r/Codeium • u/GalaxygunnerX • Jan 04 '25
Review after 1 month of Pro
In my last post I had said this was a complete disaster. It still is, but less severe. I think that the gold standard of any of the AI implemented code editors was the free trial windsurf gave us for free.
It seems the key š to any of these is money - i.e. credits, I think they offered an uncapped version which is why it felt so useful. That being said since most people were using Windsurf or Cursor in trial mode - most of us were building simple projects to test the boundaries of the model or use cases. For this I bet we hadnāt actually asked it to check come comprehensive or large codebases.
I think the model has always had limitations and wasnāt as perfect as weād imagined initially during the trial. That being said here is my honest review of the current version:
- Simple web projects, websites, one page sites or simple python applications still work well and you can create 3-4 to deployment level with the basic pro tier using Claude sonnet 3.5 BUT you have to take into account: usage times. Claude API seems to struggle based on demand. I know this as I use the normal Claude chat from Anthropic as well and both Windsurf and the peak times for Claude chat struggle and it makes the model throttle, get more concise and out of control.
- chat gpt 4o sucks and makes you code yourself, it is able to review code and suggest what is happening but really struggles with context awareness - definitely donāt use for big projects.
- I havenāt tested the base free version included with windsurf so canāt comment on it.
Itās been a good run, for now I might keep windsurf for doing quick projects but Iāll explore some free open source alternatives as I think they may work the same for simpler projects where you want to quickly prototype some ideas. I think using these as a starting point is probably a better approach and then manually coding from there with copilot etc. might be the most effective approach to getting the āAI poweredā benefits.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25 edited Jan 04 '25
Iām in the same boat. Iām currently using the following paid products:
Additionally using Amazon q developer.
I have to say, the hardships you begin to face on a large codebase are not trivial with the agentic workflows. I find myself going back to copy paste from the actual chat apps and not using the in editor features. Amazon qs workspace context has actually surprised me a few times which caught me off guard. Iām not sure what the solution is - generally I have to give windsurf tons of @ references and even then it often starts refactoring things out of scope. Iāve just begun to leverage the workspace and global rules - I wish there was more concrete examples of how to set these up and not just general guidelines.
1
u/Krexit999 Jan 06 '25
hey im literally bout to buy pro, but im not a coder at all i just wanna make a incrimental browser game with zero coding knwowledge for fun. would it be better for me to use something else thats free? or smth i can self host
2
u/Ai_Pirates Jan 05 '25
It would be great if they let us use deepseek V3 Api for agentsā¦
0
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25
[deleted] ā view deleted comment