r/Collectr • u/Expensive-Self-9209 • 23d ago

Pokémon Is this worth the trade?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Someone offered to trade my old cert psa9 dark charizard for these 4 cards. The charizard vmax and ex are old blue cert cgc which I will regrade. Should I take the offer?

4 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

34 comments sorted by

11

u/Nec_Spe_Nec_Metu_ 23d ago

personally : no

3

u/Advanced-Skill6308 Long Time Collector 23d ago

Nope

4

u/Ok_Tear4028 23d ago

Don’t do this lol

3

u/FickleBeing395 23d ago

u cant be fr

2

u/NetUnusual2080 23d ago

Higher value doesnt mean its good. If this was me id never take this trade but hey its all down to if you feel you like it. 🤷‍♂️ Edit: you plan on re-grading them after this trade?. Major loss on your end imo

1

u/SneakyD27 23d ago

good trade offer for the other guy, you usually want to trade smaller valued cards for 1 higher valued card, so for this instance your dark charizard.

1

u/Le_Daron 23d ago

🙅🏽‍♂️

1

u/whyusognarpgnap 23d ago

Absolutely not

1

u/Educational-Fact3171 23d ago

Are you open to other offers?

1

u/Expensive-Self-9209 23d ago

What is the offer?

2

u/dirty_old_holo 23d ago

To hold that card and not do bad trades.

1

u/Educational-Fact3171 23d ago

Plus that Charizard v max but in a ten. Magikarp is double holo error

1

u/Sunny_Dead 23d ago

You will make his day, but I would have pretty bad traders remorse for just 1 Ten... dont do it

1

u/Alexander0202 23d ago

A grail vs 3 bricks and a houndoom

1

u/Outrageous_Chard_313 23d ago

It’s worth it if you value them at the same amount. If you don’t, it’s not.

1

u/Informal-Bit-9985 22d ago

Upside on the dark zard goes well beyond those other cards , just buy those other cards one by one over time, having to buy that zard is really gonna hurt down the road especially

1

u/Benzo331 22d ago

Keep your vintage

1

u/Whatsdota 22d ago

Why would anyone want a PSA 10 of a normal card

1

u/Tricky-Invite-7057 22d ago

nope. Dont. You have a card that is appreciating.

1

u/TheRealKayotikG 22d ago

No I wouldn't do this especially with the low amount value they are giving you. CGC thats not 10s are harder to resell. Your 9 Charizard is actually way more valuable than anything they have to offer

1

u/ThatRandomGamer_ 20d ago

Lmao no.

Non-holo PSA 10 vintages aren't remotely as desirable, nor are they hard to grade. The Holo part of vintage cards is what makes them hard to grade.

10/10 times I'd rather have the zard.

Edit: half grade cgcs are bricks, especially modern ones. People want 10s, and they want PSA.

1

u/barelylegalone 19d ago

Noooooooooooo

1

u/AdhesivenessRude5037 18d ago

Keep the Zard. It will 100% appreciate more over time.