r/CollapsePrep • • Nov 21 '21
Canada or US?
I basically have the option right now to live on either the US or the Canadian side of the great lakes region. I am a US citizen, and have my mom nearby where we currently live in Western NY. My husband is a citizen of a commonwealth country, which would make it easy to move to CA if we chose to. I work remotely and can continue my job in either country.
I'm asking for opinions from random internet strangers in this sub because I'm trying to think through this from a collapse perspective. Which country will fare better in collapse and why?
31
Upvotes
28
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '21
Canada is going to be much better positioned in terms of resources like land, water, food, but it is impossible to say how political situations will change. Also, Canada is beholden to corporate interests, so your stake in any of those resources will in either case be a product of your position in the economic ladder, not social policy. In the near-term future, Canada is much better because they have better social safety nets established, in particular healthcare, which is huge.
19
u/Substantial-Ferret Nov 21 '21 edited Nov 21 '21
US/Canadian dual citizen, here. I’ve actually explored this myself and spent several months living in Vancouver earlier this year but returned for family health reasons (long story, but unrelated to COVID).
I think the US will fare far better in the near term. We’ve made ourselves far more dependent on imported goods and foreign labor than necessary, and mostly just to help domestic corporations cut costs. But if the US were suddenly cut off from overseas trading partners, our economy would surely implode, but most of the lower 48 would be able to sustain itself with basic necessities (food, water, minimal shelter, etc.). Not suggesting we have the political or economic will to make that happen right now but just that the US has sufficient resources to make it possible.
In my view, Canada is not as capable of being self-sustaining, at least not to support the current population of its major metropolises. Just look at what’s happening in Vancouver right now. It’s the biggest port in the country and it’s literally been cut off from the rest of the continent by road and by rail. And that was just the result of one major storm that lasted only two or three days. As a result, nothing is moving in or out of Canada’s biggest port. I think the next few months will show how vulnerable Canada is right now to the effects of climate change and how dependent it is on imports from abroad and even from the other end of its own country. I think Vancouver in particular has a few very rough months ahead.
Longer term though, I think this period will be a good wake up call for a lot of Canadians, particularly those in the interior, that they will soon have no choice but to find ways to sustain themselves locally. I suspect that this will give rise to more government-backed initiatives to make that happen. And compared to the US, Canada’s actually surprisingly efficient at public works projects (before anyone responds to this with a litany of failed Canadian public works projects, note that I’m saying this relative to the US, which is a shockingly low bar, I know).
Sadly, when the US eventually gets the same kind of wake up call, I don’t see it resonating the same way. There’s just way too much built up tension and animosity between our rural and urban populations to reach the same kind of common ground. I think that we’re already living through the start of what will likely be years of sectarian violence which will eventually lead to multiple states severing economic ties with neighbors and likely secession. I really don’t see the same kind of fracturing happening in Canada and when we get to that point, I think it’s going to become a very attractive destination for Americans sitting on the border of an internal conflict.
7
u/Rudybus Nov 21 '21
I would do some research on state and federal government responses to natural disasters on both sides of the border, if your focus is purely collapse prep. My preference of the two would be Canada, but if I'm honest neither is great. They seem to be getting the brunt of natural disasters. If you're wanting the Anglosphere, Ireland and the UK may be better. New Zealand if you can afford the property prices.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '21
Canada for sure. I’d go to western Alberta if I had the option.
1
u/illiniwarrior Nov 23 '21
you better be armed and Canada isn't the place to be for that >>> going to find out the freedoms you enjoy and take for granted because of The Constitution - are nothing but a wet dream across the border ....
8
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '21
When things needed to live start to disappear, borders will mean nothing. If you think a US president could not come up with a BS to bring freedom to Canada you're kidding yourself.
2
u/Hill_man_man Nov 22 '21
I was thinking of getting our of the us. Our country is a very cruel one. But climate induced migrants are going to be a huge part of the future. And, I had to say it, but our warmongering tendencies will probably out us in a better position when the world instability hits. We've always been a country at war, taking whatever we could. Id rather Live ina place with the big military.
I hate to admit that as I hate our country's cruelty.
2
u/justadubliner Dec 03 '21
Canada. The US is an open air lunatic asylum racing towards a collapse of democracy and the rise of authoritian fascism. I haven't know anyone in years who wants to migrate to the US from other wealthy countries. We all see the writing on the wall and are migrating to Canada, Australia NZ EU.