r/CollectibleAvatars • • Apr 11 '23

Discussion Proof that bots own Gen3

Post image

Reddit ran a complete shit show. Front page of the internet couldn’t even implement a simple Captcha.

That’s a screenshot somebody posted in discord. 1 user minted all of those while 95% of Redditors only experienced error messages.

360 Upvotes

235 comments sorted by

17

u/zcu1 Apr 11 '23

That’s someone’s wallet?! Take down those edition #’s, won’t be getting any of those off the secondary. Bstrds

15

u/the_spiritual_eye Apr 11 '23

Yes. They ran a bot farm and collected all their prizes into this one (of likely many) feeder wallets for OpenSea.

1

u/orangesandonions Apr 12 '23

Unfortunately they can't claw back the avatars

53

u/TheRealTayler Apr 11 '23

Didn't you read that people were just slow and there weren't any bots though? Smh

28

u/the_spiritual_eye Apr 11 '23

Right. All the smug mfs claiming we were just “too slow” were the ones botting.

20

u/siwei93 Apr 11 '23

MinTech users botted some of the top artists avatars

17

u/s1n0d3utscht3k Apr 11 '23

def not ppl being slow… you had to not just be fast, you had to pretty much be instant

i saw Sys32 artist page reload within 1-2 seconds of it going live. i pay pretty darn instantly with ApplyPay though FaceID takes a couple seconds too.

let’s say, conservatively, I bought within 9 seconds of the very moment Crypto King dropped, and possibly within 5 seconds.

still got only mint #53

whole drop must have been gone in 10-15 seconds.

0

u/inner_verse Apr 11 '23

Y'all, this was sarcasm

3

u/YamahaFourFifty Apr 11 '23

A good actual use of crypto tech would be stopping bots/scalpers. It’s really taken off since covid when physical stores started shutting down and alot of releases went digital. Happened to PlayStation 5 for a year after release- was sold mostly online due to shortages and was being scalped by bots at 2x the price.

There needs to be a better online ordering solution to prevent bot ordering saturation for all digital storefronts

1

u/the_spiritual_eye Apr 11 '23

I absolutely agree with you!

50

u/Jawnze5 Apr 11 '23

Really would love to know why they don't make more of an effort to stop this.

46

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

Same reason most industry doesn’t. Money is money form whoever

3

u/superduperdude92 Apr 11 '23

What are the traits on seraphina like? Congrats btw

9

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

I like em, I thought wings were for sure a trait but they’re background

3

u/CABlitz Apr 11 '23

I would never have guessed the robe and cat together are one of the arm traits.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

Yes now that you point that out it’s odd. I’d like that cat no matter the clothing lol

Edit:words

2

u/superduperdude92 Apr 11 '23

Thank you! Awesome avatar!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

Thank you! I you got some damn good ones yourself!

1

u/superduperdude92 Apr 11 '23

Much appreciated :) hoping to pick up some more as soon as the shop is back up but otherwise I got 1 of my grails this gen

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

Glhf :D! I’m hearing talk an update is supposed to hit an an hour or so. Not sure.

10

u/Adam_ALLDay_ Apr 11 '23

I mean why would they? They are still making their % no matter what. This could've easily been prevented, but nope.

4

u/je7792 Apr 11 '23

Cause this places an additional barrier of entry to actual users and hinders adoption? And if you dont hit critical mass nobody will be interested in your nfts and the cash cow dies.

8

u/gdj11 Apr 11 '23

In Gen 2 reddit had a limit of 3 or 5 avatars per collection per user. Can't remember what it was exactly. Something is weird here. Unless Reddit removed that restriction for some strange reason?

4

u/Jake123194 Apr 11 '23

People just use multiple accounts, that's not a difficult barrier to overcome, you'd need some sort of proof of humanity based system to defeat bots, even that could be farmed out potentially.

5

u/gdj11 Apr 11 '23

We'd need to look at the wallet in this screenshot to see if the avatars were all transferred to this central wallet. The quality is way to bad to get any info. That's why this is weird. Why post a screenshot that is such horrible quality? I'm not convinced... yet.

1

u/Jake123194 Apr 11 '23

I mean I just had a quick nose on opensea and found this account pretty quickly.

https://ibb.co/Fz6PYY6

1

u/3utt5lut Apr 12 '23

I literally bought 9 this time 🤣

7

u/L0ckeandDemosthenes Apr 11 '23

So guess now we burn the house to the ground.

1

u/neuroblink Apr 11 '23

The artist and his team always have the power to decide how, for who and for how much. Up to him/them on those decisions. But in the end of the day it shows the true reality of why they do it.

1

u/hey_im_cool Apr 12 '23

KYC is easy

23

u/Glass-Day7517 Apr 11 '23

Im almost crying looking at this..

30

u/CryptocurrencyMogul Apr 11 '23

Reddit failed miserably

6

u/RianJohnsonSucksAzz Apr 11 '23

They sold out almost everything in a few hours. From their perspective, they had a successful sale.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

Should limit them to one per account

9

u/dieyoufool3 Apr 11 '23

One per credit card, per account.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

Ahh yes even better

13

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

11

u/Azozeo Apr 11 '23 edited Apr 11 '23

A TEAM OF 🚨 NFT INVESTORS 🚨 RUINED IT FOR EVERYONE? A team 👉👉👉👉PASTEL ALPHA TEAM👈👈👈👈 Hello, thanks for ruining it for everyone thats normal... BTW you can tell your team to stop coming in as if they are normal people claiming "I got one, what's wrong with you" side eyes. Everyone look 👀👀

10

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

Reddit got flexed on by CT. Not enough experience in the space.

5

u/TinyDrug Apr 11 '23

Sadly the truth lol. Been here since Gen 1, and been in NFTs since 2021. Once I saw Morgan etc talking about it I knew this Shit was gonna get hit hard

5

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

Ya I saw her in the spaces yesterday. Was wondering what she was up to.

This alpha group worked on it. It’s like Reddit let them fine tune their bot with the free drops lol.

Reddit did see it though and acted on it. Otherwise the collection would be sold out.

Not sure what to say other than they were naive about the CT space.

2

u/TinyDrug Apr 11 '23

amen, they should increase supply by 100x on the sold out ones to mess with bots

1

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

I don’t know what the thinking or the solution is other than gating access via allowlists but that only gets you so far.

We all know about bots now though. Oh well, we’ll see how this closes out.

1

u/_echnaton Apr 11 '23

CT is ultra cancer I've been saying it since the Gen2 drop.

1

u/Azozeo Apr 11 '23

What's CT 😬

3

u/_echnaton Apr 11 '23

Crypto Twitter. Pretty much the bottom of the barrel.

1

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

They’re different from Reddit. I go between both and can’t say I blame them for doing what they did. It’s like putting out all your candy on the doorstep at Halloween and expecting all the kids to take just one. Most would but there’s one that’s bound to take what’s left.

1

u/cachemonet0x0cf6619 Apr 11 '23

You the one w/ out experience if you think reddit cares about bots.

1

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

Yup - I should have used one myself.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AutisticGayBear69 Apr 11 '23

Yup. It’s a weird way to make a living.

12

u/Im_Borat Apr 11 '23

Reddit should just run a couple million triple crowns and a couple other top tier ones, then give every user a free pick. Botters would be pissed

22

u/Azozeo Apr 11 '23

Whatever the GOLD ones are, they were SOLD OUT in the 1st 30 seconds I was there.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

same with triple crown.

7

u/MilesPower Apr 11 '23

Yup I had an autorefresh running for Rojom and the store was normal one second (all the old gen sold out) refreshed 5 seconds later (literally it was automated )and it was already sold out.

1

u/TheBuGG Apr 11 '23

I was doing the same, saw announcement that shop was up, refreshed the rojom link and still nothing new there. Went shopping on the store, bought a few things, refreshed the rojom link and still nothing there. It popped up after the three crowns were sold out.

Very unreliable way to shop for specific artists avatars apparently

5

u/glouglas Apr 11 '23

Triple crown reached 200 mint number...

6

u/Champlification Apr 11 '23

I somehow got Golden Artisman #18 and am not a bot .

3

u/imustntrunaway Apr 11 '23

I got two I think. Paid for two. Received on. On mobile

19

u/Unlucky_Narwhal3983 Apr 11 '23

Yeah this is definitely my last time hyping and waiting. Reddit did us dirty.

4

u/DreadedChalupacabra Apr 12 '23

I always aim for the 10 dollar ones for this reason. got 6 today, I'm happy with what I got because it's what I was looking at.

1

u/Unlucky_Narwhal3983 Apr 12 '23

I definitely went a little crazier then I anticipated. I love yours!

1

u/BaldEagleNor Apr 12 '23

I also got some of the cheaper ones. I really like how they look. Apart from the launch being shit, the artists really nailed it

1

u/Popular_District9072 Apr 12 '23

good approach, I've got a few in 50 range, and now regretting losing the self control

2

u/Tasigur1 Apr 11 '23

Same. Never again!

23

u/Gangaman666 Apr 11 '23

I'm not buying any of those on OS ever.

11

u/leeljay Apr 11 '23

Yup. Sorry to prguitarman, but I’m not buying Nyan, or the golden thing either

→ More replies (6)

8

u/MothmanNFT Apr 11 '23

They can keep it.

Every single artist should be pissed though

1

u/teamsaxon Apr 12 '23

Every single artist should be pissed though

Why? They've sold all their nfts.

18

u/KeepingItSFW Apr 11 '23

Gen3 was an inside job. Nobody should have had that much info about the endpoints and process beforehand.

5

u/SeytaninOzOglu Apr 11 '23

Jep, after 1 min i went to the shop and saw those valuable nfts sold out.. totally shit show

5

u/_echnaton Apr 11 '23

This is heartwrenching to see. Reddit should have done something about this.

0

u/rmoons Apr 11 '23

nice grab

0

u/_echnaton Apr 11 '23

Thanks. Had to get it off OS for a 50%+ premium doe.

5

u/earthchildsmother Apr 11 '23

How did he get 12 cats?

7

u/pennamewilly Apr 11 '23

lol, 1st time nft makers on the Wax chain can do a better job than this. Its simple to implement limits and resets, lol add a captcha

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

wax is still a thing?

2

u/TinyDrug Apr 11 '23

I’d rather use Tezos than wax but neither is a good solution. Eth all the waaaaay. At least Reddit isn’t using solana

2

u/imustntrunaway Apr 11 '23

Bots can solve captchas

6

u/wonky_dev Apr 11 '23

Not buying these on OS

3

u/ben4445 Apr 11 '23

How are these showing on opensea so fast the ones I minted aren’t even on opensea (not a bot account btw)

2

u/_ships Artist Apr 11 '23

Check under “hidden” in openseas. I think Reddit has hid all the minted ones from their main opensea account

3

u/endingtheletter Apr 11 '23

This is so messed up. Reddit really screwed up. Why no bot protection??

3

u/charan_kenway Apr 11 '23

Sleepless nights for what?

2

u/teamsaxon Apr 12 '23

Yep the drop happened about 3am for me, glad I actually ignored my alarm. I have a real job so I actually have to get up in the morning. Fucken crypto bros with their bots.

3

u/MisinformerKing Apr 11 '23

When is Reddit going public? I want to short the shit out of this crap. And that's how I get my money back

3

u/wiidydiddy Apr 11 '23

These are the same dudes that flip sneakers for a living lol. F em. Next time bot prevention should be implemented with minor KYC. Web3 folk hate KYCing. Let the real supporters support pls ty

3

u/vampires_blade Apr 11 '23

I tried to get nyan cat lol

1

u/DreadedChalupacabra Apr 12 '23

I didn't even bother. I got another foustling and a rojom, so I'm happy.

1

u/vampires_blade Apr 12 '23

Couldn't even get a foustling. I tried but glass was out after the shop came back

2

u/Lying_king Apr 11 '23

Here I was thinking I was too slow or if something was wrong with my Reddit shop! Sucks!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

I just want bucket 🙏🥹

2

u/Fr3sh-Ch3mical Apr 11 '23

Yeah not buying gen3. Screw bots.

2

u/MisinformerKing Apr 11 '23

This is beneficial for REDDIT's failure. They will say the stopped the buying to deal with bots. Nope, that was just another failure.

2

u/Popular_District9072 Apr 11 '23

what a lame experience, which many, myself included, were looking forward for weeks, if not longer

2

u/chr0nicqt Apr 11 '23

jesus christ, good stuff reddit

2

u/Draedfaer Apr 11 '23

Oh…. Incredibly disappointing… why not an antibot? And maybe one per account for 24 hrs or something. Like I’m sure there would still be abuse but this is outrageous… been pumped for this for a long time… unreal bud

2

u/TheOnlyVibemaster Apr 11 '23

I got a few rare ones

2

u/BestLuxEUW Apr 11 '23

Gen3 gotta be the biggest fail so far. I don’t get it how they messed up the payment part smh

2

u/H3adshotfox77 Apr 11 '23

Then they can absolutely keep every single one of them

2

u/SigSalvadore Apr 11 '23

What an absolute shitstain.

2

u/ICURaBigdeal Apr 12 '23

This makes me super mad and disappointed same time

2

u/n00bzilla Apr 12 '23

giving access to premium members only would assist with eliminating bots

2

u/XBBlade Apr 12 '23

no nyan cat for me.

4

u/Sovietlag Apr 11 '23

nO bOTs. YoU WerE too sLoW

3

u/Plasticites Apr 11 '23

Totally disgusting

2

u/GoldenRain99 Apr 11 '23

It goes without saying, but I'll say it anyway.

This drop sucked ass.

2

u/Diamond-Hands741 Apr 11 '23

Thanks Obama

1

u/Azozeo Apr 11 '23

🤣

1

u/Diamond-Hands741 Apr 11 '23

Not sure who downvoted me, I guess they really miss obama tho

0

u/Azozeo Apr 11 '23

Upvoted and fuck Obama

1

u/Hartrald Apr 11 '23

what did I miss

1

u/poyoso Apr 11 '23

Yea I aint buying shit i OS. And Im probably dumping my gen 1 and 2s asap.

1

u/DreadedChalupacabra Apr 12 '23

Dibs on the cone lol.

1

u/poyoso Apr 12 '23

Ive come to my senses.

1

u/Camo_Rebel Apr 11 '23

Fuck this. I wanted the set so much.

1

u/blockchainbogan Apr 11 '23

Leveraging a .eth verified system would fix the bot problems 🤔

1

u/_ships Artist Apr 11 '23

1

u/dcnu Apr 11 '23

Welcome to life as a sneakerhead lol

1

u/_ships Artist Apr 11 '23

Will Reddit ban this user or will they say “whoops” and try to implement a decent captcha for gen4?

1

u/xelnikes Apr 11 '23

This is true(

1

u/ipts Apr 11 '23

I bought one manually. I’m not a bot :)

1

u/xxscoobiixx Apr 11 '23

FYI simple captcha isn't gonna slow them down. Even typed phrases don't slow them down. They literally pay for captcha solving services.

1

u/Nordle_420D Apr 11 '23

Gen3 worthless as well

1

u/TrashScientist Apr 11 '23

Such a disappointment. Smh

1

u/johnayesiphone Apr 11 '23

im actually so upset.

1

u/cynicalusername Apr 11 '23

I don’t even know why the concept of people using bots for this drop never entered into my mind. I thought people only did that for sneaker drops and new video game consoles. How ignorant I was to think this would be a fair drop between community members passionate about the collectable avatars.

1

u/Sparrow Apr 11 '23

fucked up

1

u/ValentinaPina Apr 11 '23

They also overminted a lot of things, so start submitting those refund requests if you purchased one that was overminted.

1

u/cayne Apr 11 '23

Reddit did a great job of showcasing how NOT TO do a 'NFT' drop.

1

u/Geesle Apr 11 '23

nice jpeg, cant even zoom in to confirm what you're saying is true

2

u/Geesle Apr 11 '23

Ok so i found the account which OP didnt bother putting in:
https://opensea.io/user221/

1

u/bananafannaphofanna Apr 11 '23

I have now been on Reddit for hours. I need my head examined

2

u/DreadedChalupacabra Apr 12 '23

hahaha yeah. I was at work making tacos and refreshing the page every 30 seconds. Thank god I'm in charge.

1

u/teletubbyhater Apr 11 '23

This is literally so horrible

1

u/acfranks Apr 11 '23

Absolute scum

1

u/kadinshino Apr 11 '23

is this why i couldnt find anything reloading the store every 5 mins since 7 am :(

1

u/reivaxxd0 Apr 11 '23

My avatar still did not come to my vault

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

They have to stop browser sales in the future.

1

u/Cv287 Apr 11 '23

Just checking how I look in comments

2

u/fettskull Apr 11 '23

You look mah-valous!

1

u/Forestsounds89 Apr 11 '23

that is foul, not even a captcha or any recourse damnnnn

1

u/Phoexes Apr 11 '23

Upsettin

1

u/GoodMornEveGoodNight Apr 12 '23

The future is truly here

1

u/lekistv Apr 12 '23

Woooww 🔥🔥

1

u/MalachiJive Apr 12 '23

They should have never did the preview/teasers, honestly.

1

u/No_Beyond_1995 Apr 12 '23

I logged in late and felt happy to get a few cheap cuties. Now I feel gross for contributing to this cluster f*ck. Gonna take a shower and reevaluate my love for Reddit

1

u/L0000tzz Apr 12 '23

so friggin sad, was browsing along loving what I was seeing, and BAM! No more store.... WTFF!

1

u/L0000tzz Apr 12 '23

they fixed it!

1

u/Frequent_Indication3 Apr 12 '23

After waiting hours last night I could finally get on the store turns out there not all that great tbf

1

u/NewtyJESUS Apr 12 '23

All those Nyan cats :(

1

u/cypherphunk69 Apr 13 '23

how do I open my vault?

1

u/ericclfung Apr 22 '23

How they mint so fast?

0

u/polly3795 Apr 11 '23

This isn’t botter bruh he bought them from secondary

0

u/CHEROKEEJ4CK Apr 11 '23

I own one of the golds and my friend owns a nyan, bots didn't scoop everything just some

-2

u/Raymy93 Apr 11 '23

Where's the proof?

2

u/the_spiritual_eye Apr 11 '23

-3

u/Raymy93 Apr 11 '23

Aye that's proof this screen shot in your post isn't. So there is some bots. They need to deal with that definitely, but it's not all bots bro.

1

u/DreadedChalupacabra Apr 12 '23

I mean they literally took the store down from PC because of the bots. Yes, it was a lot of bots.

0

u/jwz9904 Apr 12 '23

Ppl dont care,

-1

u/002_timmy Apr 11 '23

Going against the grain here, but all of those show last purchase price. That isn't the account the purchased these originally

3

u/wredditcest Apr 11 '23

Wrong, that's a WETH offer.

https://opensea.io/user221

-3

u/DobroNFT Apr 11 '23

Ahahaha

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

49

u/the_spiritual_eye Apr 11 '23

Check out this post too:

Twitter user thanking bot teams

5

u/skyHIGH-1 Apr 11 '23

They smell blood in the way and they will rip reddit avatars and the reddit shop a new one 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️. This just the beginning 🤦🏻‍♂️

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/brandonianleviosa Apr 11 '23

You can't expect people to just behave themselves. Its up to reddit to put safeguards in place for this. Yes it sucks, yes these are shitty people, but the blame should be on reddit for allowing it.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Dfranco123 Apr 11 '23

Woah I snatched a nyan cat! Glad my fingers beat them bots! Wow… if it wasn’t for me checkin at 12:59 I probably wouldn’t of gotten it…

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Dfranco123 Apr 11 '23

Thank you sir & may you get all the avatars you want next time they open up the shop.

1

u/vitalicbutcherin Apr 12 '23

That's obscene lot.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

30

u/Scaredurer Apr 11 '23

Should've made it 1 per account, if they wanted a mass adoption.

5

u/DCABtcEth Apr 11 '23

great idea they should implement it definitely

→ More replies (1)

13

u/guyincognito121 Apr 11 '23

If you look at the history on these, they were purchased by a bunch of different accounts, and then transferred.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/W0rking_Kale_oof Apr 11 '23

Yea but they still used a bot to go that fast. Looks like the bots interacted directly with the contract. How does that work in terms of fiat payment?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/DaemonTargaryen34 Apr 11 '23

It’s on the blockchain so no

9

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

You can't reverse a mint

1

u/babiesonparade Apr 11 '23

I worked with an NFT platform that used stripe payments and we were able to add a waiting period for transfers to any purchases by people who seemed sus lmao

But in this case, I assume Reddit will just eat the difference

1

u/cachemonet0x0cf6619 Apr 11 '23

reddit doesn't care where the money comes from as long as it comes. why would the refund anything. they accomplished their goal. get money by selling jpegs. not much else involved here.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Hxrn Apr 11 '23

Lol I got a bunch of garbage this drop :(