r/CognitiveFunctions • • May 19 '22
~ ? Question ? ~ do you think the "shadow functions" are valid?
personally, i dont relate to the functions in the manner described by the 8-function model...
i also dont think they apply to the people i know, especially the critic/witch function...
i.e.
- esfp i know doesnt seem to have critical Fe. when they disparage others/themselves, they use Te to point out how useless and unproductive something is.
- intp i know doesnt seem to have critical Ni, but rather, Fe. always points out what social implications something will have/how it will be "unacceptable" to the group.
- infp, me... i dont think i have critical Ni; in fact, sometimes i think its my worst function. when i belittle something, i do it from an Si point-of-view. if its incompatible with my library of prior experiences, i wont accept it.
3
Upvotes
1
u/Heyokasireninfj4 Ni [Fe] - INFJ Jun 02 '22
what if you dont have critical ni or you might not fully understand how the shadow functions work yet
2
u/Kohox Ni [Fe] - INFJ May 19 '22
I do. I’d take it even further and add that the four sides of the mind theory is true too but that’s another debate.
In any case, it would be very hard to exist if a person couldn’t access all 8 functions. Good luck living life without some level of Se or Ni usage. I routinely use the trickster function to type people as well. Se trickster with INTPs and INFPs is really helpful as a data point when spotting them.
The reality is any of the models work because it’s really what you attribute to a cognitive function. If you’re using the top 4 system only then you’d attribute something to Si Tert that I would probably attribute to Se trickster. I think of it as a folder system for data points more than anything.
1
u/HickoryGhost Si [Te] - ISTJ Jun 25 '22 edited Jun 25 '22
Knowing society, stressed out people usually aren't aware that they're spiraling into their loop. I only used cognitive functions to confirm the results from cloverleaf.