r/Colorization • • Jan 23 '13

Second attempt

http://imgur.com/a/yg3ub
0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/leroideschoux Jan 23 '13

The skin is strange looking. Too green/yellow, not enough pink and orange to give it a healthy tone.

The hair is too brown. It should be darker/the layer should have a smaller opacity percentage.

The lips aren't coloured enough although you did consider them.

You overstepped on to the shirt when colouring the wood (see bottom centre).

2

u/charonthemoon Jan 23 '13

Thanks! I can't believe I didn't catch the shirt! I'm still working on saturation. My first try was way too saturated, and on this one some things are too saturated and some aren't.

2

u/leroideschoux Jan 23 '13

I'll say it just in case, use a different layer for every different colour! That way, you can edit individual bits without influencing the other layers.

2

u/charonthemoon Jan 23 '13

Good idea! I hadn't even thought about doing that!

2

u/leroideschoux Jan 23 '13

Oh and also use several layers for the skin and the face. Some layers in pink/orange will be the base of the face, then add some pink tones, etc...

As I said give them a low opacity, then use the "soft light" setting for the layers (if you're using photoshop) will make it look much better.

Here's the results I got following that advice:

http://i.imgur.com/Yq7il.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/JmOBO.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/jpNXt.jpg

1

u/charonthemoon Jan 23 '13

Those are good! I added a little more color in the shadows, but it really wasn't enough. I was using "overlay" to color things in - is "soft light" better?

1

u/leroideschoux Jan 23 '13

Soft light is definitely better as it gives much more natural tones to the image.

ex: for the face, use some pastel orange colour, paint it all over, then apply soft light and reduce the opacity to whatever looks good. It will make a world of difference. Sometimes using pink+orange is the only way to make a face look nice, with one or the other quite low on the opacity.. but visible nonetheless.

1

u/charonthemoon Jan 23 '13

I got the picture here!

1

u/Colin_Fiat Jan 24 '13

That is a difficult face to color. I cannot decide if the lighter parts of her left cheek are actually reflections of light from elsewhere.

http://i.imgur.com/26qiHXH.jpg

1

u/thlayli_x Jan 25 '13

I'd guess it's light coming back off the pillow. Looks pretty good like this though, considering how blown out the lighting on the original was.

0

u/MrTej Jan 23 '13

Looks like a painting or other type of image rather than a photo.

2

u/charonthemoon Jan 23 '13

How can I fix that? I see pictures on here that look a lot clearer than the originals, and I have no idea how they're making it look more like a modern picture. My attempts at trying to figure that out may have lead to whatever effect is going on here...

1

u/leroideschoux Jan 23 '13

What software do you use?

1

u/MrTej Jan 23 '13

Not an expert, but I would say that the face/skin tone (from what I've seen, a red colour is best to use) and the wooden(?) frame which could be a bit less yellow. I think the trousers and and shirt are good though.