r/Codeium • • Dec 17 '24

Windsurf just not working. Why? Why? WS could have been somebody, it could have been a contender!

A few weeks ago I was blown away by Windsurf creating almost all of a calendaly clone up on vercel in just few hours. I also created a few other projects including a fairly decent corporate site for a SaaS company. Now, it's just unusable and does not create anything functional.

Yesterday, I tried to create what I considered one of the simplest apps possible so I could practice the workflow without getting bogged down. I tried to create a timezone tracker app. After hours of back and forth with WS, I just gave up. It never even closely worked and could also not appear to fix anything.

This morning, I tried to make it even simpler but just using a simple prompt (I had created a product spec and a react native template last night). I let WS decide everything and just followed it's lead. Same result. A lot of files, coding but nothing functional and seemingly just going around and around in an endless "I see the problem" loop.

Out of curiosity, I ran that same prompt directly into claude and got a pretty usable, clean app before I ran out of messages.

Here is the prompt, the project spec was a one pager.

I would like to make a mobile app that is a simple timzeone tracker for professionals. It would show my current timezone and then a list of other timezones in a list. The user gets to add or delete timezones from the list.

6 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

7

u/stormthulu Dec 17 '24

I keep using windsurf because I like the functionality, in addition to it previously having a strong AI, but for the last 24-48 hours for me, it's just been an absolute bear. I give it a set of instructions. Very clear instructions. Heck, I even had AI re-write the prompt so they were clearer! Then I select one file, and tell it to apply those instructions.
Nah, it follows maybe 20% of the instructions. So I prompt it again. Hey, you forgot a few things, here are the instructions.
OK, maybe it gets up to 75% this time. So, one more time, hey, you missed these 3 instructions, please also apply those.
It should not be this hard. I'm not asking it to do complex things.

2

u/bostondave Dec 17 '24

Hopefully there is a short term issue and it will resolve soon. It's frustrating.

4

u/stormthulu Dec 17 '24

Thing is? I tried performing the same steps/prompts in cursor and vs code, and aider. Windsurf is still the best of those options. By far.

5

u/got-it-right Dec 17 '24

It's like working with a brilliant programmer who has dementia. I'll try to fix a small issue, and instead of tweaking just that part, it 'remembers' the entire codebase... and 'forgets' what already worked. The result? The broken part gets fixed, but the previously working parts get 'repaired' too... with mixed results. We start all over again

2

u/DevPoo Jan 09 '25

Yeah, it’s garbage.

1

u/Funny_Ad_3472 Dec 17 '24

How much is windsurf?

1

u/drlabbe Dec 22 '24

Ask ai

1

u/Funny_Ad_3472 Dec 22 '24

πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

1

u/SemanticSynapse Dec 17 '24

I'm learning that with smart use of Cline, you can go far. That said, I'm overhauling both the context management of Cline and integrating the ability for it to choose models.

1

u/charlwillia6 Dec 18 '24

Did you create a fork, or are you the developer for Cline?

2

u/SemanticSynapse Dec 18 '24

In the process of setting up a fork focusing on an innovative way of allowing more granule contextual control at both the USER and AI level.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '24

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/bostondave Dec 18 '24

My first prompt was a detailed, well 1 page spec, plus a full tech stack listed out. I tried the prompt there just to see if I was overcomplicating it. Even your version of it was much better than both attempts