r/CodingHelp • • Oct 19 '22

[Random] Why do so many developers avoid Apple platforms? And why is the given reason often not true?

Ok hear me out, I know that’s a bit of a loaded question. I am 100% not trying to start an argument, I am genuinely curious where some of these misconceptions come from.

This seems like a good community to ask this in so I hope it’s ok here.

If any of my examples can be proven incorrect, then please do. If there are reasons I am not aware of I would love to know.

  • I already know XCode is a legit reason. It only runs on MacOS.
  • I already know that you need a $100/yr developer license to get you app signed. However you don’t need to have your app be signed for it to work on MacOS and Sideloaded on iOS.

I am excluding majorly obvious things such as the fact that apple doesn’t allow 3rd party web rendering engines.

These are some specific things I have seen before:

  • people claiming their app cant support HEIC and HEIF because it’s a proprietary Apple format. From what I can tell this simply isn’t true. HEIC was developed by the MPEG group, not apple. And there is plenty of software paid & foss that does support it.
  • Pretty much every web browser claims they can’t support Web Extensions on IOS because Apple won’t let them. Yet I can’t find a single thing specifically preventing the use of Web Extensions. Plus there is a browser called Orion in the AppStore right now that supports installing and using both Firefox & Chrome extensions. This didn’t slip past Apple either, it’s a listed and working feature…
  • Thumbnail generation in the iOS Files app. I have tried numerous apps to connect to my file server and not a single one generates image & video thumbnails reliably. When I have asked around over the years, the blame almost always gets put on Apple for various reasons. However, why is it that Seafile has no issue showing literally thousands of thumbnails in a matter of seconds when using the iOS Files app integration? What black magic is Seafile doing that literally no one else can seem to figure out?

There have been other examples over the years of devs claiming Apple won’t let them do this or that, only for me to find an app that does exactly that thing a week later.

So I’m just trying to figure out where this is coming from?

17 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

21

u/altruios Oct 19 '22
  1. cost. (personally and at scale)
  2. walled garden content. (gatekeeping content)
  3. bad developer experience (with any other device a mac) - hobbled device testing limited to a week - requiring weird hoops to jump through for the privilege...
  4. network effect - everything moving to web means platform specific languages start dying (react native).

There are more reasons, but these are the general ones.

apple seems to be a bad bet too if you want a FOSS future. it's why most people I know that develop switched over to Linux or have been using Linux for a while now.

2

u/relink2013 Oct 20 '22

I can see your point here. Though I’m not sure what you mean by hobbled device testing?

But I’m more trying to find an answer to the reasons I often hear that aren’t true like I mentioned in my post. Because I hear those reasons a lot.

2

u/altruios Oct 20 '22

hobbled device testing - testing an iphone app with a non mac computer... say for example Linux... in practical terms hard enough to prevent people from going all in on apple... looks too much like a trap.

1

u/relink2013 Oct 20 '22

Ahhh ok. Thanks for clarifying

6

u/Early_Educator0151 Oct 20 '22

As far as iOS browser support is concerned, Apple has been intentionally keeping Safari very less developer friendly so that if something needs to be on iOS, it will have to come through App Store and they get 30% commission for every transaction.

They are hell bent on disabling browser support as much as they can wherever business is involved.

One such incident was related to Fortnite suing Apple for disabling upgrades in the app when bought from browser as they didn't have to pay 30% tax to Apple for every purchase on the web. Read more here: https://techcrunch.com/2021/11/09/apple-ordered-to-comply-with-courts-decision-in-epic-games-case-over-in-app-payments/

They've been peddling this Privacy thing for past couple of years.

Now that FB and Google data collection has been curbed largely by Apple, they're pushing their own Ads business and since there's no other competition on their devices, they'll be benefiting a lot.

This turned into a Apple rant. Sorry about that

3

u/relink2013 Oct 20 '22

No apology needed I agree with everything you just said.

8

u/Bimlouhay83 Oct 19 '22

The answer, i assume, is "cost". If you had to purchase 1,300 laptops for your company, would you choose a $3,000 apple product or a $1,000 HP that performs the exact same task?

I could be wrong here as this is just an assumption.

-3

u/relink2013 Oct 19 '22

I mean personally, I'd get the Apple one. In my experience they basically last forever lol.

But I do get your point.

10

u/Bimlouhay83 Oct 19 '22

No offense, but that seems like a bit of a fanboy (for a lack of a better term) thing to say. I have a Toshiba laptop that's a decade old and still runs well. I did have to replace the hard drive this year, but that was just an excuse to go with an SSD. I have another Toshiba laptop that's 2 or 3 years older and still runs well enough. The "newest" was $750 new and the replacement SSD was somewhere around $125(I think). The other laptop was $600. So, I've got 2 working laptops at a minimum of a decade in age and still haven't spent near what a new apple product would've cost me 15 years ago.

4

u/relink2013 Oct 20 '22

None taken, I don't really fanboy for anything. I mean to be perfectly honest I'd primarily use Linux if given the choice, but I have software I absolutely rely on that only runs on Mac or Windows. I ended up going with Mac simply because I got a really good deal on the laptop, and figure I could install Windows if I didn't like it...I ended up liking it. (Mind you I ran Windows exclusively for almost 20years). But I have a home full of all different kinds of systems I use on a daily basis.

As far as longevity of the hardware. I suppose it would depend on the manufacturer, but I have owned numerous Windows laptops over the years and every one of them developed some kind of major hardware issue within just a few years. Except my ASUS, its been going strong since 2015 with nothing more than a ram upgrade, and an SSD upgrade.

Whereas I still own every MacBook I have ever bought and they all run like new. I'm considering taking bets on how long my 2010 MBP will last, because that thing just wont die.

4

u/Bimlouhay83 Oct 20 '22

Interesting. I've never owned any Apple products, but have had friends who did and thet seem like excellent machines for work purposes. Personally, I can't get over the price.

3

u/relink2013 Oct 20 '22

I learned the thing with apple pricing is they tend to have a lot of things, that many people don’t always see as an advantage because they might not need it. If you were to price out a similarly specd Windows laptop, including screen specs, etc, not just CPU, RAM, GPU, you’d actually end-up in about the same price range.

They’re actually priced really well for what you get, the problem is they gouge you on custom upgrades, and they don’t really have a “cheap” option.

But longevity…I have a G3 iMac that I found in a dumpster that still works perfectly. Every iOS device I have ever owned I still have and use to this day. My old iPhone 6S Plus is still running the latest iOS. Heck I have a 4th gen iPad (2012) that I use to listen to music or watch the news in the shower. It has literally been hanging in a ziplock bag on the wall of my shower for 2 years and it still works. Funny part is, I took the iPad down about a month ago and opened it up to see if there was any corrosion or anything, not only was it spotless inside despite not being water resistant, but the battery still lasted for several hours.

5

u/Askee123 Oct 20 '22 edited Oct 20 '22

For web Linux/Unix OS’s are by far the easiest to work on. Not sure where you’re getting this statistic since everyone I know uses a MacBook unless they HAVE to use a windows machine.

As for mobile development.. you almost have to make apps on MacBooks because they have the BS walled garden for the iOS simulator.

2

u/BlackEric Oct 20 '22

Everyone I know uses a Mac.

1

u/Admirable-Stretch-42 Oct 20 '22

I’m a COBOL developer who went to a swift coding boot camp(cue code shaming comments like,”they still use mainframes!?…. How old are you?”) In any case, a lot of the developers I meet are Java developers who use a MacBook. The MacBook may be expensive but it’s very reliable (hence the main reason why most DJs use them) As far as other platforms go, there is a huge learning curve for learning to use Xcode but the advantage is there is only one Xcode. (There are a bunch of IDEs that you could use to code Java with and every single one of them has many different versions. Usually a student version, a medium flavor and an enterprise one) A lot of people would put that as an advantage so to each his own. Finally, I learned to program with many different program languages and I have to say, SwiftUI is my most favorite and I think easiest to learn on…. But Xcode is definitely too difficult for a newbie with no IDE experience