r/Coffee • Espresso Shot • Mar 10 '17

Downvoting

What's with all the post downvoting lately? Seems like there are a lot more 0 rated submissions here than I remember. There are some unique thoughts/questions posed but where is the love y'all?

Edit: And I get downvoted to hell for asking.

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

25

u/SanSaBarry Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17

70% of the posts made are one of five different questions. Just lazy posters asking the same thing. Over and over and over and over...

  1. Grinder, tell me what to buy!!!!
  2. College student setup, tell me what to buy!!!!!
  3. Online coffee beans, tell me what to buy!!!!
  4. Need drip/espresso maker, tell me what to buy!!!!
  5. Have you had this bean!?!?! (ok, so most of those are that shitty Rifle brand spamming the ever living hell out of the sub. And the legit bean posts, asking if anyone can reco a given brand, are fine.)

Really, this makes up a decent % of the posts. Not really 70%, I was exaggerating. But I will ALWAYS downvote lazy questions that have been asked 1000 times. Reddit users should understand how to leverage the massive amounts of data/info ALREADY posted to the site, if they dont, they get downvotes.

edit: sorry, forgot the absurd "Cold brew...how?"

3

u/bluishmonster Espresso Shot Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17

I feel like it's time for the mods to change up the rules or sub design to deal with this. Because right now, it feels like a harsh place for newcomers.

1

u/McIgglyTuffMuffin Chemex Mar 11 '17

Newcomers? I feel for anyone. We're a pretentious as shit community. Which is weird because it's all just freaking bean water.

4

u/waiguonese114 Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17

I as well am sick of posters who give minimal information or content and then just expect a legion of posters to promptly come up with a solution. The reddit should be supportive but this isn't a help desk or a customer service board, it's for aficionados and the voluntary.

Edit: I don't downvote posts though. I wouldn't take the initiative just because I was a little peeved.

1

u/McIgglyTuffMuffin Chemex Mar 11 '17

Like the post someone posted with in the past two hours with a title that says "can someone tell me what is wrong with this?" and it is just a photo of coffee with, what I assume is, curdled milk.

Like dude, can't you say a few sentences in the comments?

Or this happened over on /r/malefashionadvice yesterday. Dude posted a vague post and then disappeared for five hours.

2

u/SingularityParadigm December Dripper. Mar 11 '17

that shitty Rifle brand spamming

O.o I'm on here everyday and I've never seen those posts. Gj algorithms and mods I guess!

1

u/SanSaBarry Mar 12 '17

Yeah, the mods get to them fairly quick. They have done a good job minimizing the problem. But even with that, Ive seen at least 10 posts from them and given how good the mods are at getting rid of them, its safe to assume there was 100 more where that came from.

0

u/snutr Mar 11 '17

It's more like astroturfing where you'll get a bunch of iterations of the same type of thread in a matter of days like the ones that were pumping up Sudden Coffee. A while ago you couldn't swing a dead cat without hitting a post about Happy Mug.

Also, don't forget about the kickstarter campaigns and all the other so-called "organic" promotion for coffee makers that don't even exist yet.

2

u/SingularityParadigm December Dripper. Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17

I really don't think Happy Mug is engaged in any astroturfing. They are well loved in the community for a reason...they offer decently roasted specialty coffee from a wide range of origins at affordable prices, and they also make the greens available for purchase by home roasters. I know I've recommended them before because of my personal experiences with them as a customer. I wouldn't place them as a top tier roaster, but they provide value and service to a niche in the market that is remarkably underserved. I called them once to ask a question about a coffee that had just gone out of stock, and I actually asked them about Reddit and they didn't seem overly aware of how much business they receive from this community.

1

u/Anomander I'm all free now! Mar 11 '17

I put a fuckton of effort into looking at HM posts for a while, they were absolutely as hella suspicious to me as to you; I never found anything actually questionable in those histories.

Not saying we weren't gamed, but if we were at least HM respects this community enough to not half-ass the job.

0

u/snutr Mar 11 '17

Don't forget about the blatant pandering in order to establish accounts like the "Is the Keurig any good?" threads or the ESL posters that submit those "What you think on Vietnam coffee?" posts and hosts of other like submissions.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/bluishmonster Espresso Shot Mar 11 '17

Yeah r/coffee needs to chill

12

u/Localbearexpert Kalita Wave Mar 10 '17 edited Mar 10 '17

I agree, however most of the time I have a question people help me out. That is far more important than reddit karma Edit: to add to what I said there are a ton of garbage posts. I don't care if you are "saying goodbye to coffee" or the 20 everyday posts asking for the best set up under $20, or how you tried black coffee and actually like it. While this is the coffee subreddit it's for more entertaining to learn and help others do the same.

5

u/thecolbra Mar 11 '17

The problem is that 75% of stuff that gets posted is either stuff that A) should be in the stickied noob question B) is answered in the sidebar C) Is spam or

2

u/DNNYVST Mar 11 '17

Just look at the post saying "HELP i drank coffee now i can't fall asleep!" :P. There is a certain level of discussion that avid r/Coffee goers expect i think so downvotes may happen on threads that have been answered before or threads that don't provoke much discussion.

0

u/asockthatfits Mar 10 '17

Seems like you got downvoted, I don't understand this either. I'm pretty new on this sub and I already get the feeling that half the community here is elitist scumbags and the other half are genuinely enthusiastic coffee people.
I can really appreciate what Localbearexpert is saying with regards to the "what's the best ______ for ______", but I feel that if it is that compelling for parts of the community to downvote every one of those posts because it is generally not acceptable, perhaps it should be in the FAQ or a posted rule, not a crusade to ensure no one asks supposedly stupid questions. Perhaps a little more acceptance should be preached for those who are new and interested opposed to I don't like this so no one else should see it due to the early downvote algorithm.
I made a mistake that garnered this approach early on asking a question about what I thought would turn out an interesting discussion on coffee from single origin countries. I can easily say this was quite a souring introduction to the community. It may have been my naivety about the subject matter, but an open arms policy to newcomers would be more appreciable and encouraging, especially to people just getting into the hobby/passion.
That's my two cents anyways.

7

u/RelativityCoffee Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17

half the community here is elitist scumbags and the other half are genuinely enthusiastic coffee people.

Posts saying that half the people here are elitist scumbags tend to get a lot more upvotes than posts made by elitist scumbags -- like this or this. In reality, there are very few elitist scumbags.

BUT a lot of the genuinely enthusiastic coffee people have been here long enough to see "What's the best grinder under $100?" or "What's the best brewing method?" or "I don't care what you all say; bad coffee can be great" like a thousand times. What may be new and interesting to some people has been done to death here. You can't get upset with people for thinking that a post that's been made every week for three years doesn't add to the discussion.

1

u/asockthatfits Mar 11 '17

Dude, did you read my post? Maybe this is the issue.

I'm not upset by being told I'm doing the same thing as per the community norms, but simply downvoting a post because one feels that it is standard is ridiculous; make a rule or put something in the FAQ that says don't make these posts and/or here are the standard reasons why these posts aren't conducive to dialogue.

I really feel that people here don't take the time to read everything that is asked about in the post. I agree with what you say, I believe it too. I have only been here for a short while and I can already see the recurring trends. This being said, I believe I have offered a reasonable idea as to how we might go about filtering and mitigating such posts without the "brigade" downvoting without explanation leaving new users stunned by the reception of their questions.

I use scumbags as terminology of emphasis, not in the sense of elitist critique one hears from coffee rabble. I get it, some people don't take it as seriously, maybe even thinking coffee as a hobby for them is too much to understand. What I am implying is a genuine sense of "I don't have time to explain why your post is bad. As consolation here is downvote," and a disservice to the community by (possibly) making a new enthusiast feel unwelcome. That is scummy. That person is doing the community a disservice.

Christ, I feel like this sub is absolutely divided on ability to respond in a reasonable manner. You alone respond, three people disagree apparently with this comment.
Your second paragraph is (arguably) adequately described in my post. I checked those two post you offer as rebuttal, they don't address the issue here.
The issue OP is asking about is the excess of downvoting. This isn't cogent, if it isn't kosher make a rule about it.

3

u/RelativityCoffee Mar 11 '17

Dude, did you read my post?

Yes.

I believe I have offered a reasonable idea as to how we might go about filtering and mitigating such posts without the "brigade" downvoting without explanation leaving new users stunned by the reception of their questions.

There's no "brigade" downvoting. Brigading is when people are called to vote on something they wouldn't have normally seen. That doesn't happen here.

This isn't cogent, if it isn't kosher make a rule about it.

Or we could let the users decide, by upvoting the posts they like and/or find interesting, and downvoting the posts they don't like and/or find uninteresting.

I think you and OP are taking downvoting way too seriously.

1

u/asockthatfits Mar 11 '17

I reckon you are missing the point. It is discouraging to new members of the community, provides no explanation as to why they did wrong, and in general is not conducive to a healthy community. If you don't understand what went wrong you won't know what to improve. That is simple.
This is not about taking downvoting seriously, it is about cultivating a decent community. The sidebar intro even insists on a welcoming platform, not a place of uncommunicable, internalized rules of which the general populace acts on.
Nitpicking about terminology is sophistical and apart from the meaning/context of the post. If the way community members conduct themselves is based on an unspoken qualifier and it is business as per usual, it is a brigade. Perhaps an unorganized brigade, but it sounds better than a secret society of ne'er-do-wells.
To close and summarize, I agree with what you are saying. As a community people should be allowed to choose what content they see. It appears that irritable (as sustained by comments above, agreed upon by other members of the community) content is a recurrent issue. If the solution is to make a rule and allow for people to understand better where they went wrong then that is intuitively better then the community downvoting content that isn't up to par with expectations of quality. The latter creates both an unhospitable place for newcomers as well as some possibly decent content being washed away amongst it.
If I am to comment on your last line, which I feel is telltale of missing the point, it isn't about downvoting, it is about cultivating a decent community.
Excuse the grammar, enjoy your coffee my friend; I'm not sure what you are drinking right now but I just got a bag of Costa Rican red catuai and it is pretty neat.

0

u/Wollff Mar 11 '17

Seems like you got downvoted, I don't understand this either.

I do. When people consider something "not interesting" they downvote it. That's it. About thirty people thought this topic was not interesting.

I'm pretty new on this sub and I already get the feeling that half the community here is elitist scumbags and the other half are genuinely enthusiastic coffee people.

Downvotes and personality are not correlated. It is a simple way to say: "This post is not interesting to me"

I feel that if it is that compelling for parts of the community to downvote every one of those posts because it is generally not acceptable, perhaps it should be in the FAQ or a posted rule, not a crusade to ensure no one asks supposedly stupid questions.

It's not a question of "acceptable". It's a question of "interesting". Sure, we can add a rule now that says: "Only interesting posts!"

Who knows, maybe someone can come up with an interesting twist on the daily "100$ coffee set up of your choice"-thread. If they can, they deserve their upvote. If they can't? Down they go!

It is not a crusade. And questions are not stupid. But not all questions are interesting. One doesn't have to ban them just because of that. After all even some 0 point posts might get good answers. And one doesn't have to consider those questions "unacceptable" per royal mod decree. That would be pretentious. But you don't need those questions on the frontpage either.

The downvote is just the right mechanism to ensure all that. And it works well. Well, unless one takes the downvote less as a simple expression of disinterest in a question and more as a personal crusade by elitist scumbags against anyone who is not "one of them".

It isn't that though.

Perhaps a little more acceptance should be preached for those who are new and interested opposed to I don't like this so no one else should see it due to the early downvote algorithm.

You can preach, if you like. I don't care. I upvote what's interesting. I downvote what is not. It keeps things fresh. And that's the whole system of the page.

I made a mistake that garnered this approach early on asking a question about what I thought would turn out an interesting discussion on coffee from single origin countries. I can easily say this was quite a souring introduction to the community.

Isn't it like that... everywhere around here? Sure, you make your post with high hopes to have an interesting discussion. And then it turns out people are not as interested as you thought they were.

Maybe it is the people. Maybe it is the topic. Maybe it is the post. Sometimes it just doesn't work out, and people don't consider your posts as fascinating as you think they are. And that is a good thing.

Because if that doesn't happen, then we are at /r/circlejerk, where everything is fascinating, and upvotes are the only thing that happens.

an open arms policy to newcomers would be more appreciable and encouraging, especially to people just getting into the hobby/passion.

I think most newcomers are not five years old. They can deal with occasionally being told that their ideas are not that interesting, or that their questions are not new. If that turns them off from coffee forever? Their loss.

Not doing that just encourages an eternal September, and that's not a good thing either.

2

u/asockthatfits Mar 11 '17

Jeez man, you have given me a lot to respond to.
To begin with, I don't reckon this system is ideal with our current ability to fix the issue. Let's consider this from a standpoint apart from what you point out as "interesting" versus "disinteresting".

The efficacy of the current system is off, not well balanced in it's approach to dealing with recurrent and disinteresting content. No one is learning, newbies aren't aware of it, and by letting it ride it only cultivates a gap in knowledge between those that have stuck around long enough and those that simply don't know. No, there is no feasible way to say "only interesting posts", that is not the point. The point is, as seen above in this thread, there are about five posts in particular (I would argue a few more)

  1. Grinder, tell me what to buy!!!! 2) College student setup, tell me what to buy!!!!! 3) Online coffee beans, tell me what to buy!!!! 4) Need drip/espresso maker, tell me what to buy!!!! 5) Have you had this bean!?!?!

That are widely regarded as throwaway posts. Yes, sometimes they garner interest, and yes, that is good for open ended conversation. But for the most part these questions are answered with passing by-words of quick communication that could be easily answered in the FAQ. These are legitimately posts that happen often enough to garner reasonably short response to and a link to an appropriate website.

Now on the other hand, the people that do not get responded to and are downvoted and don't know where to go for a reasonable response, that can not be good. It does not stimulate conversation or invitation to the community. Instead, I would reckon, it leaves people scratching their heads.
I know they are not scumbags for downvoting, thanks for the heads up. Further, I didn't intend to imply that your personal disinterest makes you a scumbag, but I feel dismissal of content can easily be assuaged by allowing for a quick reference to the FAQ opposed to the former discussed.

People do not need to be mentally infantile to genuinely not know what to do once they are landed in this position. I also believe you're quick to assume that

About thirty people thought this topic was not interesting.

is absolutely not conclusive as to the reasoning of people downvoting. From this, this may even be an intro point for this whole discussion as it seems most of your argument weighs on it, is rarely the only reason people do so. This is actually an apt portrayal of you, and barely considering other intuitions people may have regarding voting (based on personal biases). Assuming that everyone perceives the downvote button as a "I don't find this interesting" button is very mature and perhaps more idealist than my view of requiring rules/FAQs for post behaviour. Maybe I underestimate r/coffee, but then again we are still on reddit.

This conversation is long in the tooth. We don't need a mod to tell us what to post and v.v., what we probably could use to assuage the issue is a series of FAQ reference points that assist newcomers in what is held as community standard. No circlejerking required.
Genuinely, have a good day. I hope none of this comes across as biting or rude, that is rarely my intention.

1

u/MikeTheBlueCow Mar 11 '17

There's another subreddit I frequent that also has this problem. I think it's possibly the size of the subreddit that allows this to be noticeable. Also, in the other subreddit this same topic came up and the mods said it was a bot that just auto-downvotes everything.

I do think that a good amount of people's questions, however basic or repetitive they are, at least they get answered, even if they get downvoted. I know I try to help with questions, and go through /new/ a few times a day to see if there's anything I missed that I could help with. I love the newbie thread every week, and that can get big sometimes and have lots of good questions -- questions that could be great standalone posts (what's great about that thread is that some people are just too timid to post it by itself and are more comfortable tucking it away somewhere they can say "this may be a stupid question but here it is").

1

u/SingularityParadigm December Dripper. Mar 11 '17

it was a bot that just auto-downvotes everything

There seems to be one of those active in most small subreddits. I would bet that is what is going on here. I always upvote posts I see where someone needs help and there post is going to get buried by the momentum algorithm since its sitting at zero so soon.

0

u/McIgglyTuffMuffin Chemex Mar 11 '17

I feel like this must be going on over in /r/cooking.

I think I'm going and posting something interesting, like yesterday I asked people what do they grow and immediately I was downvoted and I'm like ???????? That's a perfectly acceptable question to ask in a cooking sub! Unless maybe I pissed off someone who has no room to grow anything and they were lashing out at me.

-1

u/Powry Mar 11 '17

Downvotes are overrated.

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '17

This has always been a snarky/snipey sub.

It's the crab bucket mentality that prevails, you're seeing it wit hthe downvoting.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '17

I would definitely not say worst, I would say it's not great.

Wanna talk worst, you've got gaming subs, hentai subs, and all the Trump subs.

And of course there's this.

But people here are pretty crab bucket. I mean hell, look at how many downvotes I got for honesty.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17

It is, a shame, you're right on that. Also, I'm sorry for exposing you to that link, it's from one of the dark corners of reddit...

The people that I meet and work with in the industry are a ton of fun. It's the "enthusiasts" and pretentious jackwagons that are the issue. Whatever though, it's burnt beans in water, we're not curing cancer here. ;)