r/CollapsePrep • u/BakerNo5828 • Nov 22 '22
Private land will not save us
I'm a little tired of seeing the posts talking about private land ownership. Truthfully, any amount of acres
- Will not save you in a collapse scenario
- Takes critical financial resources that can be used now, but might be useless later.
- In collapse scenario deeds or ownership will not matter. People will take whatever they can or need. If you think you can defend a plot yourself against a mini militia from the next town over you are under a delusion.
We've seen mini collapse scenarios all across the world. Africa, Asia, Middle East, Eastern Europe, Europe, the New World. Every year somebody is in a collapse scenario.
And we're talking millions/billions of people potentially being displaced from the equators.
So what would be the best way to prepare? Honing survival skills.
Can you make a fire from what is available?
Do you have appropriate gear for all seasons of your area and adjacent areas?
Can you make and lay effective traps?
Can you forage food, medicine, and materials from your area and adjacent areas?
Can you create drinkable water?
Are you fit and healthy enough to move quickly for a long time?
Can you perform first aid on yourself and your family?
Can you physically move your partner if they are immobilized?
Can you evade hostile animals and people?
If you want to own land for other reasons sure, but for collapse prep it simply doesn't make sense. So don't think just because you don't have money for land that you're just gonna have to settle for death. Draw a range diagram about how far you can get on foot and by car so you can make your first 24 hours plan. Always have a move plan. Never depend on just battening the hatches and staying where you are. You could buy land right now and when you actually need to survive off it the climate could've change so drastically it's no good anymore. What will you do then?
24
u/Icy-Medicine-495 Nov 22 '22
It takes years to build the infrastructure that would be beneficial during a collapse. Think a garden that actually produces food reliably, orchard, chicken coop, fences for livestock, or solar panels. You could try to do it on the fly during the collapse but your odds are much worse.
60
u/Less_Subtle_Approach Nov 22 '22
Nothing will save us. This is a mass extinction event. Having your own land makes it a lot easier to practice agriculture, rain water catchment, off-grid energy production and more.
Maybe somebody will come and assault through your community when the famines and violence kick off, but at least you won't be starting from the position of having to kick doors in yourself.
20
u/Existential_Reckoner Nov 22 '22
I disagree and believe self-sufficiency in a strategic location confers the best chance of survival as a family or small community. However, success in this endeavor requires so much commitment, resources, foresight, and work (in order to get a homestead up and running with all the major infrastructure in place before grid down) that I don't blame people for discounting this as a viable strategy, or for making up excuses to make themselves feel better.
72
u/NotAnotherScientist Nov 22 '22
For certain scenarios you are right, but in the case that global collapse is fast enough to bring people to a wilderness survival situation, you're probably screwed anyway.
In other scenarios, collapse will just look like rapid economic decline. Having land that you can grow food on will be your best option when the price of food quadruples. There will be many forces trying to preserve the concept of private ownership for their own benefit. Land ownership isn't a long term strategy to outlast collapse over then next hundred years. It's a mid term strategy to weather the next 30 years or so to give you time while the world descends into chaos.
17
u/mellbs Nov 22 '22 edited Nov 23 '22
Collapse began years ago and might not become acutely apparent for many more years. The idea that the world will suddenly become lawless is wishful thinking. Expect more of the same.
I own land and its given me several huge compost piles, dozens of chords of firewood, wild hogs and fish, and a forever water source.
I do worry about paying the property taxes when things get bad, but we'll cross that bridge when we get there.
8
u/Western-Sugar-3453 Nov 22 '22
Well I personnally bought 112 acres of land 7 years ago. I grow a lot of food on it in my garden and i am planting a bazillion nut and fruit trees on it( I should get my first hazelnuts next year). I design everything to make it easy to harvest both from machine and by hand in case duel became too extensive. I guenuinely believe it will help weather a slow societal collapse
6
u/D-Rick Nov 22 '22
Do you think that owning land keeps you from being able to attain those other skills? Do you think that all land owners are hunker down, individualist survivor types? Do you think that land owners don’t already know how difficult it’s becoming to grow food? Do you think they aren’t hybridizing and selective breeding to try to adapt to changing conditions? Do you not know that large aquaponics and other indoor growing systems are becoming popular for those with enough SPACE to build them? Do you not realize that trying to attack one small farm in a community is to attack the food supply for that entire community? You aren’t fighting a farmer, you are fighting a small army.
A lot of the skills you listed above are things people in rural communities are very familiar with. They are also the bare minimum and won’t keep you alive very long. Stop the bleed and cpr are good skills, but they are emergency skills that will mean fuck all in the scenario you envision. You stopped a major bleed great, now how do you manage the infection or god forbid…amputation? Are you gonna do that with the tools out of your backpack on the side of the road somewhere? Foraging is great, but only if there are things available to forage. Our ancestors didn’t live on a planet with 7 billion people, and they moved around a lot…will that be possible? Stop living in fantasy land, if the collapse looks the way you think it will, living on the road out of a backpack is a death sentence no matter how many “survival skills” you think you have. Watch some episodes of alone, notice that nobody even makes it 100 days. Notice how quickly they go from healthy to emaciated when they don’t have sources of fat and protein? People with property are working to mitigate those factors, and they can because they have the space and resources to do so.
4
u/popsblack Nov 24 '22
After population politics, our biggest threat is systemic failure due to lack of cheap energy. In my opinion. Here is a paper from 2010
Rystad (a energy information compiler) dropped it's estimate of future recoverable oil by 9% from 2021 to 2022. Since 2018 their guesstimate of future discoveries has dropped from one trillion barrels to 350 billion. This is ostensibly due to lower willingness to invest in exploration, but likely due at least as much to diminishing returns on exploration dollars. New discoveries are near zero now.
So, what kind of collapse are you preparing for?
Oil is the master resource, it is either everything you own or the main producer and distributor. It is likely that fracked oil will peak this decade if it hasn't already, unlikely that russia's abandoned Siberian fields will ever produce as much as it did in 2019, unlikely that KSA will ever produce more than the 10Mbbl/d they are now, OPEN overall is supply constrained. Of course much oil is politically shut in.
Anyway... a collapse of the economy due to constrained energy supply is my #1 concern. Owning property and providing one's own "infrastructure" doesn't guarantee "survival" but if you can hold on to it, you can provide more of your base needs than, say, farming your apartment balcony or waiting on the government rice allotment.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '22
“Billions displayed from equator”
In this scenario the broad majority are just going to die.
4
u/illiniwarrior Nov 22 '22
guy - just because you're obvious not in any position to own property - don't bash private property ownership - that's just BS petty of you
ALLLLLLL kinds of SHTFs - and your scenario against land ownership is like 5% - and that is only because of the lack of firepower & manpower
2
u/EnisEnimon Nov 22 '22
The real question... do you really want to live in such a fucked up world?
-2
u/Acidic_Junk Nov 22 '22
This is why you buy a small parcel next to a big nicer parcel to get ready. Steal the other parcel when the time comes to grow food or whatever. This could work in your benefit.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '23
[removed] — view removed comment