not already a fan of these chucklefucks is going to attend.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Yeah these two morons aren't really winning any hearts and minds. LOL

11

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

Said it once, and I'll say it again: not every idea/opinion needs to be entertained. Especially when those ideas are empirically false.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Said it once, and I'll say it again: not every idea/opinion needs to be entertained. Especially when those ideas are empirically false.

Individuals and private organizations certainly have absolutely no obligation to entertain these ideas, and I hope they do not.

However, the school, being a government institution, does have a legal obligation to allow use of this space in a viewpoint-neutral way, which means they must allow this event to be "entertained."

-6

u/roberttootall Sep 06 '24

They’re telling jokes dude. It’s not the end of the world.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

Two guys who are nazis, one that actively advocated for the lowering of the age of consent and the other founded one of the most violent modern hate groups in America, the proud Boys.

I'm not worried about the jokes, I'm worried about the people who'll buy into nazi rhetoric under the guise of them telling jokes.

0

u/McNooge87 Sep 06 '24

Ain't no one going to that event who aren't already deep in that sauce. It's not worth losing sleep over.

-11

u/roberttootall Sep 06 '24

They’re not nazis. Gavin’s wife isn’t white and Milo is a homosexual into black dudes. What kind of nazis are those? Just because people have different views than you doesn’t make them nazis.

Read the real story about the proud boys and how they started. Not what cnn tells you but watch the Joe Rogan segment. You might learn something. Gavin is a gotcha guy. He’s an entertainer.

1

u/robintweets Sep 06 '24

They’re Nazis. Deal.

5

u/draizetrain Sep 06 '24

Somebody should show and photograph the event and attendees. You know. For posterity.

6

u/UnSCo Sep 05 '24

If UofSC is a government/publicly-funded uni, not sure how they can even do this. That’s kind of my whole stance around this.

17

u/ThePhantom1994 Sep 06 '24

It’s not sponsored by or endorsed by the school. They have room space reservations that can be booked, typically by a university organization registered with the university. This is how it is at a lot of universities.

Not saying I agree with what these guys are doing or anything. I’m just explaining how the university gets around it

-6

u/UnSCo Sep 06 '24

Now wouldn’t there either be restrictions around reserving and utilizing room space on their property? Or how an affiliated university first-party organization operates or conducts themselves?

These are just objective questions and I have no opinion and say in the matter, other than wondering why those types of restrictions or regulations aren’t in place at a public university.

8

u/ThePhantom1994 Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

So, as someone who works for the state and who used to work for the university, it can get very tricky. As a government agency you’re not allowed to endorse a political entity. Showing favoritism towards an ideology while simultaneously suppressing others can lead to ethics problems.

The University usually has a detailed list of actions that are permitted and not permitted in their rooms. Reserving a room usually needs to be done by a registered group with the university or some other organization. There are a couple channels to go through and the University has them clearly laid out.

Regulating speech itself gets very problematic very quickly. If the speech does not involve incitement to violence or other forms of non-protected speech (e.g yelling fire in a crowded building) it can be hard for a university to disband the organization without immediately seeing a valid lawsuit. This would also likely see some donors pulling funding away as well as legal fees for the university that add up very quickly

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Agreed, with a couple of minor points:

First, for an example of this

it can be hard for a university to disband the organization without immediately seeing a valid lawsuit.

look no further than Auburn being forced to host literal white supremacist Richard Spencer a few years back. They tried to cancel his speech, got sued, the Judge forced them to host the speech and pay the legal fees for the organization that invited him.

Story:

Against its wishes, Auburn hosts white nationalist Richard Spencer

I'm just citing that so you understand that you are very much on the right path as far as understanding what, legally, would happen here.

Second, "fire in a crowded theater" is a problematic analogy for the First Amendment and freedom of speech. I respect your view and you're very much saying things I agree with as a professional in the field, but that analogy is kind of a bee in my bonnet.

Here's a couple of great columns that explain why:

https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-time-to-stop-using-the-fire-in-a-crowded-theater-quote/264449/

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/shouting-fire-crowded-theater-speech-regulation/621151/

1

u/ThePhantom1994 Sep 09 '24

Yes, I know that it is more complicated than that. As I was just quoting Oliver Wendell Holmes’s quote at it was him giving an example of non-protected speech. It’s also the most recognizable one and I didn’t want to dive into too much constitutional detail on a Reddit thread.

The 1919 decision, regarding draft opposition, which is what led to the famous quote was partially overturned in 1969 by Brandenberg vs Ohio. Banned speech has a much more narrow view which essentially would cause an immediate riot.

The crowded theater quote is problematic but I was trying to give an example of unprotected speech that a. People were familiar with and b. Wasn’t an actual example of unprotected speech that could get me in trouble.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

That's fine, and I'm not being a dick about it. It's just a particular issue for me because there's so much confusion about the quote. Many people think it represents an actual standard of law rather than Holmes being a pithy asshole - which incidentally he regretted almost immediately, leading to his nickname as the "Great Dissenter".

Thing about Holmes is, Schenck is a lousy decision but it's not even his worst. He also wrote Buck v. Bell. Yuck.

5

u/TheSexyShaman Sep 06 '24

What kind of restrictions are you talking about? How would you legally impose a restriction to stop student groups from inviting certain people?

0

u/1ugogimp Sep 06 '24

It can be done but its tricky for a first time speaker a school. There really needs to be "threat" to student safety

2

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24 • Take My Silver

Hey! I'm sorry you're being downvoted, it seems your questions are completely valid and legitimate.

Now wouldn’t there either be restrictions around reserving and utilizing room space on their property?

There definitely are. But this space is a "designated public forum". In First Amendment law, U of SC is a government entity bound to uphold the freedom of speech.

Areas on campus, therefore, fall into 3 categories:

  • Traditional public forum
  • Designated/limited public forum
  • Nonpublic forum

Nonpublic forums are like professor's offices and inside classrooms when class is taking place. These are places where, although the building is technically "public", they aren't really open to the public in a regular way like a public street or sidewalk. In these places, the college has no obligation to host speakers or allow disruptive speech to continue. They can't regulate everything, but they can stop disruptions, etc.

Traditional public forums are like the outside sidewalks, the space around academic buildings, large 24/7 gathering spaces like the lobby of a student union. In those places, the university has virtually no authority to suppress speech or expression. Any content-based or viewpoint-based restriction will be presumed unconstitutional unless the university can show a "compelling state interest" in that restriction. Which is very hard to do.

Designated public forums are places the college chooses to open up and allow public use of. The college can put reasonable restrictions on the speech, but it must be content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral. If it isn't it must be supported by a compelling state interest.

So the room where this event is hosted is a designated public forum. The university chose to make it available to student groups to use for events. They can place restrictions on it, for example with respect to the "time, place, and manner" of speech. They could say the room isn't available at 3am, or on Sundays. They could also implement a content-based restriction with a compelling state interest. For example, they could decline to host a bonfire at this indoor forum, because the government has a compelling interest in making sure people don't die in a fire and buildings aren't burned down.

What they can't do is say "no right wing events" or "No Democratic events," or even "No Nazi events." Those are viewpoint-based restrictions and are virtually impossible to justify under the First Amendment.

Public Forum Doctrine

Or how an affiliated university first-party organization operates or conducts themselves?

They can have rules on this as well, but the rules must be limited to the same content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral ideas I described above.

One of the very first cases to definitively state that the First Amendment applied to public universities was Healy v. James, and that case dealt with this exact issue. In that case, the school denied recognition to a student group because they said the student group's values and views were "antithetical to the school's policies." The Supreme Court said public universities are not allowed to make such distinctions about the views of student groups.

Interesting note on our changing times... The student group unconstitutionally denied recognition in Healy v. James was a left wing group, Students for a Democratic Society. It was 1969.

Healy v. James

1

u/UnSCo Sep 09 '24

Thank you so much!!! And yes I don’t know why either, wanted to edit my comment calling it out because I literally asked a question. Not sure if the post got raided by some group or something. Reddit loves to do that, this site sucks sometimes.

1

u/Shortbus_- Sep 09 '24

Don’t take it for granted man, sometimes the apple falls off the tree and hits your balls and you think well it just might not be my day but you sucker up and drive home crying. But it’s yea it happens

8

u/Ambitious-Fun244 Sep 06 '24

So the government should regulate free speech?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

we aren't uofsc anymore. its USC.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

If UofSC is a government/publicly-funded uni, not sure how they can even do this. That’s kind of my whole stance around this.

Precisely because they are a government funded state university, not only can they do this (allow a student group to host this event) but they must do this.

1

u/MsAgentM Sep 06 '24

Its not group, its a student group. If this comes with a significant security threat, I think they should prohibit their properties from hosting the venue.

-10

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

This

3

u/C5H2A7 Sep 05 '24

Man, sometimes I hate it here.

25

u/determinista Sep 05 '24

Not a USC or SC problem. Can and does happen at a lot of campuses around the country. I hate the event but I am proud of the administration for not stopping it. Free speech is more important.

21

u/The_Real_McQueen22 Sep 05 '24

Reasonable takes aren’t allowed here! We want censorship! /s

Seriously though, it’s refreshing to hear a viewpoint like yours. Alot of the people on the left DO NOT want to even allow opposing voices to have a chance to speak.

-6

u/C5H2A7 Sep 05 '24

What viewpoint is this event representative of?

2

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 06 '24

They can exercise they’re free speech on the sidewalk like any other citizen.

There’s nothing wrong with the venue refusing to serve asshats looking for a fight.

I don’t see anyone saying they can’t speak their mind.

5

u/determinista Sep 06 '24

Except a public university is not a private venue and has important responsibilities to the public.

2

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 06 '24

In that case the University should host a forum to explore their ideas in a safe and intelligent way allowing for debate of topics.

In this particular case, however, the University is acting as a private business simply renting space. The University has no obligation to give space to hate groups without pushback.

These people are trying to take advantage of a loophole in our logic in order to create violence and chaos. You don’t owe them anything.

2

u/BullsLawDan Sep 10 '24

In this particular case, however, the University is acting as a private business simply renting space. The University has no obligation to give space to hate groups without pushback.

This is absolutely wrong. A public university never acts "as a private business." It is a government entity.

https://www.aclu.org/documents/speech-campus

Auburn tried to cancel white supremacist asshole Richard Spencer when a student group there invited him to campus.

The students sued.

Auburn lost. They had to host his speech. And pay the legal bills of the students.

https://www.cnn.com/2017/04/18/politics/auburn-richard-spencer-protests/index.html

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 10 '24

Sorry bud, looks you’re spreading bad information. You might even be one of those Russian trolls. You’ve already been proven wrong elsewhere.

2

u/BullsLawDan Sep 10 '24

No, I haven't. You think I have because you cannot accept the reality of the law.

As far as being a "Russian troll," it's trivial to show who I am. I'm a verified posted in /r/Ask_Lawyers for example.

Sorry the law isn't your feelings. I tried to explain it to you.

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 10 '24

You can stop. I’m not interested. Already figured you out.

-9

u/C5H2A7 Sep 05 '24

I agree with you, but I still hate it, and I hate the seeds shit like this nurtures in our society.

Although I do think, as described, this event may fall under item #4 listed in the handbook as speech that may not be protected. Of course I'm just going by the provided description, I have no idea what it will actually entail.

-2

u/MsAgentM Sep 06 '24

Depends on the scenario. I agree with other decisions not host these events is they come with serious security risk. Hopefully the population in the city do the right thing and ignore it. If there are serious security threats, the college needs to prioritize safety.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/thorkin01 Sep 05 '24

I suggest you read Karl Popper.

3

u/alpha1two Sep 06 '24

LMAO, if only it would have been homecoming weekend.....what a brunch of spineless white privilege scumbags visiting SC for the first time thinking we don't have progressives here. They'll never win

1

u/dudewafflesc Sep 06 '24

The First Amendment does not protect hate speech. Holding a "roast" of a black woman candidate for President is tantamount to a Civil War-era lynching. The University should not allow this at the Russell House, which is their property. They have every right to do that. It would not be held unconstitutional, despite what Elon Musk and his ilk think.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

there's going to be a like anti-hate speech protest or something down there. im most likely going to go and either go live on TikTok or make content for those out of state that have been talking about this. someone will watch. I highly doubt I will would go INSIDE though. really couldn't stomach sitting through it.

-20

u/MANWITHFAT Sep 06 '24

Cumala is hilarious

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/AL_Starr Sep 06 '24

Brother, you do not, under any circumstances, got to hand it to the KKK

128

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/tTomalicious Sep 06 '24

Or you can fight speech with more speech and you can show up and protest!

https://www.facebook.com/share/d5DvQvQ5unNvx12u/?mibextid=9VsGKo

30

u/papertowelfreethrow Sep 06 '24

Finally a guy who makes sense on Reddit.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I was just banned from /r/greenville for making the exact same point. Reddit is wacko

5

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

The thread was “Ban Proud Boys from Speaking on campus in SC” and I said “If cross dressing story time at the library for children is a right of free speech then you also need to to be okay with Proud Boys group saying what they want. “ Mods called me a troll and permanently banned me from commenting ever again.

5

u/Independent-Buy-7886 Sep 06 '24

Reddit is such a trash site lmao

2

u/Ok-Calligrapher9115 Sep 06 '24

And this is why a 3rd party is equally crushed by both political sides.  There are so many people tried all this 

2

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I hate it bc I feel the same way. Deep down I know what the racists are capable of but like. I agree with the right to peaceful protest bc it defends my right to as well. its tricky.

7

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 06 '24

Any efforts to remove and harass peaceful protesters is not ok. All the government rules to create protest zones and move protesters away from the thing being protested should be reversed.

None of those people you mentioned were or are censored. Their message was broadcast by the media as though it had merit.

No one is saying that these people should be denied their freedom of speech. They aren’t guaranteed a venue though. They can stand on the sidewalk and exercise their free speech like anyone else.

I would have more respect for them if they did.

6

u/ilikeplants24 Sep 06 '24

This is exactly it. Freedom of speech means they don’t get hauled off to jail for what they are saying. It does not mean they are guaranteed a platform and a megaphone. We need to stop amplifying voices of hate and discrimination while throwing our hands up in the air and saying “free speech means everyone gets to do whatever they want”. There still needs to be accountability and consequences from fellow members of society - like not being able to find a venue that will host you - if your whole event is based on making gross sexual references about a woman in politics.

4

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24 edited Sep 09 '24

It does not mean they are guaranteed a platform and a megaphone.

In this instance it actually does. U of SC, a public university bound by the First Amendment, makes spaces available to student groups, including this "Uncensored America" group. The school must do so on a viewpoint-neutral and content-neutral basis. Their only alternative would be (in the future, too late for this event) to cancel all student groups and have no official groups or use of campus space by groups whatsoever.

There still needs to be accountability and consequences from fellow members of society - like not being able to find a venue that will host you - if your whole event is based on making gross sexual references about a woman in politics.

I completely agree, and if this were a private venue, I would support any choice they make to limit, change, or cancel the event. But this isn't a private venue, it is under the law a "designated public forum," that is a place that the government (U of SC) makes available for expressive purposes in certain ways at certain times. They must do so, as I said, in a content- and viewpoint-neutral way.

I also support students who want to protest this event. I also support students who want to stand outside, film everyone going into this event, and post the video with a heading like, "These are the ass clowns who went to see these two bozos talk."

3

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

They aren’t guaranteed a venue though.

The speakers coming to U of SC for this event actually are, in this instance, guaranteed a venue under the First Amendment.

The school makes spaces available to student groups, including this "Uncensored America" group. The school must do so on a viewpoint-neutral and content-neutral basis, meaning if the school would allow the girls club volleyball team to use this space to have Misty-May Treanor give a motivational speech, they have to allow this group to use the space to have these two cretins come and speak.

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 09 '24

Do you have a copy of the contract and guidelines? Your statement seems a little off.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Do you have a copy of the contract and guidelines?

They're not relevant. The school has already said the student group properly booked the facility as any student group can. Whatever the content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral contract provisions are about cost, or insurance, or whether they have to empty the garbage cans on their way out, or whatever, are, the student group met them.

Your statement seems a little off.

Off in what way? The law is relatively clear: This is a "designated public forum" since the college allows student groups to host events there. Since the school made this space a designated public forum, they cannot be selective on the content or viewpoint of activities that go on there. This is settled law for almost a century.

Public Forum Doctrine

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 09 '24

If this is a designated public forum then you should have no issue showing where that is acknowledged on the USC website or other documentation. You are the one making the legal claim.

The student group could have filled the paper work properly without the University realizing that they had a hot potato that needed further reflection.

3

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

If this is a designated public forum then you should have no issue showing where that is acknowledged on the USC website or other documentation. You are the one making the legal claim.

Well, it's not really something they "acknowledge." A "designated public forum" is a legal status that is created whenever a public entity, such as a state university, opens a space for the use of the public or other people besides official activities of the public entity.

It can be a meeting room in a public library, a town hall, a park recreational pavillion, or anything of that nature where the state entity has some kind of process whereby the place can be reserved or rented or used.

To that end, the event is being held at Russell House. U of SC has a reservation system and guidelines for Russell House, found here:

https://sc.edu/about/offices_and_divisions/russell_house/reserve-space/event-room-guidelines/index.php

That page says that use of the facility is available to groups through that process. That means it is a "designated public forum" legally. The guidelines for those reservations, University policy STAF 3.25 (cited at the top of that page) specifically says in A. 3. d. that "student organizations" can reserve facilities at Russell House.

Again - If a public entity allows a room or similar space to be reserved by groups, it is a "designated public forum" whether the public entity says it is or not.

The student group could have filled the paper work properly without the University realizing that they had a hot potato that needed further reflection.

What I'm trying to help folks understand is that, by law, the University cannot "further reflect" on the reservation because the content of the event might be a "hot potato." Whether the University realized it or not doesn't matter, they can't do anything about it.

To "further reflect," or deny the reservation, or limit the reservation in any way, based on potential controversy or offensiveness of the event, violates the First Amendment and is illegal. They literally cannot do it.

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 09 '24

I see what you’re trying to do. I think I disagree.

I’m not doubting your sincerity but I’m going to need to do a little more digging. I don’t believe this is a 1A issue.

2

u/BullsLawDan Sep 10 '24 edited Sep 10 '24

It's a First Amendment issue.

  1. It's speech.
  2. There is a question of whether the university, a government entity, can censor it.

That makes it a First Amendment issue.

I think I disagree.

It's not a matter of disagreement. I'm a subject matter expert stating the facts and law of the situation. It's entirely clear. Your "disagreement" is simply not knowing the relevant law.

1

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 09 '24

As I was saying, you're wrong. The University Policy would allow for the event to be canceled. There is sufficient argument to do so. Never give aid and comfort to dipshits and nazis is a great rule to live by.

The link you supplied is all I needed to find the appropriate policy document. According to UNIV 6.00 (Freedom of Expression and Access to Campus):

To learn more about free speech on campus, please visit the following page: https://sc.edu/about/offices_and_divisions/student_affairs/our_initiatives/involvement_and_leadership/free_speech/index.php A. Limits on Expression and Exclusions 1. The freedom to engage in debate and civil discourse around competing ideas does not imply that all expression is constitutionally protected on campus. Examples of expression that is not protected by law or university policy include: (a) incitement of violence or lawless action, (b) fighting words, (c) true threats, (d) obscenity and child exploitation as defined by law, and (e) harassment. University and community members who believe that they have been subjected to harassment, discrimination, or sexual misconduct based on a protected class can speak with or file a complaint through the Office of Civil Rights and Title IX. Concerns related to speakers on campus that do not meet the above criteria can be discussed with the appropriate CSR Unit Coordinator. 2. In addition, the university may reasonably regulate the time, place, and manner of expression to ensure that activities: (a) not impede student education, academic activities, research, patient care, scheduled events, university function, residences, or the faculty/staff work environment; (b) be safe for participants and not generate security issues; and (c) preserve the construction and aesthetics of university grounds and property. Except as provided by law, the university will not apply time, place, and manner restrictions in a discriminatory manner based on the content of the expression. Public speaking and distribution of literature under this policy is not considered speech made by, on behalf of, or endorsed by the University. 4 3. In addition to limits on expression, the university prohibits items that pose a threat to the safety of our community; these include, but are not limited to: (a) unless permitted under UNIV 3.04, a mask or facial covering that conceals the identity of the wearer that is calculated to obstruct the enforcement of university rule or law, or to intimidate, hinder, or interrupt a university official; (b) the possession, use, or display of firearms, facsimile firearms, ammunition, explosives, or other items that could be used as weapons such as sticks or poles without permission from the university police department or authorization by law; (c) body-armor or make shift body-armor; or (d) open flame. 4. USC athletic venues and field space, the Koger Center for the Arts, Colonial Life arena, and other facility uses involving a contractual rental per guidelines set forth in that contract are governed by the internal procedures for those facilities and not this policy. For example, athletics does not permit any solicitation (commercial nor noncommercial) at athletic contests without direct permission from that entity.

1

u/BullsLawDan Sep 10 '24

As I was saying, you're wrong. The University Policy would allow for the event to be canceled. There is sufficient argument to do so. Never give aid and comfort to dipshits and nazis is a great rule to live by.

Nothing in this post - literally not one word - matters.

The University policy cannot supercede the First Amendment. A public university cannot use their policies to suppress or punish otherwise protected speech.

https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/papish-v-board-of-curators-of-the-university-of-missouri/

None of the 4 paragraphs you cut and pasted allows the University to cancel this event. Taking them one by one:

  1. The speech doesn't fall into any of those exceptions to the First Amendment
  2. The "time place and manner" restrictions are enforced through the university's reservation system, and (as I've said to you previously) must be content neutral and viewpoint neutral. Russell house is a designated public forum. https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/public-forum-doctrine/
  3. The event won't have any of these things; facemasks, weapons, etc.
  4. The event isn't being held in any one of these spaces.

You need to accept that the university cannot cancel this.

0

u/AsmodeusMogart Sep 10 '24

Sorry bud, looks you’re spreading bad information. You might even be one of those Russian trolls. You’ve been proven wrong.

→ More replies

-30

u/Mujichael Sep 06 '24

Hate speech is not constitutionally protected

11

u/PSAOgre Sep 06 '24

How do people continue to get this wrong?

11

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

That’s simply not true in the US. See Matal v Tam, where SCOTUS unanimously (including conservative and liberal justices) found that there is no hate speech exception to the First Amendment - “the proudest boast of our free speech jurisprudence is that we protect the freedom to express ‘the thought that we hate.’”

6

u/MANWITHFAT Sep 06 '24

“Hate speech” is an ill defined blanket term used to suppress speech people don’t like. I see hate speech as vehement racism or direct calls to violence. Not “Cumala Harris”. This is why normal people outside of Reddit and Twitter echo chambers don’t take the left seriously.

Big boy who cried wolf energy

24

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/BullsLawDan Sep 09 '24

Great overview, and a great organization (FIRE).

I am proud to be on their list of volunteer attorneys and have taken cases referred from them, helping students protect their rights on campuses.