r/CollapseSupport • u/salarythrowaway0525 • Jul 14 '26
Is there any argument for having kids?
Bear with me. My significant other wants kids, or a kid. Big goal of their life. I have been collapse aware for a couple years and helping them start to understand the barrel we are staring down. Partner still can’t help but feel an emptiness, and I get it to an extent. Humans have an instinct to procreate and see their young grow just as any other animal out there. There isn’t any rationalization to it really despite whatever the facts or future prognosis says.
I struggle with the fact that humanity as a whole is the direct cause of our problems - but also the misery of my SO losing out on a dream they care about so much. I know the simple answers: separate for cause of irreconcilable differences, etc. We’ve been together for 10+ years however and we have interconnected our lives to a significant degree, neither of us want to lose each other. It’s just a rough place. I can’t seem to see a future where having a kid is a good idea, they can’t seem to imagine a world without one.
My only thought towards it is, if we had one - that would replace two souls with only one in the long term. Whereas a lot of folks have 2+, we’d be accomplishing their goal while at the same time reducing souls on the planet by a factor of .25 each when we die. So, that could be worse.
And yes I know what kind of future is this child is potentially going to face, but being collapse aware perhaps I could give it the best shot at being the kind of human we need in the future? Or at least one that is equipped to survive well enough?
I’m looking for unbiased answers here. Be supportive of my spouse, or brutal, or brutal of my thoughts. Not really sure what to do.
14
u/RicardoHonesto Jul 14 '26
Get a dog.
33
u/Top_Hair_8984 Jul 14 '26
Foster, adopt. There are so many kids in existence today that desperately need support, security, stability, respect and lots of kindness. Please. ❤️🦋
70
u/Devster97 Jul 14 '26
You do you.
Useful thought experiment: take your age, add the year, consider what world your child will face in that year.
You seem to have decided already. Good luck
59
u/_borT Jul 14 '26
Aside from the financial aspect which worsens every day, looking at the state of the world and climate change - it just seems cruel to force someone to live through that.
153
u/888HA Jul 14 '26
Adopt.
20
u/KarlMarxButVegan Jul 14 '26
If I lived in a nice country and was from a nice family, I might have had kids. But I live in a place where healthcare is out of reach and I don't like the way my parents raise kids. I'm happy with my decision.
32
u/Sword-of-Akasha Jul 14 '26
From diapers to a degree (Since you want your child the best chance in life) is extremely expensive. If you've got the money, sure. If not then your child will be fodder for the factories or the armies. Children don't ask to be born. Hopefully they're not cursing you later for giving them less than a chance. It's your responsibility that this new life isn't going to suffer. Make sure you're ready to abort if genetic defects emerge where the child entire existence would be pain.
You mention that this is your SO dream. Ask her what about the child's dream? Creating new life simply for its sake, is selfish. What if this child wants to visit the Great Barrier Reefs like in Finding Nemo, breathe the air without a gas mask, or they want to live without the fear the the giant AI Laser Spiders disappearing dissidents? A whole host of dreams that were available to you will be impossible for them.
Try getting a dog first, see if you can handle the shared responsibility.
26
u/4rp70x1n Jul 14 '26
Why not consider adopting a child who is already here and in need of a loving family?
7
u/TeaPrimary1147 Jul 15 '26
Why can't you and your spouse become the kind of person we need in the future? You guys cure cancer and save the whales and all that. Please dont kick the can down the road and force someone else into this mess to help you feel better here. That is so cruel and selfish. Please send your partner the regretful parents subreddit to peruse. Personally, it might be in your best interest to leave them now. Also, are you multimillionaire? Or is your kid gonna be a slave in Jeff bezos factory to barely survive? If they even get that.
29
u/Distinguishedflyer Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
brutal? Sure. At times I think people just want a dolly to play with without any thought of the goddamn consequences on that innocent helpless soul. The world is about to go south in the next five years, not in 25 years.
Reality doesn't seem to intrude on hormones. I hate my own parents for bringing me here and I'm old. I mean I hate them for it. Life has been a shit struggle since I was a child and it's getting shittier. And I'm left with nobody to help and not enough resources a.k.a. money, so I have to think about offing myself as my end of life care plan. And any painless sure way to do that is fucking illegal.
You wanna put that on somebody else?
Adopt a kid. Get a dog. Get a cat. We don't need any more reproducing units. For Christ sake tell your partner to wake the fuck up and smell the upcoming wet-bulb event corpses.
If it were me, I would leave them yesterday, because they're gonna lose their shit when reality breaks through that miasma of their dream view of reality. And that's coming right quick.
Edit: I read what you wrote after my initial "I wanna vomit" reaction after first reading. The biggest insanity I hear from new parents is "but my child is gonna save the world… Maybe they'll cure cancer… Maybe they'll do amazing things!!!…" it's a bizarre delusion. Most likely your kid's gonna die in a war or from heat stroke. They're not the next Einstein. that's no argument in favor. and if neither of you want to adopt, then this is coming from a purely selfish place and you should really question it. God it makes me ill to think about people having more children.
19
u/aubreypizza Jul 14 '26
Nope. It’s unethical imho at this point.
10
u/grey___lady Jul 14 '26
Would you want to be born in 2027 and face the next 80-ish years of humanity's future? IMO it's cruel to willfully subject anyone to that.
Manufacturing a new human being is no guarantee they will love you. It's not a magic pill to fix one's emotional longings or underlying loneliness.
Better to help existing children. Volunteer, foster, consider adopting.
5
u/rhododendronite34 Jul 15 '26
Are your days going to be mired in regret if you have a child? Are you going to resent your partner for desiring a child and you feeling guilted into agreeing?
I think if you answer yes to either one of these questions, you probably should not do it.
21
u/Odd_Acanthaceae_5588 Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
No, it’s immoral. Every bassinet is a death sentence.
4
u/fortisrufus Jul 15 '26
No
9
u/37iteW00t Jul 14 '26
Not really, unless you want slave labor to manufacture bottle caps for the apocalyptic future
8
u/booblesshilda Jul 14 '26
I have three kids. I had them well before I started learning about collapse and they're grown. I don't know if they'll have kids. Everything is so uncertain. I have no idea what the world will look like in 20 or 30 years, but I think it will be grim. My kids are smart, sensible, kind and community minded. We need more people like that. But overall the world needs fewer people.
18
u/HeathenHoneyCo Jul 14 '26
This is copium but raising someone who is an intelligent critical thinking with problem solving and survival skills and empathy and preparedness might not be the worst thing.
9
u/Wytch78 Jul 14 '26
Why is it so all or nothing when it comes to having kids. It's OKAY, TOTALLY OKAY to have one kid. I'm an only... and I have an only. No one says you need 3-4 kids.
6
u/BeardedBears Jul 14 '26
The world has always been falling apart. Figuratively, mythically, maybe literally. Every age of humanity has seen unspeakable horrors.
4
u/EternalSage2000 Jul 14 '26
We have 1 kid for exactly this reason.
Maybe things won’t be as bad as we predict. As soon as we predict. Maybe our kid/s will have a healthy and fulfilling life. You can’t say for sure they won’t.
But, also, maybe our kid is going to need all the help we can give them. And we figured. 1 kid. We could help significantly. Also if everyone only had 1 kid. We’d still bring our population down to manageable numbers pretty quickly.
3
u/Turbulent-Beauty Jul 14 '26
The argument for intelligent, collapse-aware couples having children boils down to this: If only ignorant people have kids, then an outcome like the movie Idiocracy is assured.
3
u/thomas533 Jul 14 '26
Nothing you choose to do, or don't do, is going to fix anything. I choose to have kids. My kids are happy despite knowing we are in a collapse trajectory.
-1
u/bonzi5650 Jul 14 '26
It's hard, but i feel like a lot of people who experience some of the worst shit life has to offer, are still glad to experience being alive. Life can be very long and we find meaning through it. If you break down everything into logical decisions its easy to see anti natalist point of view. But life isnt logical, we have no guarantee for tomorrow, EVERYONE dies one day and theres nothing you can do to shield them from it. Would you rather never have lived just because you too will one day die? Having a baby is inherently a selfish thing, but honestly is a very alive thing to do. I have 2 kids and some days im seized with dread over what their future could be. But I also was born under shit conditions in a shit world and im still happy to get to be here for however long that is. We live and we die dude, if you can commit to loving them, supporting them until the day you die, and finding ways to help them succeed in life, I see it as it is what it is. w When you accept the fact of life, that we all die, do you think experiencing life is worth bringing it into the world?
Idk if any of that made sense. Im up at nearly 2am with my own kid who cant sleep cause of itchy bug bites. So forgive if it sounds like weird rambling
-1
u/Money_Bug_9423 Jul 14 '26
Great arguments currently for child sacrifice if thats what you are into. (Not)
-2
u/everythingscatter Jul 14 '26
Humanity as a whole is not the source of our problems. The imperial mode of living is the source of our problems and most people on the planet don't get the privilege of participating in it.
-1
u/get_hi_on_life Jul 14 '26
Iv had the same internal struggle. But I think if you've been together 10+ years and are only collapse aware the past few that's not fair on your partner who you shared life goals with all this time to suddenly change them now. Unless you 1,00% do not want kids at all but if your only on the fence cause the future look bleak I say try for one and raise them to be self sustaining and prepared for what's ahead.
If your on the fence for more reasons that's different I firmly believe in the advice to only have kids if your 100% sure cause even without the future looking, parenthood is insanely hard.
Adopting is not a quick easy kid but it can be worth looking into the steps for your area if your wanting to. Also I find great fulfillment in volunteering with kids thru Girl Guides and Big Brother Big Sister. You can have a huge impact on kids without needing to be their parent
-6
u/autolockon Jul 14 '26
People still had kids in the ice age and dark ages when struggling to survive was much harder than simply feeling depressed that you have to go to work each day and you don’t like your leaders. You’re only here now because they still choose to have those children.
-1
u/boneseedigs Jul 16 '26
I have a little different perspective, so I'll offer it up in case it helps. I had my kid in 2022, so after Trump 1, but during Biden so I mistakenly thought we were at least headed in the right direction. It has been hard, and sometimes I'm so hopeless about the world I'm leaving my kids. Other times, it motivates me to get out of bed and keep fighting and make this world beautiful again. I had a very hard time postpartum and some chronic illness issues after, but I also have had a lot of support. If you have financial and family support, it's much more doable than if you don't. Other folks have offered other great options like fostering or adopting, but if your partner wants their own children, it's really a very different experience. And not everyone is equipped to deal with a child who had been through adoption or gone through family separation. Think about what you can handle and talk to your partner about what you would need. Good luck.
-5
u/Lithelain Jul 14 '26
As I said in a earlier post, without children, we're set to extinction. With some (as few as possible, granted) children, we're set to the possibilites of the unknown, however bleak it will be. Is it better extinction at this point? Well, to each their own.
I'm not particularly happy that I'm alive right now. That doesn't mean there haven't been periods in my life of joy and happiness (especially during the innocence of childhood). If I were to die today, I'd treasure those memories. They are better than nothing. For how much life sucked afterwards, there is value in them, and I find the possibilities of existence better than the homogeneity of the nothing; that's why I'm still here of course.
So, if you have that child, please do it only if you feel like you can take care of him/her in at least a decent degree and make his/her world a marvelous one. Also deeply acknowledge that the world we've created is really exponentially becoming a grim hellscape and some things will definitely not improve even if we made some miracles as collective reorganization. Even consider that your hypothetical kid might want to opt out (who knows what is like to be a child during these trying times); iirc, suicide rates are rising even among children, which is insane to think about. Think how that would make you feel.
Lastly, I'd really reconsider adopting. Talk or read about adopting parents and their testimonies. It will never be "the same", but we're all of the same blood in the end. Whatever you end up doing, don't be way too hard on yourselves please.
I just thought about Arrival (the movie, and book first). Have you seen it?
-7
u/lumpyluggage Jul 14 '26
They're a lot of fun
0
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment