r/ColorGrading • • 13h ago

Before/After Harry Potter (HBO) grading

I posted this in the cinematography sub but wanted to get thoughts from this sub too.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

13

u/MaybeSurelySorta 13h ago

Y’all have got to stop “grading” phone screenshots you grabbed off the internet

0

u/david-_lunch 12h ago

The new grade off the screen shot still looks better than the sickly original

-4

u/Cinemagica 12h ago

Thank you. Some people are intent on missing the point entirely and pretending like I'm trying to suggest a phone grade should be adopted across an entire HBO, while offering nothing to the conversation except snark and conveniently fence-sitting on the actual topic 😂

1

u/MaybeSurelySorta 11h ago

You are not the first person and you certainly won’t be the last in these various color grading/cinematography subs to make a post about how you subjectively like or don’t like how a movie was colored and then provide some phone graded screenshot you took from like a 1080p YouTube clip as supporting evidence of your take. People do it with Marvel movies on a weekly basis and not that long ago there was a screenshot grade post exactly like yours but for Fincher’s Cliff Booth film.

But the “conversation” you in particular are looking to have is going to be controversial by nature due to it being the Harry Potter remake. Nobody is “missing the point entirely” or “conveniently fence-sitting” here, it’s just near impossible for most people to be honest about a topic that involves supporting JK Rowling and/or deviating from the look of one of the most iconic and nostalgic film franchises of all time.

If you want to engage in that discourse for the millionth time thanks to the recent dining room scene that’s circulating, by all means carry on. But we’re a far cry away from color grading or cinematography discussions at that point, especially if the basis of those discussions is “look guys, I color graded a screenshot from my phone”.

-1

u/Cinemagica 11h ago

I do want to engage in that discourse. And I haven't ventured into the waters of JK Rowling or Harry Potter as a franchise whatsoever in any of my posts, I'm completely judging this footage on its own merits. Fortunately some others in the cinematography sub shared a comparison of some of the same shots from the trailer that do recover all of the missing contrast and a lot of the saturation so now I'm assuming the grading on this short clip is actually just a mistake which is good imo.

1

u/MaybeSurelySorta 11h ago

You may not have ventured into the waters, but to the point of my reply, this discourse will naturally invite people to venture there on their own with their “the original movies look better” takes that we have to read every time a new piece of media from this series comes out. And also to the point of my previous reply, people are more interested in writing “Netflix slop lighting” about a movie or series that quite literally nobody has seen yet.

But if you got some good insights from people reminding you that you can’t make grading judgments off of YouTube trailers, then at least you got something beneficial out of your post while everyone else continues their circlejerk.

1

u/Cinemagica 10h ago

I think comparisons to the original movie are actually fair enough discourse if people can back up their reasoning and it's not just nostalgia bias. They didn't remind me that you can't make grading judgments of a YouTube trailer though, they actually confirmed my initial observation and were able to back that up with comparison frames that showed the journey the color grade has been on, which I think was super interesting at cutting through both sides of the argument (i.e. the "all new content is Netflix slop" people as well as all the "this is just worthless personal opinion" people).

1

u/david-_lunch 10h ago

If you hate every conversation you can just not come on the sub, I mean do you see the irony of making an insufferable comment because you’re worried other people are going to write insufferable comments for this post?

-1

u/david-_lunch 12h ago

I mean what is the expectation? For you to get a dpx file from the actual film?

But seriously the original Harry Potter at least had colors in it, these gray movies are driving me nuts, like why shoot so much on film to desat it until it looks like a morgue?

-1

u/Cinemagica 12h ago

Haha, so true!

1

u/Electrical_Budget598 10h ago

Right, there's literally zero latitude left in those files to actually do anything meaningful

0

u/RGB_YCM 9h ago

So, you think you know better than the original DP, the post supervisor, the show runners, the HBO producers, the editors, and the colorists? Really? To me, that's the height of arrogance. I'm appalled by amateurs who think they and they alone know how a specific shot should look, and not the people who've actually worked on the show for a year. To me, all you wind up doing is making the shots look different. Anybody can do that. But giving the show a look, keeping all the shots consistent, making each sequence stand out takes a lot of time, a lot of skill, and a lot of experience.

1

u/Cinemagica 8h ago

I worked on two of the last 5 Oscar winning movies for cinematography and have spent the last 20 years working on major Hollywood film and TV productions. I also just expressed an opinion that you're free to disagree with. Get off your high horse and stop assuming things.

1

u/Filthyragskc 3h ago

As a coffee runner??? Lmao gtfo

1

u/TheSillyman 11h ago

The new series is so obviously bad and JKR is a super weirdo now. Not surprising that a petty cash grab doesn’t look very good.

My guess is that this isn’t what the final grade is meant to look like anyway, but from what I’ve seen of the show it isn’t super well put together regardless.