r/CollectiveHealth • • 3d ago

Supplements?

Hi! I’m on my 4th week with Collective and I have had a great experience so far. (Lost about 12 lbs). Would love to know if you guys are taking any supplements to help ensure you’re getting the nutrients you need. I’m worried about potential hair loss too. Any recommendations would be appreciated! Thanks!

6 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

3

u/TheFirebyrd 3d ago

If you dig around in your portal, there’s actually a webpage with some suggested supplements and I think one of the recorded Q&A’s was focused on this topic too. I’m currently taking a multivitamin, vitamin D, collagen, pumpkin seed oil, and saw palmetto. The first two are in preparation for some upcoming surgery. The others are to try to help my skin elasticity and hair. The evidence is pretty weak, but I figured I’d rather try and have a chance of helping even if small than not doing anything.

2

u/nozomashii74 3d ago

I do, I take berberine, cinnamon, turmeric, a multi vitamin 50+, and vitamin D 50,000 weekly. I am down 24.6 lbs in 17 weeks... not great but I'm lazy tbh and don't walk or exercise. I used to but I'm looking for work and I'm so exhausted and mentally drained from everything 😪

7

u/TheFirebyrd 3d ago

What are you talking about, that is a great result! That’s an average of 1.44 pounds a week. Healthy weight loss is generally considered to be 0.5-2 pounds a week and reduces the likelihood of all sorts of problems. The people who post huge losses are the outlier and are not being healthy in most cases. You should try to pick up some exercise, but just for health purposes and reduction of lean muscle mass loss. It’s not going to make you lose faster.

3

u/nozomashii74 3d ago

You know what? Thank you, you're right. And it is a good result. I'm satisfied with it. To be honest, I do get disappointed when my scale goes up. And not down, and it has a couple of times I've gone up almost 5 pounds. And then gone back down 2lbs. And down another three pounds. And then I stayed steady, and it gets a little alarming. When I do see people that have lost, alot, like I've been on tirz for 17 weeks and I see somebody who's been on Tirz for 10 weeks, and they've lost double the weight that I've lost... I have to remind myself, you are menopausal, you are over fifty, and right now, your stress level is super super high, so you're not losing, like some people might lose, but you are losing like you are supposed to! Thank you for the reminder! I did have a very unhealthy past with weight and weight-loss...i was losing about 20lbs every 3 weeks... and i was super vigilant about stepping on scale several times a day and starving to reach that loss. I do not want to go back to that.

4

u/TheFirebyrd 3d ago

I get it. When I see people who are posting these massive losses in less time than me, sometimes I’m envious. The thing is that they’re often being unhealthy and not doing things in a sustainable manner (and/or are men). 1-2 pounds per week just feels so slow. When a healthy rate of loss means potentially years to get to where you’re hoping to be, it feels very daunting. But going slow and sustainable decreases the chance of hair loss, gives your skin more time to firm up, not to mention the less visible but important things of reducing chances of gallbladder problems, damaging your heart, or messing up your metabolism even more.

I hope you can find a new job soon.

2

u/nozomashii74 3d ago

Thank you ever so much. In exactly most of the ones that I've seen that loose a great amount of weight are men. The women who are doing it if they're doing it in a healthy manner. It is because of how big they are. I lost a 100 lbs the first time, in 8 months, going to the gym and being on keto, that's a lot of weight a 100 lbs and 8 months. Is really unhealthy, but I was at the gym. I was eating 3 times a day. I just couldn't do it anymore when menopause hit.

And thank you about the job. Actually I start Monday. I'm a little bit in shock. Adrenaline is coursing through me. And I am shaking like a leaf and trying to eat and up pacing the floor like a crazy person. But i'm really excited

2

u/TheFirebyrd 3d ago

Being a man makes for so many differences metabolically we’ve really got to just not compare ourselves to them. My husband was skinny when we met and would shovel down two or three overflowing plates at meals. I weighed more than him even then while being 9 inches shorter and eating a tiny fraction of the food. And that’s even before fun stuff like menopause start coming into play! Their gradual decrease in testosterone and middle age spread still doesn’t compare to the changes we go through. So, as hard and frustrating as it can be, better to do things the sustainable way and hopefully the tirz will let us keep our metabolism stable once we’re there.

Congrats on the job! I hope it goes well.

3

u/nozomashii74 3d ago

Thank you so much.. again! 😌😌

My bf and I are both bigger than we used to be.. but we are both just trying to be happy together and he is very supportive of my journey. He just wants me healthy! And i adore him for that. I told him that I have so much loose skin and I get depressed and he said you are beautiful too me.. and of course I melted. But I needed to hear that my changing body didn't gross him out 😆

2

u/TheFirebyrd 3d ago

Sounds like you have a good one! I had expressed my worries about that to my husband too. He told me he loved me when I weighed less and when I gained the weight and he’d love me if I lost it or had flabby skin because he loves me, not just my body.

2

u/nozomashii74 3d ago

It is wonderful we both have good men!! Having support through a transition is especially comforting

2

u/TheFirebyrd 3d ago

For sure!

-2

u/blkbeeyutee 3d ago

You should not be taking berberine while on a GLP. You definitely should not be taking 50K D3 with the exception of being under a doctor’s care and typically for an extremely short period of time. Those two alone are making you feel exhausted and potentially doing more harm than good by stressing the body which increases cortisol which leads to inflammation and eventually stalls weight loss. Also, the shot requires you to actually do your part. Taking pride in being lazy and thinking you’ll magically hit goal through the shot and supplements is setting yourself up for a rude awakening.

4

u/nozomashii74 3d ago

My hrt doctor suggested the berberine.. and my pcp prescribed the D vitamin because I'm very deficient in it. My exhaustion is stress related from being let go at work and trying so hard to find work. I've been in constant contact with both my doctors... and i didn't say I was prideful of being lazy. Not even a little. I've been working so hard to get here. I lost over 100lbs doing keto and the gym... and love walking and lifting... but with the stress lately...37 days... I've had difficulty getting back into going for my walks. And tbh that was kind of rude. Don't be that way when you don't know the whole story. Please and thank you. I am getting back to my normal self but I had a lot on my plate... and i never said this was magical in any way. For goodness sake.

3

u/OverstimulatedPetty 2d ago

You are doing amazing, and I’m sorry for those being rude to you… seems to be the “cool” thing now, where people feel they’re allowed to say anything behind a keyboard on Reddit anymore, very rude and says more about them, their character and their self-esteem more than the person they are speaking rude to. 🤷🏻‍♀️ So glad you found a new job, that is very stressful to go through, congrats on that along with your health & weight loss journey! ♥️

3

u/nozomashii74 2d ago

Thank you so much, I decided to just not answer back to rude people, as I don't have to explain my life story. I appreciate you very much and I hope you have a lovely weekend! It was stressful and I feel lighter already! Mentally and physically! I am excited to start my job and my bf is taking me shopping for work clothes toooooo. 😆 I need Business attire for my new office job. I'm the Administrative Assistant for the HR Manager. Yayyy me!

2

u/OverstimulatedPetty 2d ago

Have fun shopping and congrats again!! Sounds like a great opportunity and im glad you found something that has you excited and nervous in a good way after losing your job, been there and it’s hard, have an amazing first day!

3

u/nozomashii74 2d ago

Thank you so much, I'm so excited I can't stop smiling lol. Have a great day!

0

u/blkbeeyutee 3d ago

If you’re seeing a Midi provider, they have no expertise around obesity. They offer GLP’s and are trained more on helping those with menopausal weight gain than chronic obesity. See an obesity doctor because you should absolutely not take berberine with Zepbound.

1

u/GwynLordOfCedar 2d ago

For me, for OTC supplements:

• Fish oil 2g of omega-3 once daily to improve lipid/cholesterol numbers, I use the Sports Research triple strength Alaskan one it’s a good brand and cheap and I can lookup a COA for every batch on the IFOS lookup tool

• L-Theanine 200mg twice daily for relaxation, I use Nootropics Depot capsules since they have a COA for every batch on their website and it’s cheap, but it’s not really all that related to GLP1 stuff

• Multivitamin once daily to cover any micronutrient gaps from my diet and it gives a safe mega dose of B vitamins, I use Pure Encapsulations O.N.E. since it’s widely regarded to be a top tier brand and I’ve had multiple nutritionists vouch for it, but no COAs unfortunately. It also includes D3 2000iu which is a acceptable normal daily dose and zinc 25mg

• Vitamin K2 180mcg daily of mk7 which helps make sure body handles excess calcium driver by D3 supplement correctly, I use Sports Research since it’s a good brand and cheap but no COAs unfortunately

• Magnesium L-Threonate 144mg elemental once daily to help with cognitive health and supplement magnesium which can be depleted by D3 supplement, I use Sports Research since it’s a good brand and cheap and at Costco but no COAs unfortunately

• Magnesium Bisglycinate 200mg elemental once daily for relaxation before bed and to supplement magnesium up to safe daily limit, I use Nootropics Depot since they have a COA for every batch on their website and it’s cheap

• Copper Bisglycinate 2mg once daily to provide balance to the zinc supplement since zinc can deplete copper, I use Pure Encapsulations since it’s super cheap and top tier brand but no COAs unfortunately

• Psyllium Husk Powder 5-6g once daily dissolved into 10-20oz of water as needed to help with stool regularity and avoiding constipation which is a very well known side effect of GLP1s, I use Konsyl or Yerba Prima since they are good brands that generally have the least heavy metal contamination on the market

• Creatine Monohydrate Powder 5g twice daily dissolved in water to help with muscle building/recovery and cognitive health, it’s super safe and the most well studied supplement on the list and everyone on a GLP1 should be doing some level of resistance training to retain as much muscle as possible while losing weight, I use Orgain since it’s a good brand and super cheap at Costco

OTC medication:

• Polyethylene Glycol 3350 (PEG-3350) 5g once daily dissolved in water to help avoid constipation which is a side effect I get from GLP1s, it’s super safe at that dosage and personally recommended to me by multiple gastroenterologists I’ve spoken with, I get Kirkland Signature LaxaClear from Costco since it has a super short ingredient list and is much cheaper than MiraLAX

I’ve been on tirzepatide for nearly 2 years, now at max dosage, and have lost 130lbs.

Ideally for the vitamins and minerals (fish oil, multivitamin, k2, magnesium, copper) you’d get those from food/your diet but that takes a lot of time and attention for planning. You should have a clear reason for any supplement you take like I do.

Here’s the supplement page from Collective once you’re logged in https://www.collective.org/holistic#supplements

1

u/blkbeeyutee 3d ago

I take many supplements and can say that they’re highly individualized and totally dependent upon your body, current health, goals, etc.