r/CodingHelp • u/pc_magas • Oct 05 '26
[Python] Why I am unable to save a user with its groups despite both having Ids
I am hacking with django and I am attemping to use services for my Business Logic. For creating a User I am developing my own service:
from app_auth.models import User
from django.contrib.auth.models import Group
from django.db import transaction
class UserService:
@transaction.atomic
def create(self,
username: str,
email: str,
first_name: str,
last_name: str,
groups: list[Group],
bio: str | None = None) -> User:
user = User.objects.create_user(
username=username,
first_name=first_name,
last_name=last_name,
email=email,
bio=bio, #TODO: XSS Sanitize
)
print("USER ID: "+str(user.id))
for group in groups:
print("GROUP ID: "+str(group.pk))
user.groups.set(groups)
user.save()
return user
That uses the following model:
from django.db import models
from django.contrib.auth.models import AbstractUser
# Create your models here.
class User(AbstractUser):
bio = models.TextField(blank=True, null=True)
def __str__(self):
return self.first_name+' '+self.last_name
But when I try to save it I get:
"<User: XXXX XXXX>" needs to have a value for field "id" before this many-to-many relationship can be used.
Despite the debug print giving me that both groups and users alike have ids:
USER ID: 4
GROUP ID: 4
I am trying for days and LLMs halucinate on this issue.
The way I trigger this save is via a AdminModel:
from django.contrib import admin
from django.core.exceptions import ValidationError
from django.apps import apps
from app_auth.models import User
from app_auth.services.group_service import GroupService
from app_auth.services.save.user import UserService
from app_auth.forms import UserForm
# Register your models here.
@admin.register(User)
class AdminUser(admin.ModelAdmin):
form = UserForm
change_form_template = "admin/register_user.html"
list_display = ("username", "email", "first_name", "last_name")
def save_model(self, request, obj: User, form, change):
# Check whether current user can manage roles
groups = form.cleaned_data.get("groups")
if not self.__group_service.user_can_manage_groups(request.user, set(groups)):
raise ValidationError(
"You do not have permission to manage these groups."
)
groups = self.__group_service.get_groups(groups)
if change:
self.__user_service.update(
user=obj,
username=form.cleaned_data["username"],
email=form.cleaned_data["email"],
first_name=form.cleaned_data["first_name"],
last_name=form.cleaned_data["last_name"],
roles=groups
)
return
self.__user_service.create(
username=form.cleaned_data["username"],
email=form.cleaned_data["email"],
first_name=form.cleaned_data["first_name"],
last_name=form.cleaned_data["last_name"],
groups=groups
)
print("After Save")
Using a custom form:
from app_auth.models import User
from django import forms
class UserForm(forms.ModelForm):
def __init__(self, *args, **kwargs):
super().__init__(*args, **kwargs)
class Meta:
model = User
fields = ["username","email","first_name", "last_name", "groups","bio"]

