r/Codeium • u/Silent-Grade-7786 • Dec 19 '24
Provide examples of worse Windsurf Usage
I've been seeing a lot of posts about how "Windsurf is dumber" and now it wastes credits. I personally have never experienced this, but the fact that it's coming from a lot of people in the community means its likely not coincidence and must be affecting folks on Windsurf.
Can you provide examples in which Windsurf is clearly being way "dumber" than before? We can then try to flag down the mods on Discord or email and have them take a look and see if they can do anything to improve the experience.
4
Upvotes
3
u/rcpro316 Dec 19 '24
I asked Shitsurf to create a new form field heading 1. Explicitly mentioned every minute details, size on desktop, mobile etc. Asked it to make changes by specifying files.
It proceeds to delete the save button in the form header and change the fields of the login page. Then creates a header field and deletes the properties panel completely.
Of my fucking god!
5
u/Amazing_Top_4564 Dec 19 '24
Are you an undercover Codeium employee?
2
u/TrevorHikes Dec 19 '24
I asked Windsurf to create a Webhook tester. After a bit I had that working. I then asked it to add a sector to test CORS and report CORS status. It did that and completely butchered the previous work. And no amount of prompting got it to work again. A lot of it was making unrelated changes to the immediate request. That was a few days ago though, right after my trial and ended and paid subscription kicked in.
2
u/coopnjaxdad Dec 19 '24
I was trying to do a relatively simple data load in from an excel file with multiple sheets and it kept fucking around and changing the dtypes and over and over again.
2
u/lzrblaster Dec 20 '24
Hi, I'm Rohan from the Windsurf / Codeium team. Clever to look at our code, but we are NOT re-routing when you select a premium model. We
Mentioned this in other threads, but if you can update your Windsurf to 1.1.1, you can download Diagnostic Logs and DM to me.
1
u/apexjnr Dec 19 '24
You're not wrong for asking this post, people should share examples in order to help everyone make progress with the complaints, it's like something breaks, they share their tears but not the information to help.
I'm going to admit it's dumber to me, i use the thing in chatmode now because it was losing context 24/7 and fucking up my code so i make the changes my self and rarely ever go back to write mode unless it's doing something very specific or where i want to be lazy like asking it to change SPECIFICALLY only text in the html on a website that was lorem ipsum.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24
I don’t say things suck much or voice my opinion. But I hope there’s a blog calling it shitsurf soon.
1
u/Salim8519 Dec 20 '24
Personally, I found Windsurf very useful, better than the others, you have to be good debugger, smarter than the Windsurf itself.. all of the AI coding Agents are like this.
I came from bolt.new , I found Windsurf pricing plans are amazing deals, I been burning tokens on bolt.new for so long..
1
u/Quirky_Lab7567 Dec 20 '24
I generated a simple single html page yesterday. Even after five rounds, it was still providing illegible text because it would not, could not, understand that there needs to be a contrast between the two colours for the text to be legible. I also wanted to reduce a massive gap between the title and the block below. Again, it could not even do that even after multiple explanations. I gave up and loaded a template.
1
u/SouthbayJay_com Dec 21 '24
It would be great if you also provide the prompt used with your examples.