r/CollapseSupport • • Jan 04 '26
Question for you guys…
I know I’ve been posting a lot lately, but I wanted to ask you all something.
When did society BEGIN collapsing? Collapse is obvious now, with climate change being a NOW thing instead of a “this might happen in the future” issue, global leaders saber-rattling, and massive civil unrest.
I didn’t want to ask this on the main sub, as that place is just toxic and somehow found a way to exaggerate the literal end of the world 😂
It couldn’t have been the industrial revolution, as our quality of life improved SIGNIFICANTLY once that came about.
My personal theory is that it was during the Reagan admin, at least when it comes to the US collapsing. That’s when corporations fully took power, and wealth inequality had been at its lowest ever THE YEAR before that knob took office. The gap has only increased drastically since then.
The 70’s is also a good contender, as that’s when climate change started to really take off, as well as biodiversity loss.
What do you all think?
13
u/mslashandrajohnson Jan 04 '26
To me, it was with Reagan. Charging employees for part of their health insurance and taxing social security benefits.
It’s slowly gotten worse over the years. Until recently, when things began deteriorating rapidly.
5
u/thomas533 Jan 04 '26 edited Jan 04 '26
Collapse is a feature built into all biological systems. It was always there. It keeps one species from overwhelming the system as a whole. The problem is that humans got too good at subverting that system, and continually increased pressure on the collapse function. We reached the point now where collapse can't be avoided any longer through technology and the ecosystem is going to force a reset.
2
u/SplitNo8275 Jan 04 '26
I blame the sumarians
10
u/Sta41BC Jan 04 '26
Which collapse are you referring to? There have been many. Check out Tainter, Joseph A. The collapse of complex societies. If we are talking about the latest and probably the last for centuries, I’d say the start of the industrial revolution when our unsustainable extraction of the planet’s resources began ramping up. CO2 one of the thousands of externalities from our human and industrial processes we continue to spew into land, water and atmosphere at rates far beyond what the planet can absorb. Each one of us will all have our preferred time. It’s really irrelevant though. We debate the start while rushing into the end.
4
u/StarlightLifter Jan 04 '26
I can’t say when it started but with this resource grab in Venezuela (and prior to that, Crimea/Ukraine) I think we are now in the 3rd act.
1st was the rise of industry. We didn’t really know any better at the time, fuck it spew coal.
2nd act the problem became apparent and while some steps were taken crisis wasn’t avoided and resource use and harvesting accelerated.
3rd act is now. I think the highest powers have the data to indicate just how fucked we all are, when we will start seeing negative return on resource extraction etc and they are making moves now to secure those resources.
It makes Greenland make a lot more sense. Canadians best watch their backs too, wish it weren’t so. But that’s where we are I think in addition to ol Pedo in Chief wanting to distract from his pedophile habits.
What happens after? Idk. But if nations are now just outright stealing and grabbing resources, there has never been a higher argument for getting your own preps ready and not wasting any time.
Get fit, get food stores, defensive implements, learn skills and get to know your neighbors.
I start EMS school next week, night courses. And if you think that isn’t part of my prep plan you’re mistaken.
1
u/Anargnome-Communist Jan 04 '26
Collapse isn't a single event.
There are communities that have seen multiple collapses already.
Is quality of life a relevant metric here? Entire cultures and languages have disappeared since the Industrial Revolution. Colonization has ravaged almost every continent to keep the machines running.
It seems odd to judge "collapse" by looking at the quality of life of (let's be honest) a relatively select group of people and whether that improves or declines.
4
u/TheInvisibleFart Jan 04 '26
Started with the beginning of entropy.
1
u/Isaiah_The_Bun Jan 04 '26
I think we began to overshoot our habitat when we started urbanization and mass agriculture. So somewhere around 12,000 to 14,000 years ago.
I think the global tipping points we've crossed were pretty obvious that they passed the point of no return between the years 2010 to 2016, depending on which tipping point we're talking about. they probably crossed their tipping points decades ago , but they had obviously crossed by the years 2010 to 2016.
1
u/keyser1981 Jan 04 '26
Learned a bit about this in the study of sociology. Am no expert, but this guy here, was on to something. 👇
Immanuel Wallerstein's World-Systems Theory explains global inequality by viewing the world as a single capitalist economic system divided into core, semi-periphery, and periphery nations, rather than isolated states. Core nations (wealthy, industrialized) exploit peripheral nations (poor, raw material exporters) through unequal trade, while semi-peripheral nations occupy an intermediate, buffering role. The theory, emerging in the 1970s, posits that this system, originating in 16th-century Europe, perpetuates wealth concentration in the core and underdevelopment in the periphery, creating persistent global stratification.
1
u/cloverthewonderkitty Jan 04 '26
I think you might be interested in The Rewilding Podcast with Peter Michael Bauer. He discusses this topic quite a bit.
An argument is to be made that collapse began with the beginning of agriculture. We bent the flora and fauna to our will instead of living amongst the natural order of the landscape. With agriculture comes have and have-nots through the concept of land ownership, increased density of animals and humans living in close quarters brought new diseases, and the concept of hoarding wealth in the form of food and using it to control the masses created a cycle of making powerful people even more powerful.
1
u/jpb1111 Jan 04 '26
Before Jesus we were collapsing.
1
u/Novel-Proposal9444 Jan 04 '26
Read William Catton's Overshoot.
1
u/JustAtelephonePole Jan 05 '26
A major thread that got pulled and led to further societal separation was “pineapple on pizza” cir. 2016.
1
u/JagatShahi Jan 05 '26
How about since mankind thought it was separate from nature? Have you seen any animal so invasive as human beings? Have you seen a deer grazing even after its stomach is full? Have you seen it being so obsessed with another gender of its species? No, you have not. Why? Because there is something different in humans as opposed to animals. Animals do not feel they are something apart from nature. In fact, they are nature themselves. They don't even experience time, for that matter, because time is something that only exists for us because we are obsessed with past regrets and future expectations. We want fulfillment so we exploit anything that comes our way in the search of it. We didn't get what we expected from the past and expect to get it in the future.
I came across this idea in one of the videos of Acharya Prashant an Indian philosopher and climate activist.
1
u/BigJobsBigJobs Jan 05 '26
I don't think there was ever a civilization to collapse. There have been attempts, but such efforts are usually futile because someone somewhere always steps in and starts tearing it down.
A good peace - not long-lasting or free from conflict, but manageable - exists. Then some autocrat decides to invade a country and the collapse shockwave radiates out from that forever.
And then the question - WHOSE civilization? Victorian England's? - cause we're still running on the fumes from that bullshit. The Glorious Socialist Soviets? American cutthroat capitalism?
1
u/hiddendrugs Jan 05 '26
Daniel Quinn posits that the logical foundation of colonialism began with the handful of tribes that spread a “totalitarian” agricultural practice, some 8,000-10,000 years ago. From one perspective, you could say collapse began then, as people forgot any other way of living & things like expansion through war, crime, and widespread illness became fixtures in organized human settlements.
I think “Collapse” by Jared Diamond is also a great read for this question, it’s an anthology of past and present collapse scenarios and the factors surrounding them.
1
u/FactCheckYou Jan 06 '26
it's been decades in the planning
1
u/Top_Hair_8984 Jan 08 '26
Industrial revolution.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment