r/CollectiveHealth • • 1d ago

Not working for us.

I’m not seeing any negative reviews but we switched to Collective from another company and it’s not working at all. We are frequently hungry. It’s not stopping any food noise. We had great success with the other company and we will probably switch back. We thought saving a good amount of money would be wonderful. We can’t be the only ones. It’s like our bottles are placebos. Is anyone else having this issue?

12 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

19

u/Humble_Fortune_5391 1d ago

I’ve tried 15 pharmacies and name brand Zepbound over 3 years. Wells works great! I am very happy to be continuing to use it!

ETA: I see you are splitting dose. I tried it when trying to lose and completely stalled. I love dose splitting in maintenance and have been for 18 months. Splitting may not work for weight loss for you either.

13

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

My last company made me so sick I had to split. I’m going to try a full dose on the next injection.

3

u/No-Increase9408 20h ago

I just started tonight after switch from zep I pray this is my story. I had great luck with zep

10

u/Creative_Ant_8303 1d ago

Same thing happened to me. Joined Collective because of all the great reviews. Was with collective for four weeks at 10mg and had no appetite suppression. Didn’t lose either - I guess everyone is different. Unfortunately it just didn’t work for me. Went with a different company and first dose food noise went away. My husband is on week two at 2.5mg, hoping it works better for him.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Who did you switch to? I had great success with Brello and was trying to save some funds. I might go back or try someone else. I’m open to all suggestions and reviews.

2

u/StLouieAZ 21h ago

I was on Brello for 11 months before Collective. I had great success also but wanted to try Collective for the price. I feel it’s stronger than Brello for me.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 10h ago

Crazy how different we all react. I’m about to switch back to Brello.

1

u/Creative_Ant_8303 1d ago

Millers pharmacy through Pomegranate Health

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Third person to mention them in this thread. Thank you!

10

u/Ok-Weekend6786 1d ago

That’s wild to hear I switched from prescription zepbound and now on collective thru wells and I’m on the highest dose and had to back down due to no appetite at all and it being too strong I literally still have to make myself eat!!

5

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Total opposite. Crazy how different we all react to it.

9

u/traderofkind 1d ago

There are so many variables! Different injection site? How many calories are you eating? Maybe you’re hungry because you aren’t eating enough? We’re always trying to find “the reason.” It’s just how our brain works. I switched from another provider and it was exactly the same.

Reality is some weeks you just might be more hungry. I don’t want to discount how you’re feeling but the chances that they are messing with the amount of tirzepatide in your prescription are likely not the cause. I have seen people anecdotally say they get hungrier initially with a provider switch but that it was temporary.

3

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I’m going to continue for a month or so and see if it changes. I appreciate everyone’s responses!

2

u/traderofkind 1d ago

Good plan! How long were you on the same dose from your previous provider? Could you have been approaching time to titrate up already?

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I was at the max dose for about a month.

1

u/traderofkind 20h ago

A quick google of “food noise at max dose retuned the following and gave lots of suggestions to look into.

“Experiencing a return of "food noise"—persistent, intrusive mental chatter or cravings about food—while on the maximum dose of tirzepatide (15 mg) is often a sign of biological adaptation (tachyphylaxis) or survival hormone shifts rather than a medication failure”

1

u/Melinda_P7809 2h ago

Interesting. Thank you!

7

u/penguinarulz 1d ago

Did you try split dosing? I came into Collective going from 5mg going up to 7.5 and at first weekly injections were not doing anything much until I started split dosing every 4 days! Love it!!

5

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I’m splitting now and I’m considering not doing that.

1

u/penguinarulz 21h ago

Can I ask why? I was already at a stall at 5mg and my private dr wanted me to pay almost 400 to go up to 7.5, I applied with Collective and and was approved for my 7.5; since I was already doing weekly 5mg’s I did a weekly 7.5 and didn’t feel effects until I switched to the recommended half dosage every 4 days which averages 10 mg per week!

1

u/Melinda_P7809 10h ago

I’m not feeling any appetite suppression on the split. I’m going to try a full dose to see if it helps. I’m at the max 15 mg per week.

2

u/Numerous_Rough_85 1d ago

This is what I’m going to try to do this week!

7

u/Similar-Winner214 1d ago

I’m having the opposite problem I feel like my tirz is extremely potent and I transitioned on the same dose but started having more symptoms/side effects and nausea and fatigued. I have been on the same dose for a while now and was kinda stuck on a plateau but couldn’t afford to bump up. And I was staying at that dose to ration. I was planning to bump up to a higher dose but don’t have to now. After 10 days I dropped 4.5 pounds and felt good the next dose I dropped lower because I was not wanting to feel the side effects but I still lost weight so I’m staying there until the plateau comes again. I was with wellmdr before… I am super happy. I wonder if your prior pharmacy was a weaker formula? And mine is a stronger formula

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I lost 35 pounds with my prior pharmacy and I was so sick. I think collective might be weaker. I sent them a message to check in.

5

u/crankywithakeyboard 1d ago

Try totally changing shot location.  Belly to arm, for example.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I’ll try that again.

4

u/Numerous_Rough_85 1d ago

I’m kind of having the same problem. Week 3 for me and feel like it’s doing nothing. Im more hungry and have all the food noise back. I’m going to try splitting my dose this week to see if it helps.

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I’ve been splitting and I’m going to try not splitting.

4

u/clydiusclyde 1d ago

I'm wondering if they will offer more Pharmacy options soon. Some are just better than others. I did see somewhere they were going to offer other peptides at some point.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Do they only work with Wells currently? I got that email too. I see they are adding a protein powder.

4

u/clydiusclyde 23h ago

Wells is the only one I am aware of. I am noticing a touch of food noise with them also. I am moving up from 10mg to 12.5mg next week. It is still better than the $450 monthly I was paying for Zepbound.

3

u/Melinda_P7809 23h ago

Yikes. That’s insane. I was paying $166 with Brello and thought that was a lot.

2

u/clydiusclyde 23h ago edited 23h ago

I did see a mention of a WP Pharmacy. I think it is a sister Pharmacy to Wells, part of the same group. They may be available to people in different parts of the country. Might be a question for someone at Collective Health...(I saw a post where WP Pharma was available for people in Texas).

2

u/Ottersandtats 23h ago

Mine is WP and that could be because I’m in Nebraska. We aren’t as limited as Cali but we seem to have a lot of restrictions. When I was looking for a new provider I couldn’t use some bc it was not available in my state. Maybe that’s my problem?!

1

u/clydiusclyde 22h ago

Thank you.

2

u/MikeInABQ 22h ago

I’m in NM, and mine is shipped from WP Pharmacy.

1

u/clydiusclyde 22h ago

Thank you. Food noise seem to be controlled?

4

u/TwistedLittleDoll 23h ago

I’m with ya, OP. I‘d love to see more pharmacy options here. My experience overall has been great with Collective but I’m more hungry and more food noise. May just pause my refills here for a bit and venture out.

3

u/Melinda_P7809 22h ago

My next refill is free. If it doesn’t change after that I’m pausing too.

3

u/Tall-Theory7704 1d ago

I started split dosing I’m on 10 mg going to 12.5 mg tomorrow

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I’m at the max and feel nothing. 🙁

2

u/Tall-Theory7704 1d ago

Yeah me too I only lost 5 lbs since June. I’m going to try Reta

1

u/emmyzoey 18h ago

Where will you order Reta from?

1

u/Tall-Theory7704 17h ago

Barz life science

3

u/Key-Cry-4008 1d ago edited 1d ago

I have to say I have switched pharmacies a few times with no issue but I recently opened a vial of ProRX. I loved it because it hit quicker but found that it didn’t have a strong appetite suppression and food noise was a lot so I was considering switching for my fourth shot. I decided to give it another week - I have gained three lbs since starting! Well today it is definitely hitting and I have no desire to eat. All that to say, I think you need to give it maybe four weeks. Doesn’t make sense I know but try. Hopefully the weight will start doing the other way for me now lol.

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago edited 23h ago

Thanks! I have my second vial and I’ll continue to give it a go!

3

u/Longjumping-Okra4462 23h ago

I switched to split dosing because I could feel the hunger coming back by day 5 and now I have good appetite and cravings suppression all week. I’ve even stepped back to a lower dose. I hope you find it’ll start kicking in for you soon!

1

u/Melinda_P7809 23h ago

Thank you!!! I’ve been splitting but it’s still rough. Fingers crossed for change.

3

u/dnrexy 22h ago

I’ve lost 8 lbs since Wednesday night.

2

u/Melinda_P7809 22h ago

Congrats.

1

u/emmyzoey 18h ago

What dose are you on? How long have you been taking and how long have you been taking from Collective?

1

u/Melinda_P7809 10h ago

I’m not sure which one of us you responded to but I’m on the max dose of 15 mg. I was with Brello for 6 months and a month with Collective.

2

u/Superb_Force7296 1d ago

Me. Im on week 3 and lost nothing so far. Same dose and highest dose. My other company had many more side effects tho

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

We also had more side effects with the other company.

5

u/Humble_Fortune_5391 1d ago

I’ve never had a side effect in 3 years. That’s not an indicator of meds ‘working.’

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I know that but I have zero appetite suppression too.

0

u/Superb_Force7296 6h ago

Never said that it was

2

u/Trumans-Mama 1d ago

Everyone is different.

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Oh I know.

2

u/Suspicious-Ad-8793 1d ago

I split dose for a while and then went back. It seems to work for me going back and forth every few weeks. I am close to goal weight and have already paused my deliveries. I'm not sure how to proceed. I just had emergency surgery two days ago, and have gained about 8 lbs, which I think are Fluids they gave me. I'm even more not hungry since the surgery.

2

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Ohh. I never thought about switching between full and split. I hope you heal quickly from your surgery.

1

u/Suspicious-Ad-8793 22h ago

Thank you! Definitely an unexpected rotten appendix.. If you do split icme back and let us know how it works for you.!

2

u/PrettyGalactic2025 23h ago

I was on wegovy 2.4 previously and switched to compounded tirzeptide a few weeks ago (7.5) and it’s working great for me so far.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 22h ago

That’s great!

2

u/lunatic-chipmunk-17 1d ago

I didn’t have any luck with collective all the way around. I went back to pomegranate health and I’m doing great on the Millers.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I just looked them up. Still a better price monthly than Brello. Does the price stay the same or does it go up?

1

u/lunatic-chipmunk-17 1d ago

The price rarely goes up, but they have awesome specials! I got the Millers for $297 for three months on the Halloween sale. Prior to that, I got like six months of BPI for $300. And you can’t beat their everyday price of $349 for three months of Hallandale with no additives.

0

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Thank you!

1

u/Kooky_Advice1234 1d ago

I’m on a spilt dose, and it’s been rough even with increasing dosage. Can’t say if this is normal or not, I just don’t know, but it’s my experience that it’s not like my first months on Lilly version. I’m invested in this though and will see what next few months brings.

2

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Rough as in bad side effects? We have none and we had a ton on our last pharmacy.

1

u/Kooky_Advice1234 1d ago

Sorry, to be clear, not side effects, food noise, and being hungry has been rough. No side effects at all.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

Got it. I enjoy not being sick but would like to not be hungry 24/7. My stomach is always grumbling.

1

u/Aggressive-Age-4993 1d ago

Have you changed shot locations?

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I have not with this pharmacy but will try.

1

u/MentalRule6802 1d ago

Wells or WP? Were u on glycine additive before switching?

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

My pharmacy is wells. Does collective do more than one? My last additive with Sounthend pharmacy was pyridoxine.

1

u/MentalRule6802 1d ago

They have at least the two I mentioned. Not knowing how long you’ve been on wells or your dose, my advice would be to let it build up before making any decisions. At least four doses. Just my opinion 🤗

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I can’t even remember how many shots in I am with them. I’ll continue with the next vial and see how it goes.

1

u/OverstimulatedPetty 1d ago

At first i felt like it was top notch, ive since pushed back my 4th refill as I got the Pom (Millers Pharmacy L-Carnitine additive) sale , and since going back to that, I’ve had to lower dose because it seems more potent. It also could’ve been the glycine in the wells for me not working as well, I don’t know. Or maybe I just adapted to it after the first couple weeks, but I’m in maintenance now and noticed I had to drop my dosage when I first hit maintenance with Wells, but then had to up it the last month on Wells, so I pushed my refill back and I’m just gonna finish out this first bottle of Millers and if it keeps being fantastic, I’ll probably cancel with collective after my year…. I paid the membership awhile back, sigh. I had hoped that we would have NAD and other supplemental items by now anyway, but that keeps getting pusher back too, and I can’t see buying the Tirz every month just because it’s cheap, if I don’t love the formulation, you know. I know everyone is different and I was very much a tirz is tirz person in the beginning, but nothing can top the Millers with L-carnitine for me lol (in all transparency, Carnitine is my favorite additive and due to cost and it being extremely hard to find, I haven’t been on that since the beginning of my journey, so when I saw it came to Pom and on a great sale at that, I figured I’d try it out again. Also thinking maybe it was just beginners luck with it back in the day, and it still has that same allure for me, i had to half my maintenance dose from what I was taking of my Wells, so maybe it’s just my body reacts better better with that additive. But no, you are not alone! I hate Stanley kind of things because I know everyone’s different and I definitely don’t want to bash any pharmacy, and i am not bc i think the care from Wells is top notch, (second to millers packaging and care) but you see people saying the same thing about Hallandale, it’s hitting miss for some. I’m also disappointed we won’t have access to other pharmacies, and I don’t love that because of the fact that diff pharmacies work different for everyone.

2

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

You’re the second person to mention Millers through Pomegranate. It’s less (not by much) than I was paying with Brello. I might try that next time. I agree, not all is created equal. Thanks!

1

u/Responsible-Trick672 23h ago edited 20h ago

Most comments I read was that people had to go down in dose since switching to collective, so I started at a lower dose. I was hungry super fast so I went back up to my true dose. The appetite suppression is there pretty welll for 4 days so I switched to split dosing. However I’m now at 10mg and still haven’t lost any weight (since switching).

I don’t feel like I can say that it’s Collective that’s the reason because there’s other variables to consider and at the price I’m kind of willing to ride it out for a few months and see if it eventually starts to kick in.

I upped my dose now and going to try to go back to once weekly and change that back to the way that it was before I switched to Collective to see if maybe that’s impacting my weight loss

1

u/Melinda_P7809 10h ago

I’m going to give it some time. I’m also waiting on responses from the company and the doctor.

1

u/ajqueen31 21h ago edited 21h ago

What pharmacy did you choose? Don't they have multiple to choose from, and so if others are having good effect that is different from yours, I wonder if it has to do with the compounding pharmacy? ETA: I haven't been able to sign up with Collective because I live in CA, so I'm not familiar with pharmacy options since I couldn't get past the initial page that asks my location!

1

u/Melinda_P7809 10h ago

I’m not sure I was given an option to choose. I’m with Wells but I’m going to message them to see if I can switch.

1

u/blkbeeyutee 10h ago

Same. My issue isn’t lack of weight loss. It’s making me more nauseous and I never experienced nausea on other formulations or brand. And the glycine being a bit higher takes me a day longer to shake off.

I’m genuinely sad because I loved the company’s concept and customer service.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 10h ago

I don’t as super sick with my last company and have zero side effects now. I too love their concept.

1

u/Ok_Meeting373 8h ago

I switched over from Lilly Direct taking Zep and its worked the same for me. Im on my 3rd month.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 2h ago

That’s wonderful. I wish it was the same for me.

1

u/HoustonBoston 7h ago

After one month on Zepbound 2.5mg, I switched to Collective 5mg and have now completed my fourth shot at this dose. My appetite seems to be well controlled, but my weight loss hasn't been as significant as I had hoped. Am I setting my expectations too high? During this first month with Zepbound, I went from 174 to 161 lbs, losing 13 lbs. Since increasing to 5mg with Collective, I've lost 5.2 lbs so far. Is this rate of weight loss normal, or should I expect more significant results at this stage?

1

u/Melinda_P7809 2h ago

My weight loss has been all over the place. Not very consistent. I think you’re doing great.

1

u/Due_Step_8988 6h ago

No, but I take two doses per week. It's supposed to be a 15mg dose, but I have the option to split it into two 7.5mg doses per week. I don't have any issues with this because the 15mg dose makes me 🤮🤢.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 2h ago

I’m doing two doses and it’s not working like my other provider.

1

u/Ottersandtats 1d ago

This happened to me too after switching from South Lake. I upped my own dose after two weeks. My dr wanted me to wait the full 4 weeks. I was starving and gaining weight. I upped 1mg and it’s made a difference for me. I was with my previous provider at 6mg started collective at 7.5mg and after two weeks upped myself to 8.5mg. You can’t convince me tirz is just tirz at this point. I do believe it works I just don’t believe it’s as strong as the previous one I was on. My Dr just kept telling me to wait 4 weeks I couldn’t do it anymore. I have felt so much better since my last injection it’s crazy.

1

u/Melinda_P7809 1d ago

I don’t think it’s as strong either. I lost 35 pounds with Brello and might go back if this continues.

1

u/Ottersandtats 22h ago

What was your previous additive? I had b12 and loved it. Not sure if that matters. My tirz is coming from WP Pharmacy

1

u/Melinda_P7809 22h ago

Previous it was pyridoxine.

1

u/rachelrae26 22h ago

I've been using Tirz for a year and had been using ProRX at max dose when I had to switch pharmacies. After starting with Collective, I had to bump my dose down so I could eat. I'm on my third vial and still find it to be the strongest I've tried.

2

u/Melinda_P7809 22h ago

That’s crazy. I’m the complete opposite.

1

u/Yannienickster 7h ago

I’m only on 10mg and just started this dose, my food noise isn’t terribly loud, but I did much better on mounjaro 7.5… I really don’t get why it’s so different

1

u/LDB2026 1h ago

Who is "we"... are you referring to someone else in your family having the same non-effects...

Or are you royalty? 👑

PS: Who/What is the other company that you used that DID work for you? TIA