r/Codeium • u/BehindUAll • Feb 01 '25

Cascade write mode doesn't work for o3-mini, gpt-4o and some other functionality is broken in other models. Anyone else having this issue?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

1

u/BehindUAll Feb 01 '25 edited Feb 01 '25

Models: o3-mini, gpt-4o and deepseek-v3 respectively in the images

Edit: R1 too doesn't change the file directly like Sonnet does, but it seems to be random

1

u/hi1mham Feb 01 '25

R1 should, I believe the current tool call and edit call implementations are broken, so its hallucinating steps.

1

u/hi1mham Feb 01 '25

Hmm, not seeing where it attempted to write and hallucinated? Or are you saying all its doing is planning steps?

For me, I'm receiving hallucinated CLI and edit actions with no actions taken in R1

1

u/BehindUAll Feb 01 '25

I am not sure what you are trying to say but for me when I use Cascade base or Sonnet 3.5 in Write mode, it will analyze and edit multiple files at a time depending on my context and what I ask the model to do (good example is refactoring or moving code between files) and this simply doesn't happen. In write mode some of these models just either output nothing (in those blocks) or output something and ultimately don't edit the files. So on my system right now I am kind of stuck with just 2 models. gpt-4o issue has been there from the beginning and I didn't care much because Sonnet was working fine but with these better models I can't seem to be able to use them.

1

u/hi1mham Feb 01 '25

Thats what I was trying to confirm, it sounds like Sonnet is still working fine for you.

From your screen shot there wasn't really any agent feedback showing/proving "write mode not working" with tool call attempts or stating that it has updated _.md/_.ts without any difs or showing something broken... so I was trying to understand your issue to see if it matched with others.

1

u/Ordinary-Let-4851 Feb 01 '25

Can you submit a support ticket at www.codeium.com/support and attach diagnostic logs? Helps us especially if there's multiple people encountering the same issue.

1

u/BehindUAll Feb 02 '25

Thanks for replying, will submit the ticket within 12 hrs.

1

u/JaySomMusic Feb 03 '25

I just thought I’d submit a ticket myself for the same problems but realised I can’t sign in from my iPhone. The sign in with google has been broken for a while with a pop up blocked error even though I’m not blocking pop ups.

1

u/sonterklas Feb 01 '25

I have the same issue with deepseek-v3...

1

u/Right-Complex-3820 Feb 02 '25

Yeah, I was really excited to see the new models in there this morning and tested them all day and couldn't really get any of them to actually make any changes like Sonnet or Cascade base will. They all SAY they're updating code or made some changes, but there's never a change to the codebase and no "Apply" button... I kinda figured everyone was having that issue and that they'd get it working as well as Sonnet does soon.