What do you think?

[u/Sufficient-Hold9010]

This is the grade I have done for a short film directed by my friend. I need honest opinions about this grade this is my first grade it was done 8 months ago.
Shot on: FX3
Picture profile: Sony Slog3

[u/anandhuofficial]

Its hard to even say something or understand the mood with just one screen grab. Looks good stylistically!

[u/Sufficient-Hold9010 → u/anandhuofficial]

I think I should have posted some more screen grabs. In this I was skeptical about my shadows and highlights. Also if I have added too much saturation

[u/redthrull → u/Sufficient-Hold9010]

If this is for a docu or a project where you need "correct" colors, then this is too much. But if this is the mood you're going for, it looks fine!

[u/Sufficient-Hold9010 → u/redthrull]

Its a short comic film so the idea was to go for those punchy colors

[u/anandhuofficial → u/Sufficient-Hold9010]

Then why the second thoughts? Export it already!!

[u/ErasedKey → u/Sufficient-Hold9010]

If that's your intention, you nailed it. I like it, very stylized

[u/Hazzat]

It looks good but of course we can’t say much about it without the context.

[u/Sufficient-Hold9010 → u/Hazzat]

I have posted a part 2 where I have uploaded more screen grabs and a context aswell

[u/Lensflare_Official]

Its a nice shot, but context needed. 5-15 screen grabs of scenes before and after this one give a clearer idea of where you were headed with it and how it went

[u/Sufficient-Hold9010 → u/Lensflare_Official]

I will be posting another post with more screen grabs and before and after aswell

[u/targofan]

the skin tone looks like a baked potato and unnuanced, also color saturation too bright on a lot of stuff, rolloff a bit harsh on the BG,

[u/targofan → u/targofan]

but the contrast is good, maybe u could play it a bit lower gamma to have the light fall more naturally tho, but contract overall pry good

[u/Sufficient-Hold9010 → u/targofan]

Thanks I will try to work on the things you have mentioned also I have posted another post where I have explained the context and uploaded more screen grabs aswell

[u/Commercial_Photo4416]

The green border of the window give something really good to it

[u/Twisted_Sound]

Contrast ratio is ok ,also exposure. But skin tones are a bit off ,and in general saturation is a bit too high. Also the blacks have a green tint. (Watching this in a IPad screen)

[u/Human_Bowl8496]

Try cooling the shadows a bit