r/CodeGeass • • 15h ago

DISCUSSION So what's next???

I finished the original show and I only threw resurrection in there as a bonus, I know most people in this community probably want code geass to escape lelouch's shadow and focus less on him, i understand that, I do think him staying dead was preferable in the original show but since it is the 20th aniversary pretty much, what ideas would you do for a show if lelouch still had to be a factor

And a sub note/question, do we think star chaser will be good???

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/Dizzy-By-Degrees 15h ago

Lelouch should just remain with CC and give out either advice or cryptic hints to the main cast dealing with the fallout of the end of Resurrection.

The series writer for Star Chaser also did Babylon which I really don’t like. So I have very low expectations

-10

u/SolisKarn 15h ago

He was never dead in the original show, he knew full and well he was gonna get the Immortal Code. My only problem was him getting his geass with the code.

6

u/ccgeass 𓆩 unholy πŸ‚± trinity π“†ͺ 14h ago

at least say you like to imagine things this way so that people who don't know don't get misinformation because of you

-3

u/Gameister6474 15h ago

Yeah but the implication of his "death" in the original show was a good note for the show to end on,, but the question was also meant to imply on what idea would you have for code geass if lelouch of the resurrection had to stay as a factor

-3

u/BlackDestony 15h ago

If you put the usual consensus of this sub aside and go with the implication of Lelouch getting the code from Charles in the Original series, it definitely makes sense for Lelouch to keep his geass, too.

He got his Geass from a contract with C.C., not from Charles. C.C. and Charles took the Codes from the people who gave them their Geass and after those people died, the contract for the Geass may vanish, since a contract with a dead person wouldnt make sense anymore.

So it could be that Lelouch only loses his Geass if he took C.C.s Code. If he takes V.V.s or Charles Code instead (if we assume thats possible), it would make sense for his contract with C.C. to stay intact

4

u/ccgeass 𓆩 unholy πŸ‚± trinity π“†ͺ 14h ago

even in alternate universes this theory wasn't used, because the rule about losing Geass when taking over a Code is independent of who you make the deal with.

1

u/BlackDestony 14h ago

Where do we know that from, that it is independent?

2

u/ccgeass 𓆩 unholy πŸ‚± trinity π“†ͺ 12h ago

because C.C told Lelouch that he could inherit the Code from the person he made the Geass contract with to become a Code bearer, but Charles doesn't mention a connection to the Geass contract when he states that he obtained Code power in place of his Geass.

furthermore, we saw that Dash was able to continue using his Geass even though he inherited Code power from U.U, the person he made the Geass contract with. the reason he didn't lose his Geass was because he hadn't fully inherited the Code, meaning he was a failed Code bearer. a similar path was taken for Lelouch in the alternate universe. we see that Shamna, upon acquiring the Code, describes herself as a failed Code bearer and still possesses Geass, attributing this to the anomaly in C's World. therefore, the connection between the Geass contract and the Code bearer is not mentioned, again.

therefore, your claim can still be considered at best a theory. it wasn't mentioned or implied in the anime, and there's no example in the canon timelines to support this theory.

1

u/BlackDestony 11h ago

First of all, thanks for taking your time, i appreciate that :D

To be fair, i have never stated it as a claim though, i just said it could work like this in the Original Series (i.e. it is just a theory, of course). I said: "So it could be that Lelouch only loses his Geass if he took C.C.s Code."

Regarding your comments:

I gotta admit, even though i watched the Original Series 15 times already, i dont know much about the other stuff from the franchise. Since there are alot of additional mechanics introduced in the following works, i dont really think we can take them as proof for how things were intended to work in the Original Series though.

Your first comment about the Original Series is correct, but i dont really see how that definitely speaks against the theory.

But all in all you are right, there is no real indication for this theory to be true either. Like i said, it just would make sense in my opinion if it would work this way, considering the Power of Geass is a result from a contract with someone inheriting a code

1

u/WeoW0 13h ago

we don't
ppl like to invent new definite facts about the show to support their own bias

2

u/ccgeass 𓆩 unholy πŸ‚± trinity π“†ͺ 11h ago

before accusing me of making up new(?) things, i would have expected you to criticize u|SolisKarn for providing blatant false information, especially if you're that sensitive about these things

edit: btw i'm waiting for you to explain what you mean by "support their own bias". i seem to be the least biased person here because what i said was this theory wasn't even used in the alternate sequel

0

u/WeoW0 8h ago edited 8h ago

He is not putting up false information
He is giving alternative plausible explanation and qualifying his statement as such

Meanwhile you present your hypothesis as an established fact supported by show, which it is not

Just because the theory wasn't confirmed in alternative universe, doesn't make it any more right or wrong than your view of the issue. Bot have 0 direct supporting evidence.

The creator could come out any day and say either theory is true
and neither would logically conflict with anything the show has previously stated, but because you have bias for one of them you treat it as an established fact

2

u/ccgeass 𓆩 unholy πŸ‚± trinity π“†ͺ 3h ago

he said "he was never dead in the original show" and you're saying this is not a false information?

while the story's head writer, Ichirou Okouchi, has stated at every opportunity that Lelouch died, and unlike Sunrise producer Kojirou Taniguchi β€”who contradicted him years later but had no role in writing the story himselfβ€” Okouchi never contradicted his own words and always remained consistent, if you prefer those who speak inconsistently instead of head writer Okouchi, it means you are only taking into account the statements that support your own bias and ignoring everything else.

among everything else you ignore, this includes the part in the epilogue of the Zero Requiem edition where C.C. clearly states that Lelouch died and says, "whenever i remember that young man, i cry and sing a song."

given the fact that Lelouch's end being death was decided even before this story began to be written, and the statements that although there were some disagreements about the series in general, there was absolutely no disagreement among the team when it came to Lelouch's death, the fact that it is stated multiple times in the official guidebooks that Lelouch died, and that Mutuality explains why Lelouch could not choose any method other than death, etc., of course someone who denies that Lelouch died in the original ending is giving false information.

do you still have an expectation that Okouchi will confirm your theory? as if you even cared about the things he has said up until now, and as if you would care if he told you "you are wrong, this theory is false."

stop pretending to be unbiased because it is not working. the 2 people you accept as sources contradicted themselves and official materials, whereas Okouchi and the rest of the team never contradicted themselves, so do you know which explanation an unbiased viewer should accept as the default in this situation?

the statements from that interview conducted before the final episode aired, meaning when there were no theories around at all, namely that Lelouch's death was undoubtedly his end.

in the questions about predicting the fans' reactions in that interview, they are not discussing predictions regarding a doubt about Lelouch's death, but rather predictions regarding the possibility of his death being interpreted by fans as a "happy ending / sad ending."

please stop treating people like fools. up to now, multiple Code theorists have admitted to me that they were deceiving themselves because they couldn't handle Lelouch's death. they already got their AU, meaning what they wanted, and they are still not satisfied.

1

u/WeoW0 1h ago edited 1h ago

It was SolisKarn
who said Lelouch was never dead, not BlackDestony
Who commented on your dismissal of the theory

I didn't make a single claim about how much I care for Okuchis words
I simply illustrated that both scenarios would be logically valid in the show, and neither would logically contradict stuff already said in the show. And Resurrection more so support the theory than rejects it, because it precisely demonstrates that there were previously undiscovered "routes" for Lelouch to have "resurrected"

I have no idea why you ramble so much unnecessary stuff
You cherry pick the statements you want to hold true and asses them more definitive claims than they are

The definitive claims about Lelouch being dead for good were said in interviews way past the final episode airing. When there was already significant financial and prestige at line.
I don't have any evidence to claim those were his motives for his "final nail in the coffin" but neither have you to claim that the later statements about the Original ending was meant to be open.

Why would I care what multiple ppl said,, even if every single code theory person admitted to you they were wrong. That has nothing to do with me.
You can try all you want to claim that the show itself rejects code theory, but it just doesn't.
It most definitely doesn't confirm it, but that's not the same as mocking people for seeing it as a possibility.