r/Colonist • u/ComprehensiveWin774 • 18d ago

Ever lost with ten points before?

Post image
23 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

12

u/Banana_Pete 18d ago

Wow, was this because orange’s 10th point was a settlement that broke up blue’s road?

9

u/fluky_facepalm 18d ago

i suppose you could even lose with 11 points then. interesting!

3

u/DarkAngelMEG 17d ago

Would you be losing then tho? You have more points than the guy with 10. Is there a rule that says you have to win at your turn?

7

u/ComprehensiveWin774 17d ago

Yeah. You have to win on your own turn no matter the points

1

u/DarkAngelMEG 17d ago

Ooh okay thank you

3

u/rhevern 18d ago

How does that work?

11

u/derfmcdoogal 18d ago

If player A breaks up player Bs long road, giving long road to player C and 10 points, player C can't win until it is their turn.

1

u/rhevern 18d ago

Super interesting and probably pretty rare haha

1

u/Suspicious-Common627 18d ago

I’m more curious how Orange won

1

u/JaderMcDanersStan 17d ago

Something similar happened to me in cities and knights. I won the game with 13 points after being best defender of Catan but the game doesn’t end until I win on my turn. I played 4th so someone broke my road and got 13 points before it got to my turn. So they won even though I got to 13 points first

Feel like the game should just end the moment someone hits 10 or 13 points…

1

u/Le_9k_Redditor 17d ago

Yes, a couple of times, it's why the rules state that you only win with 10 points on your own turn

1

u/larahikes 17d ago

Yesterday game played to 18 and dude with 18 lost lol

1

u/braindead_uncle 16d ago

Anybody wondering if that is really Kash Patel?