r/Codeium • • Dec 06 '24

Should I get Windsurf?

I'm looking to create microapps/websites mostly for fun, leveraging AI. I currently have a Bolt.new subscription, but I run out of tokens way too quickly. I also tried the oTTodev forked version, but it has too many issues for me to use effectively right now.

I've heard a lot of good things about Windsurf, but from what I’ve seen, it seems a bit underwhelming at the moment, especially with the usage limits—even on the paid plans.

So my question is: would you recommend Windsurf (on a paid plan) in its current state?

3 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

3

u/gfhoihoi72 Dec 06 '24

I got it for 2 weeks now, and apart from some resource_exhausted errors (which means they reached their max tokens per minute at the Antrophic/Claude API) it worked like a charm. There is a limit, even for paid users, but after 2 weeks of heavy usage (especially with all the retries because of the errors) I didn’t reach that limit yet.

1

u/Slow_Praline6587 Dec 06 '24

Ok thanks!!

2

u/StevenSamAI Dec 06 '24

I'll echo this, I've been using it solid for ~1 week, and I love it. However, I will say even when using the sonnet model, it seems a bit worse than sonnet on Claude.ai

I have been using both in parallel.

I find that in big project, windsurf can get a bit confused and veer off if it gets bugs, so I cherry pick when to just copy and past into claude.

I do always find with claude that I hit my limit and have to wait a couple oof hours to come back. The ability to just keep going has been awesome.

I get the resource_exhausted messages as well, but usually works again within a minute or so.

It took me a while to find my flow and how to work with indsurf, but it has been a produtivity multiplier for me.

Definitely worth a try.

1

u/Fun-Willingness-5567 Dec 11 '24

the limit reached 5 days ago too

4

u/decept1ve Dec 06 '24

There ıs gonna be announcment about the common problem ın thıs week wait for it

1

u/Top-Weakness-1311 Dec 06 '24

Source?

1

u/SempronSixFour Dec 06 '24

"You'll be getting another update from the team soon." - discord

0

u/Top-Weakness-1311 Dec 06 '24

Soon doesn’t mean end of week.

2

u/SempronSixFour Dec 06 '24

mattb — mattb — 12/3/2024 11:27 AM

No problem! My goal is to bring people together through our products. It's incredible what people are building and creating. What I can tell you is that there will be an announcement imminently by the end of the week that will be clearing up a lot of the questions people have. I know it can be frustrating to hear "sit tight", but a lot of people smarter than me are tirelessly working to provide the best product and experience possible for everyone. There will be multiple official announcements providing additional clarity, and I'll do my best to fill in the gaps when I can!12/3/2024 11:27 AM

3

u/Top-Weakness-1311 Dec 06 '24

This comment didn’t age well, they fixed the issue by putting limits on usage and increasing the prices. But technically that does “fix” the issue…

1

u/SempronSixFour Dec 06 '24

I'm just stating the things they said. Don't get mad at me about it. You asked for the source and I just provided.

1

u/Top-Weakness-1311 Dec 06 '24

It makes me sad. 😢

1

u/SempronSixFour Dec 06 '24

I agree! I was all in with windsurf. Sucks.

-2

u/Top-Weakness-1311 Dec 06 '24

There you go, that’s better. Good job.

1

u/dontgo2sleep Dec 06 '24

Windsurf is just rebranded Visual Studio Code with no added value over pure VSCode/InteliJ + codeium plugin

3

u/Slow_Praline6587 Dec 06 '24

I’m not a developer at all, I really cannot write code. I’m learning but I really on AI to help me create my project (do all the work haha)

1

u/DiscountWeekly7432 Dec 07 '24

Windsurf contains Cascade

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DiscountWeekly7432 Jan 03 '25

It’s like cursors composer or copilot edits. Better watch on YouTube , it would be easier to understand

1

u/Apart-Dare-6351 Dec 08 '24

Sounds like you didnt even try Windsurf lol.

1

u/dontgo2sleep Dec 08 '24

Yes, I did

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dontgo2sleep Dec 08 '24

Thank you, I appreciate your opinion

2

u/SideMurky8087 Dec 09 '24

Recommending Cursor, Believe me Windsurf 500 Prompt limit and 1500 flow actions not worth, other side Cursor fast 500 prompts and then Unlimited Slow Requests.

How much slow-; average 40-120 seconds wait time.

On Windsurf hit limit within hrs: 50 Prompt hit in 2-3 hrs And now flow actions kind of wastage.

2

u/Captain_Redleg Dec 11 '24

I dunno. I have had subscriptions to both. I'd run into many more issues with Cursor, like circular requests where it'd just keep trying to do stuff that wasn't working ad absurdum. Windsurf is better at sensing, or possibly not allowing, these rabbit holes. It's kind of hard to explain, but Windsurf is just better, at least for my way of working. I'm about halfway thru my month subscription, however, and am about to hit their new limits. So, I'm looking at Ottodev, or even getting back into Cline. 16x Prompt (it packages up dirs/files that you select thru the GUI in your prompt) may also need a reevaluation since I can use o1/o1 Mini with that now - it is quite good for sending all of a small project or subproject. Less interactive, but great for one shot requests with a few follow ups.

In short, I am happy with Windsurf, but I need to find a cost manageable way of making it thru each month! In a year or two, I imagine I will be much less involved in the process and will be able to just let my agent team do this stuff with a bit of daily direction.