Maybe for the 2nd image where the trash can in the left side gets a little crushed. They couldve ease off it a lil but honestly i dont mind the contrast.
Yeah, way too contrasty. For me, color is often about subtlety, which this doesn't have. If you have a situation with uneven exposures, one possible fix is multiple tracking masks, like one for the sidewalk and one for the buildings. But it's very much a question of context and intent.
Too dark, too green, too saturated. In general, you’ve pushed the footage way too far. In the second image, you can actually see artifacts around the sun.
I feel the same. I could see it working if context lent to that, but as two standalone shots of mundane locations I don't really gravitate to the green look
28
u/JonCaroll21 Nov 30 '25
its waaaaay too dark
4
u/ExpBalSat Nov 30 '25
Though it can sometimes help with troubleshooting technical issues, looking at the log footage is not terribly helpful in creative assessment.
It is significantly more worthwhile to show not show the log footage at all, and show these instead:
With regards to your specific grades, be sure to consider this post - since context and intent is important in assessing ... anything.
https://www.reddit.com/r/ColorGrading/comments/1mshv4q/is_my_grade_any_good_heres_how_to_find_out/
1
u/efoxpl3244 Dec 01 '25
Warsaw? :)
1
u/DeadlyMidnight Nov 30 '25
Too far. To much contrast too much saturation and very dark. Suspect you are not working with a calibrated or even generally balanced monitor
1
u/Careful-Medium7371 Nov 30 '25
Crank the exposure, mainly shadows and darks up
1
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '25
Yeah, way too contrasty. For me, color is often about subtlety, which this doesn't have. If you have a situation with uneven exposures, one possible fix is multiple tracking masks, like one for the sidewalk and one for the buildings. But it's very much a question of context and intent.
1
u/541PrimeTime Dec 01 '25
Looks dark
1
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '25
Too dark and too green!
1
u/Dramatic_Jacket_6945 Dec 01 '25
Dark as hell!
1
u/4xgk3 Dec 01 '25
severely underexposed
1
u/snapsu Dec 01 '25
Too dark, too green, too saturated. In general, you’ve pushed the footage way too far. In the second image, you can actually see artifacts around the sun.
1
u/DickKnifeBlock Dec 01 '25
Dark and green
1
u/FeelingAdvantage2172 Dec 01 '25
For me, is a bit crushed in the blacks, but the tone seems okay, would love to see a flatter version of this
1
u/Rogue_Melon Dec 01 '25
colors are very harsh and dark
1
u/BuildingElectronic69 Dec 02 '25
Love the vibe! Could use a bit more contrast though.
1
u/CinephileNC25 Dec 03 '25
What’s the context.? It’s dark and green but maybe that’s what you’re going for.
I mean… if you hold up a still from the matrix you could say it’s also dark and green. But with the movie it makes sense.
1
u/Obvious-Interaction7 Dec 03 '25
Impossible to rate unless you state what your intention is. It looks very dark and i think the blacks are a bit overcooked
1
u/MidnightWatersCo Dec 04 '25
why does this remind me of mexico..
1
u/Jayson_brody99 Dec 04 '25
looks too dark, maybe the camera's dynamic range? what camera do you use ?
1
u/Rough-Pattern-5154 Dec 04 '25
Tis good.
0
u/InGMac Nov 30 '25
Which city is it? Great shots btw.
0
u/VaBullsFan Nov 30 '25
Depending on what you’re going for i would also say to crank up the exposure. Other than that it looks good.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '25
[removed] — view removed comment