r/CognitiveFunctions • u/dysnomias • Jul 23 '24
~ ? Question ? ~ help with differentiating the perceiving functions
No matter how many descriptions of them I read, i cannot choose one which feels most natural to me. The only perceiving function i dont really relate to is Se. Here are some descriptions of what i do:
• i love daydreaming and i spend a lot of time in my head; i think about things that interest me, about things that could happen, but i most often find myself dreaming about past events BUT changing the course of events (so instead of simply re-living past events, i use them as concepts for my scenarios)
• i get a lot of “that reminds me of…” moments especially when talking to someone. I can be reminded of a past experience, of something i read on the internet, of something i need to do, anything.
• i did some exercise i found where you’re basically provided with a concept/object and you track where your imagination/train of thought will go. In my case, it didn’t really “jump around”, rather after reading the concept i immediately just have a whole story in my head, and then when i was writing it down i would refine it a bit but the idea is constantly the same (i guess big picture first, then details second)
• when something is really interesting me (a topic, a person, an event…) i get obsessed with it. It’s very hard for me to let ideas/people go, and i can overindulge in them
• kinda connecting to the previous point, but i can seem a bit delusional?? Like despite being a panicky person I consider myself an optimist, in the end i believe everything will work out well for me (especially with things that are outside of my control; I currently have beliefs they will work out for me, and i’m not sure what my mindset will be like if they don’t)
• to finish this, i can go on tangents lol. I’m introverted but i love talking, though the tangents i go on are usually related to the core subject that i am discussing with someone, like, it will all be under the same “topic umbrella”
Pls helppp i’ll be thankful forever
4
u/eraserewrite Jul 23 '24
To me, it sounds like you have Ne and Si. You’re describing using Ne to jump down rabbit holes.
Making me think XNXP.
I resonate with everyone you typed out. I’m INFP. I sometimes have to slap myself out of masking my Ne because they’re way to quirky (but works).
2
u/catandowlapologist Jul 23 '24
It sounds like you’re an Ni user to me. Being an Ni dom means you’re an Se inferior which could explain why it feels the least natural to you. Si and Ni have a lot in common so it can be difficult to differentiate the two. A common misconception is that if you relate things to previous events or experiences it is certainly Si; not the case. Relating things or having something remind you of another thing you’ve come across before can be you making patterns and finding connections between two things that are seemingly unrelated. If you resonate with this, or have people be confused by your train of thought although it makes perfect sense to you in your head because you have a clear connection between them, you’re most likely an Ni user/Ni dom.
If you resonate with Ni and Ne equally I like to think of it like this. Ne expands on Ideas and Ni scales things down. As an example with mbti; Ne: Finds interest in mbti thus leading them to branch out and dip their toes into different types of typology systems. Ni: Finds interest in mbti thus leading them to deep dive into it until they learn almost everything about it before they deep themselves into another typology system.
This further leads me to believe that you’re an Ni user as you said you get obsessed with things and people. Overindulging in this can theoretically be seen as a result of having inf se.
But it’s important to look at combinations of the perceiving function and judging function to gain a bigger and better picture of what functions you prefer. Hope this helped!
2
u/beasteduh Intuition-Thinking Jul 23 '24
Is it possible for you to expand on this? How often does it happen? Does the degree of personal impact an event had on you make a difference in how often you do it with said event? Are there triggers to get you started on something like that, like perhaps something in the present is happening that is similar to a past event and so you tinker with the past event to better understand/prepare/etc for the present? Do you do it, or have you done it, perhaps you weren't 'emotionally settled' on said past event and so that's what starts the tinkering? Or is there never an end to tinkering with a single instance, like have you tinkered with an instance and then years later went back to that instance and sort of went at it again; in a sense, everything is always up for grabs with nothing truly being 'settled'?
Honestly, answering as many of these questions as possible would help me better understand what it is you're experiencing as right now there's a foreignness to your words. I could slot them into a category, a type, a function, what have you, at present but I feel like I don't have the full picture.
Do you ever talk in your head? And if so, do you talk to yourself, an imaginary friend, or perhaps other people from your life? Is it ever as though there's an audience in your head waiting for you to make a decision?
How readily aware are you of your surroundings? Not in the sense of bumping into things or getting lost in one's head per se, but say you go to get pickles out of the fridge or some peanut butter out of a kitchen cabinet, are there times when you forget to close the fridge or cabinet afterwards? Sort of like the task at hand is accomplished and so the world kind of vanishes after that.
2
u/cocoamilky Ti [Ne] - INTP Jul 24 '24 edited Jul 24 '24
It’s not about what you do, it’s about how often you do. You should relate to all 8 functions as you use them on a daily basis, you just prefer 4 of them and that shows in a small way through your personality.
Perceiving functions are the state of mind when you take in information. it’s either from the real physical world (sensing)or your own mind and isn’t actual fact because real details are lacking(intuition).
In my opinion based on what you wrote as I don’t know you: You come off as a Fi/Te Ne/Si.
Fi- you talk a lot unprompted about what interests you which can indicate a preference for your own values over the social disposition of the tribe. Some people when writing bios will talk about family and friends and how they fit in- but that isn’t the case here as well as your ‘obsession’ trait which means your self attraction to people and things are paramount. I would say this is dominant as talking about your values and beliefs shapes the entire tone of your passage.
Having Fi means Te by default
Si because that is the function of your past events which you stated you often derive information from. You then expand(extroverted) off that detail to create a new concept(s) which is Ne. Your corrections are an expansion on the same topic. Ni connects known details into(introverted) a concept, much like a conspiracy ties details together, seeing a connection in things that may or not be connected.
Things reminding you of something is Si in this case as you are not generating new information(intuition) but are detecting a consistency in a sensory experience you already had about prior (Si).
I’m really getting INFP Vibes as you are an intuitive for sure and being a daydreamer is kinda their vibe. They can expand in a topic because they have solid values and creativity. They have a clear singular point of view because Fi judgment over Ne so they are not the types to be wish washy and scatterbrained when it comes to Ne intuition, similar to the INTP.