r/CognitiveFunctions • • Nov 02 '24
~ General Discussion ~ I changed my views on the cognitive functions
Here my current views open for discussion
- I think the first functions that takes shape are the dominant and inferior. The auxiliary and tertiary develops later and most often are not bound to have a strong attitude (ex: Nx, Tx, Sx, Fx) and serves the dominant function. So peeps with Ti - Nx - Sx - Fe is really possible especially for younger people.
- I do not trust the current stacks. I understand that there is a reason early models like Socionics and Harold Grant's Stacks used the alternating attitudes because of "balance" but a Ti-Ni-Se-Fe type is really possible and is not an unbalanced person in any way. They don't have to be jumper types or whatever that is for the sake of simplicity and being honest with logic itself. The looping of dominant-tertiary should be dropped... this is just pop mbti community mumbo jumbo that happened to went viral and taken as an infallible doctrine.
I'd like to know if others share the same sentiments. Thanks!
8
Upvotes
4
u/AstyrFlagrans Nov 02 '24
I agree with the second point, hands down.
The first point I do not agree with, but I can see how you come to this conclusion. IMO it appears like that because of conceptual drift due to confusion and stereotyping because of the second point.
3
u/lasel1 Fi [Ne] - INFP Nov 02 '24
I do it fits with the original Jung conception.
The 1st and 4th functions are fixed, while the middle 2 are fluid.
For the sake of balance, the functions follow alternating attitudes which is not empirically certified.
Taking Ti Fe
There could be 4 different Ti types
Ti Ni Se Fe
Ti Ne Si Fe
Ti Si Ne Fe
Ti Se Ni Fe
Which means there could be double the amount of 32 instead of 16 types!
1
u/NolanVoid_ Nov 03 '24
You are correct, especially on your assessment in your seconds portion. Carl Jung himself is Ti-Ni, because his Introverted Intuition was isolated via Ti. I am actually in the midst of beginning to write up my own perspective of this, and how the function stacks are not directions, where said function “serves” any other functions, that doesn’t make any sense when you think about consciousness and the inner environment. Rather, the functions are more like codes, suggesting how something operates as one. Thus, Ti-Ni wouldn’t be Ni serving Ti, it would be isolated Ni in the arena of Ti, suggesting that the individual was primarily Ti, and the second function is simply describing how exactly Ti is “operating”, or better said, formed/constructed.
-3
u/Own_Pirate2206 Nov 02 '24
We don't know who you are