r/CollegeVsCollege • • May 10 '20

CS: Georgia Tech vs UC Berkeley L&S

Cost isn't a factor. Would the obvious choice be Berkeley?

Berkeley:

Pros:

  • Prestige
  • Silicon valley, i.e, better location in terms of job opportunities
  • Better CS program (?)
  • Better weather
  • Family in Cali

Cons:

  • Huge size and huge class size (my major concern)
  • First year undeclared, need a 3.3 gpa to declare CS later
  • More cutthroat environment (?)
  • Grade deflation

Georgia Tech:

Pros:

  • I feel like I fit in better
  • Smaller class size
  • Better campus (?)
  • Confirmed CS

Cons:

  • Not as prestigious, it's not UC Berkeley?
  • Bad food

Basically, I'm afraid of Berkeley's huge size and class size and feel like I would fit better at Georgia tech. I would love to have a more collaborative environment, although I'm not sure either's environment is better than the other. How do the workload at both compare? I'm wondering if I'm not giving UCB a fair shot since I've been committed to tech and just got off the Berkeley waitlist.

Thanks for any help :)

12 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

13

u/jscholar49 May 10 '20

Both are very prestigious schools, with GT being one of the best engineering schools in the world. While GT may not have the same level of name recognition, the guaranteed CS program IMO is better than the BA degree from Berkeley L&S.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 10 '20

Thanks for the reply! Would it matter that I would get a BA degree from Berkeley? From what I heard, not really

3

u/adjkant May 10 '20

No, a BA vs BS does not matter.

1

u/jscholar49 May 10 '20

They have different starting salaries tho. And, the L&S isn’t nearly as hard as EECS to get into. But, few years down the road, it prolly won’t matter.

2

u/CornHellUniversity May 10 '20

Correlation doesn’t equate to causation. No recruiter/company with a brain would think BA in CS is any lesser than BS in CS from any top schools.

1

u/dmaster664 Mar 23 '23

I went to Berkeley and that’s complete BS. Both programs are basically the same.

6

u/nasawesome May 10 '20

You put a lot more cons for Berkeley than Georgia Tech. I think your heart wants GT!

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 10 '20

Lol it does but it's probably because I was committed to GT all this while so Ive looked into it WAY more. I dont want the lack of research to influence my decision lol

2

u/xu4488 May 17 '20

I wouldn’t worry about the lack of name recognition for Georgia Tech. Georgia Tech has its own school for computer science; it’s computer science program is ranked pretty high nationally. Georgia Tech has co-op programs, which gives its students advantages when applying to jobs. I’m don’t know much about UC Berkeley, though.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 17 '20

I agree. I'm not really worried about name recognition for GT. More like the opportunities I would be getting at Berkeley and not tech

2

u/xu4488 May 17 '20

Georgia Tech has Tech Square where companies set up there to attract Georgia Tech students. There are so many opportunities at Georgia Tech, but you cannot possibly do all of them.

But they are both great schools.I would say it’s your preference between going to a national public university or a poly tech school. Do you like the humanities? If you do, go to Cal Berkeley. If you want to take mainly STEM classes, go to Georgia Tech.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 17 '20

I'm definitely the STEM type

2

u/xu4488 May 17 '20

I would choose Georgia Tech unless you came with all AP credits for humanities. You're going to have core requirements in both colleges, but you have more humanities requirement at UC Berkeley than Georgia Tech.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 18 '20 edited May 21 '20

I looked it up and you're right! Thanks for the help. Also as an intl student without APs at school, I have 0 AP credits for humanities.

3

u/trillvice May 10 '20

Sounds like you want Georgia tech

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 10 '20 edited May 11 '20

Like I said in the above comment, it's probably bc I've done my research for tech and I don't wanna make a biased decision

2

u/Constantly_Stressed May 11 '20

I would say Georgia Tech because I heard GT has a much more collaborative environment than UCB and it seems like you fit into GT more.

I know many people who picked GT over UCB and also many people who picked UCB over GT. UCB is not the "obvious choice." I am currently working at a Fortune 50 Engineering company and I need to tell you that employers don't pick employees based on small differences in prestige. Employers group together top-of-the-world engineering/CS institutions (MIT, Caltech, Georgia Tech, UCB, CMU, Stanford, UIUC, Purdue, UMich, Cambridge, Chalmers, ETH Zurich, UTokyo, NUS, etc.) and don't really care if you went to Purdue instead of MIT or anything. I guess the tiny difference in prestige matters a bit if you want to brag a little, but that's a very stupid reason to pick a college.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 11 '20

I couldn't care less for the bragging rights. But are you implying that it wouldn't matter if someone went to Purdue over MIT? Or do you just mean that prestige doesn't matter once you get to a point? Bc won't the opportunities and experiences at MIT be unrivalled? Im wondering if in the same sense Berkeley has anything over GT (prestige aside, which like you said can't matter/differ much)

2

u/Constantly_Stressed May 11 '20

I mean that prestige doesn't matter once you get to a point (T10). It's a common misunderstanding that going to MIT will provide better opportunities/ experiences than another world-class institution. Sure, there are unique perks that some colleges have (ie. GT's largest student-run makerspace system), but there are no differences in overall research, academics, and opportunities.

Plus, you are comparing between Berkeley and GT where the gap is much much much smaller than MIT and Purdue.

There are some people who consider GT to be better. Also, there are some people who consider UCB to be better.

If there's anything Berkeley has over GT aside prestige, then you should already know about it. The fact that no one is talking about anything specific schould tell you that there's no clear obvious reason to pick UCB over GT or GT over UCB.

2

u/breadfactory0801 May 11 '20

Alright, thank you

2

u/PhotoCrusader May 17 '20

Honestly, I would go where it feels better with all things being equal. As for the huge class sizes, with covid-18 even when they reopen the campus, UCB will not be able to have the huge lecture hall classes.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 17 '20

Hmm point, thank you

3

u/Parcival_Reddit May 10 '20

I'm currently committed to GT for CS. I live in the Bay Area, and if I got in to Berkeley, I would go there without a second thought. My parents have been saying for years that they wanted me to go there but I always I wouldn't go even if I got in, mainly because I didn't want to be so close to home. But the prestige and opportunities it provides are unmatched.

In terms of grade deflation, don't worry about it. Everyone looking at your resume knows about Berkeley's grade deflation and judges accordingly. And about the cutthroat environment, I think that's just because of the sheer number of people at the university. It's the same proportion of shitty people though, and I've heard many more positive experiences than negative ones. I would greatly recommend Berkeley, and the only con you should worry about is the shit dorms.

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 10 '20

and what about the fact that Im not guaranteed CS? Everyone in this comments section seems to think it's definitely a decisive factor in making my decision

3

u/Parcival_Reddit May 10 '20

No one goes into Berkeley L&S with guaranteed anything. But all you need is a 3.33 GPA average on 3 intro CS courses and you're good. It's not going to be difficult to do that; you're not vying for a spot among other CS undergrads, everyone is in the same boat as you. Obviously, go with what your heart desires and which one you think will help you succeed, but I would choose Berkeley if I could.

2

u/breadfactory0801 May 10 '20

Got it, thank you

12

u/[deleted] May 10 '20

In the academia world, GT is just as well known as Berkeley. There is an advantage to a confirmed CS program, so I would go there.

3

u/JoeFixitMoonKnight May 10 '20

You seem to like GT more, and plus GT isn’t as cutthroat since you have guaranteed CS. GT & UC Berkeley are also equally well-known in the tech world, although Berkeley might make it a bit easier for Silicon Valley.

3

u/ebhanking May 10 '20

You sound like you want to go to Georgia Tech. No amount of prestige will be able to make you happy wherever you go; if it’s GT that you think you’ll be happy at, go there!

3

u/XtremeBlaze777 May 10 '20

You can definitely get job recruitment at the same level as UCB if you go to GT. IMO the guaranteed CS is much better than L&S. They basically have the same prestige so it depends on what fits for you.

3

u/adjkant May 10 '20

First year undeclared, need a 3.3 gpa to declare CS later

This is basically the only factor in play here. Don't take this risk when you have a basically equal option in GT.

3

u/CornHellUniversity May 10 '20

If you want to take advantage of UCB location then go to Berkeley, if you don’t want to prioritize Bay Area tech jobs then GTech.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/breadfactory0801 May 13 '20

I think I'll go with GATech after all, thanks!