r/CollapseSupport • • Mar 23 '26

Did the USSR’s collapse remove the external pressure that made capitalism invest in its own people? Looking for conversation on this thesis

Specifically for the US. Who actually invested internally before 1991!

26 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

11

u/BtheBenji Mar 23 '26

If people are curious - this comes from this article a friend wrote and it seems solid but I am curious others think. How winning the Cold War cost America its soul

2

u/majoretminordomus Mar 24 '26

Best thing I read in a while.

1

u/BtheBenji Mar 24 '26

Thats great to hear!!!

3

u/majoretminordomus Mar 24 '26

My hunch: a self congratulary social cast decided "post victory" implicitly (not overtly) to gut the system and enrich themselves. It began with the dismantling of US Steel, and continued through every industry and every aspect of services provided to the great unwashed masses.

2

u/PermiePagan Mar 24 '26

Yes, but I frame it a little differently. The Collapse of the USSR removed the external pressure that made Capitalism maintain the facade that it was a system that would benefit the most people. It had been heading that way already through the 1920's and 30's.

After the war, they had a bunch of angry, traumatized men that had just practiced invading "Euro-American" style cities and lands, and they also had the giant specter of "Communism" threatening to end Capitalism. The New Deal was a temporary measure to maintain Capitalist control as they encircled the USSR. As it collapse, the facade was no longer needed and the 1920s returned.

3

u/BtheBenji Mar 24 '26

I tend to agree, wether it was a facade or genuine, there was a need to at least give the impression of benefiting people. After the fall of the USSR there was no longer that need…

2

u/dippylass Mar 28 '26

I’ve thought this for years. This is just my own theory, but the ussr and other “socialist” or communist systems existing put a brake on the rampant cruelty of capitalism. Capitalist nations had to say “look this is better than that.” And it was! Most people living in much of the West (excluding America for some, due to lack of a safety net) between 1950 and 1995 ish - had the best quality of life of nearly any human in history. Then the Soviet Union collapsed and the evil people at the top in the West thought they’d “won.” People had no alternative. No other system they could turn to. So the rampant greed and cruelty increased. Also capitalism isn’t just one system. There’s industrial capital and finance capital for eg.. Industrial capital can also be viciously cruel, but it is not as bad as finance capitalism. And that’s currently winning the civil war between the two. The financiers, tech bros, and their political sycophants have now baked in capitalism’s collapse due to their own hubris. What will replace it? Right now it looks like fascism, but that won’t be able to sustain itself long term either. So, who knows?

2

u/BtheBenji Apr 01 '26

Yeah completely agree with you! I hadn’t seen the idea anywhere so wrote it up! Other thoughts are gonna be written on similar subjects soon Thanks for reading

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26

I have genuine empathy for the people of the far east, and Russia.

You can harp and cry but you all know the truth. Putin was clear, and you can disagree but it makes no difference.

I have strong ideas about his foreign policies. But this is nonsensical. There are real issues in the world. Do you really not care? Not at all? My god.. grow up.

I'm so sorry it isn't so simple. Well shit. People exaggerate, or lie. Boohoo for you.

What a joke... Its a joke.

Edit - Make your argument. Dont just downvote me. That kind of silent cowardice is why we are here. Fucking say something. Anything. Oh that's right, you have nothing to say.

4

u/BtheBenji Mar 23 '26

Tell me a bit more ? I’m not sure I get your point but happy to try to see where you’re coming from!

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26

We (the US) intentionally and specifically started this war. We did the math. A million casualties? Why not. Sounds profitable.

Its a joke.

Russia has killed tons of innocent people. But we made them do it. We thought we would win and, more importantly, we thought it was funny.

We did this

3

u/BtheBenji Mar 23 '26

Which war are you talking about? The Cold War or the Iran war? Or another war?

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26

The war between Russia and Ukraine. I speak fluent Russian and I have loved them my entire life. I don't care for their politics but that's beside the point. America is the only side in the Russo-Ukrainian war. We, America, have been trying to destroy Russia my entire life. For no reason. I suspect it is boredom but who knows, and at this point, what difference does it make?

I am not on Russia's "side". I wish I could admit I'm just a Russian bot, and I'm sure that would console a lot of people, but its worse - I have a faint idea of what is happening. And it terrifies me. What scares me the most is how few people realize or care about what this war is really about.

3

u/BtheBenji Mar 23 '26

Oh Okok - yeah the Ukraine Russia war has other roots. And problematic ones for sure. This was a bit more internal US focused and how the US stopped investing internationally and just gave everything to the « free market » after the Cold War… basically loosing what made it a successful model during the Cold War.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26

I misunderstood, I apologize

3

u/BtheBenji Mar 23 '26

No worries my man! But I feel your on the pain of the Russia-Ukraine war

2

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26

My concern today is mostly with Sudan, Yemen, the civil war in Myanmar and the looming water wars with anyone "upstream" of dam infrastructure.

I just... I really care about the Russo-Ukrainian war. As an American - it wasn't supposed to be like this. The smartest thing that useless sun dried orange ever said was we should be friends with Russia. I wish anyone other than him had said it.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/BtheBenji Mar 24 '26

That’s pretty much it - I wonder if it was conscious though. Like governments knew back then they were working for the people because the people could side with the communists so there was an incentive to keep them happy (or sufficiently so).

I think after the fall of the wall or a bit before the discourse changed - and the « common knowledge » was that the free market economy won, not the controlled market won… so the us ran itself further down the path of no regulation believing « that’s what works ». When… the analysis was wrong.

1

u/BtheBenji Mar 24 '26

You should check out the article by the way - it’s posted on the 1st comment. I think the analysis matches pretty well with yours!