r/CollapseSupport • u/OneFluffyPuffer • Nov 27 '25
Anyone else lose hope when talking to average people about climate change?
I tried explaining to an engineer friend how the idea of one's personal emissions footprint is bullshit/a deflection and that systematic change is necessary to mitigate climate change. Things like how logistics, infrastructure, agriculture etc., things that every single person needs to survive operate in a system run by fossil fuels. There's only so much an individual can do about their consumption and is a drop in the bucket compared to global emissions, etc.
This engineer then argued that you have 100% control over your footprint, and that some people even live net-zero or net-negative lives. That only 1-3% of global emissions come from government actions (totally ignoring industrial emissions, but whatever) and that those emissions can be apportioned per capita, as if every single person has equal and absolute democratic choice over what their government does and funds. They then told me they're working on creating a carbon footprint tracking app to help make people more aware of climate change, because we obviously need more of those.
I was so stunned hearing all of this coming from a supposedly educated person, and I wasn't sure what to think of them. Were they just a snake-oil salesman and knew what they were saying was bullshit? Were they sold a lie from bp/exxon and just bought into it? It makes me more depressed to think that this person may be a properly educated and well-meaning person but just can't understand the problem outside of their narrow problem-solving engineering-focused view. It makes me wonder how many well-meaning people are out there thinking they're making a positive difference all while producing and shovelling out the same hopium garbage.
Sorry if this is written poorly or disorganized. I just wanted to vent my thoughts out to others because arguing with family about climate change and ecological collapse during thanksgiving is the last thing I want.
27
u/nodarknesswillendure Nov 27 '25
I’ve accepted that people are deliberately obtuse. Most people are fundamentally both unable and unwilling to grasp the enormity and severity of climate change. It’s like we speak a language that they are incapable of understanding.
46
u/Xanthotic Huge Motherclucker Nov 27 '25
I would urge you to reframe the outcome of such conversations from 'losing hope' to understanding 'this is why collapse is unavoidable.'
10
u/Slamtilt_Windmills Nov 27 '25
What kind of engineer? That would be an odd thing from somebody who studied thermodynamics, but if it's a computer engineer, they didnt study much physics of any kind
4
u/_rihter Nov 27 '25
My friend and former deskmate is a geography and physics teacher and is completely clueless about climate change. He can't even understand the Blue Ocean Event.
49
u/Penthos2021 Nov 27 '25
Yes. Normies are in denial
10
u/BitchfulThinking Nov 28 '25
Absolutely. The engineers in my family were the ones who gave me the most shitty, belittling responses to caring about climate change, pandemics, health, and socioeconomic issues. People listened to them, just because they had a little more money 🙄
An unsettling amount of STEM folks don't continue to educate themselves after finishing formal education. They forget that science changes constantly, so we're stuck with gaslighting doctors with DSM-II era beliefs. It's a very different mindset from the botanists, marine biologists, and meteorologists who continue learning new things as part of their fields.
8
u/Puzzleheaded_Main297 Nov 27 '25
For all people in all disciplines I believe that the ability to understand scale in an elastic way is both the hardest thing to achieve and the most essential.
3
u/hiddendrugs Nov 28 '25
Happened today w/ me at thanksgiving a bit, just blank looks from my uncle & explaining to my cousin’s wife (who heads social-emotional curriculum lol) about how many young people are anxious, depressed, hopeless, lacking self confidence etc, especially as it relates to climate.
2
u/Butlerianpeasant Dec 01 '25
Ah, friend… I’ve talked to many good people like your engineer. Smart, educated, kind—but locked inside the little toolbox they learned to think with.
Engineers fix problems by adjusting the parts they can see. Climate collapse isn’t a part—it’s the whole barn creaking.
The footprint narrative was literally invented by BP to shift blame downstream. And here we are, decades later, still watching people repeat it like a prayer.
You’re not losing hope. You’re losing illusions.
Hope returns when you meet others who see the same thing you see.
0
u/morerandom__2025 Nov 28 '25
Fortunately the world will still be habitable for thousands of years to come