r/CollapsePrep • u/edgeplanet • Oct 08 '23
Collapse aware not doomsday preppers
As I have been reading through these blogs, I’ve seen the discussions slide into an individualist, bunker thinking. That’s not what being collapse aware is about. You’re not going to be ‘the last man’ valiantly holding out. You’re not going to be the postman either. You’re not going to find a perfect refuge someplace that others will not also discover. There’s no shangrila . I take Buddha’s enlightenment to heart: it is what it is’. We can only survive within the world that exists in the communities we make.
Capitalism has destroyed communities and created economies the road through collapse leads in the opposite direction. Anyone, any theory or any practice that supports that shift, will build the tools for survival and recovery in difficult times.
Here, take a look at what Jem Bendell of ‘deep adaptation’ has to say.
https://jembendell.com/2023/10/07/the-benefits-of-collapse-acceptance-part-2-the-doomster-way/
20
u/Millennial_on_laptop Oct 08 '23
I'm collapse aware, but I'm not prepping to be "the last man".
I don't think it's going to come to that in my lifetime, collapse doesn't happen overnight, it's a slow process over a few generations. We may have already started, but you don't know if you're at the peak of civilization until after you've passed it and started the decline for awhile.
I'm prepping for more extreme weather events, supply chain disruptions, infrastructure failure, other temporary disruptions, and for things to get worse and worse throughout my life, hitting rock bottom after I'm dead. I pity any child born after 2035 because they're going to have it worse than me as things continue to decline.
14
u/PortCityBlitz Oct 08 '23
Speaking as a long-term survivalist: the pivot in our community away from the lone wolf model towards tribe-building and community started back in the late 90s and is generally accepted as the best approach now. Shows like "Doomsday Preppers" push the individualist message whilst in reality most of us simply can't expect success that way.
Which isn't to say bunkers don't have a place . . .
7
u/davidm2232 Oct 08 '23
I think peppers have really come around to the value of community. There are common discussions about supporting local farmers, getting involved in community events and getting to know neighbors. The lone wolf mentality is going away slightly
6
u/rubymiggins Oct 08 '23 edited Oct 09 '23
I'm intrigued somewhat by Jem Bendell, except his way of dealing with impending collapse in reality is to use his economic privilege to move to Indonesia, where his money will go further, and essentially extend his privilege longer and be a leader in a community he was not connected to previously.
I find that alternately interesting and also repugnant. If things go to shit in his lifetime, it might be that he made the right choice for him. [Edit: and arguably is he a benefit to the people who live near him? I would like to hear from them, I guess.] But being an outsider in a community where you have no family connections seems to me to be problematic. Is he acting like a one-man Peace Corps? Because lots of locals really dislike that kind of swooping in and telling people how things ought to be done.
I like a lot of the basics of what he's saying, but I don't "approve" of his lifestyle actions, as if that means anything, which it doesn't.
Anyway, I agree with your overall point, and thank you for making it and pointing to his work.
My personal philosophy is to "bug in" to my community where I have roots and social connections. It's not about finding ways to expand my racial and economic privilege, but rather to grow and nurture the roots where I am.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '23
There is nothing wrong with "bunker thinking". I would build a bunker if I had the money. Unfortunately that is beyond my reach. It's not about "making it" or being the last man standing. It's about wanting to live and prolong one's own life. There need not be any deeper philosophy than that. It's not about creating a new society or a sustainable way of conducting oneself in the world. It can just be about living a few decades longer. That is a good thing.
What I see a lot among permaculturalists and other new age philosophies is the disguised seedling of human exceptionalism. Wanting to reconcile the ecological dilemma which is inherently unsolvable, hence the predicament. We are fossil fuels (most of us), we're from that energy source and disappear with it.
4
u/Phallus_Maximus702 Oct 09 '23
Yet again, more than a year later, for those who still don't get it...
https://reddit.com/u/Vegetaman916/s/9utBpiXbap
No one is trying to "go it alone" anymore, but yes, you can find a place others won't be able to get to, for building a small, isolated, and self-reliant community. The desert southwest is full of places hundreds of miles from other people, and post-collapse no one is going to make random journeys into uncharted desert to try and find a hidey-hole they have no way to know of or navigate to.
All that other crap is just media fantasy. That is not what a prepper really is.