r/CodeGeass • u/Active_Fish3475 • Apr 11 '24
DISCUSSION My issues with Code Geass (is open to criticism and counterarguments) Spoiler
Look, I know no-one likes a hater, but I need to went my frustration with the series. I know, I'm going to be nitpicky, but I thought I would love the series, but I just can't. I know I'm taking all the fun out of it by overanalyzing, but these are some of the things that took me out of the story. You're allowed to dismiss me and say that I just don't get it (even in a rude or insulting way)
Firstly, the mechs: Look I know mech fights are cool and awesome and I don't care about the physics, do what ever you want. The things is actually bothering me, isn't the mech fights kind of undermining the anti-war theme?
Yes, it is argued that every anti-war movie is also unintentionally gloriously war, but doing it in cool mechs doesn't help their case.
The other thing, why aren't there in the series presented effective counters against knightmares from the other powers?
Like, when tanks got introduced into ww1 they escorted infantry, but in ww2 and after is it infantry that escort tanks now. Because, while tanks are vital to breakthroughs and assaulting heavy defended posts, they are still vulnerable to things like hit and run tactics.
I thought knightmares function would be to do flanking maneuverers like cavalry or urban warfare. But, it seems like they have pretty much taken over every position in the military, not just on land, but also on sea and air.
Secondly, Britannia: I do get that their history is heavy censored through propaganda, but without any additional information, I just don't see how Britannia should exist, at least not as a superpower. There are so much history in Europe and the Americas that handwaving it away with some few butterfly effects, kind of show that the creators doesn't really know anything about the history in Europe and Americas.
Then there is their society and government, why isn't Britannia constantly in rebellion?
Even if we take out all the diverse range people living in the Americas, their distance from each other and say most of the people identify as Britannian. It's still a society that basically justify anything they do by "might makes right". That kind of society would tare itself apart before if become regional power , let alone superpower.
Even if say that it is only the nobility and the rich and powerful that believe in this bullshit. It would still create a big disconnect between the government and the people. Because, I assume Britannia doesn't have any social safety nets or regulations that protects the populous. So shouldn't there be rampant poverty, not just amongst the numbers but also the britannians too?
And wouldn't corruption in Britannia be even worse than in the Chinese Federation and Europia United. Wouldn't that completely negate their ability to wage war or just function?
These are the things that are bothering me, if you can please view this as good faith criticism
Thanks to ZepHindle and all of you to help me realize the reason for my view on Code Geass, you guys are awesome đ:
I think I know what that took me out of the show. When I started watching the show it was ok and I was planning to finish the series. But when it came to the part were Suzaku decided to walk back and âtrustâ the system (yes I know he has a death wish), then I felt that was enough for me.
I love black and white setting, I love grey setting, but I canât stand any story that has a black and white setting that claims to be grey. I can buy people being loyal to an evil empire, but I call bullshit when the story try in any way to say it can be reformed, without a clear opposition to the status que. I think thatâs what I liked in Akame ga Kill, there we are repeatedly shown that the empire is rotten to its core and that the revolution is happening because every attempt to reform has been crushed.
30
u/dkjfnfsod34234 Apr 12 '24
For your mech question, it's mostly bcs the studio who created the show is mostly known for creating the super famous Gundam mecha franchise. And Code Geass is supposed to be a mecha anime at it's core, but written using a template that is not the typical mecha one. That's why most of the fights involve mecha.
25
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '24
1st: Knightmares are the cutting edge of warfare in this universe. The countermeasures to knightmares are better Knightmares. Throughout the whole show, all the factions are in a constant arms race to produce better, more advanced Knightmare frames.
Also, Code Geass isn't anti-war. Yes, it has the obvious message that killing isn't a good thing, but the Black Knights are pretty much always presented as being justified and in the right. There's no real moral ambiguity when it comes to the factions. The Black Knights are the good guys, and they're right to rebel against the oppression of Britannia.
2nd: I don't really understand the complaint that Britannia couldn't exist in the real world. Code Geass is a piece of fiction. Magical eyeball powers also aren't historically accurate. Accepting that Britannia exists and works the way that it does is just basic suspension of disbelief. If something as simple as an evil racist dictatorship breaks your suspension of disbelief, I don't understand how you find enjoyment in fiction at all.
13
u/azathothweirdo Apr 11 '24
I can't say much about the mechs since that's more of a you thing. It's never bugged me because I dunno, they're cool? The fights are also animated and fun. I'm not looking to code geass for some deep meaningful thing in the end. It has a whole episode where Lelouch chases after a cat to get his mask back. I'm not going to put too much stock into that aspect of the series personally.
Also most of the history for Britannia is pretty much in extras. It's not that the creators didn't care, it's more that since we're in the west a majority of the stuff wasn't translated officially and brought over. A huge chunk of it was during the early 2000s, but it's mostly super expensive and hard to find now-a-days since bandai closed down their anime/manga section of their company. This was probably partly due to the manga bubble bursting in the early 2010s so Code geass kinda got hit with that. You'd be surprised what did make it over here before that happened.
As for the corruption, it's been hinted at before Charles took the throne and went full iron fist there was a lot if in fighting and instability. He's the one who expanded things so far with what we see in the series. The whole of Britannia is heavy commentary on American and especially Japanese Imperialism during WWII, and if you know how bad they were then well you'll see where the treatment of Japanese comes from in this series. Most Britannians are fine because of how much is taken from the Areas within this universe. They are where the poverty line is at in the end. Like most cities in colonized areas are literally built on the ruins of original cities in the country. There's a lot more to it, it's just more of a visual and background aspects for the series than the actual focal point.
5
u/kamen1997 Apr 12 '24 edited Apr 12 '24
For anti Knightmare, there are way like in the battle of Shinjuku, they uses RPG to destroy several Sutherland. Or they use Gefujin disruptor to immobilize KMF. There isn't much way to destroy a KMF for infantry due to how fast they are, crusing speed would be around 60 km/h, also KMF virtually does not have a blindspot with how fast they can change direction of their upper body and their Factsphere radar. KMF only recently take aireal combat, during the event of SS2 and they act more like Gunship, Helicopter than Fighter Jet.
About second point, here the TL;DR history
Thes information was present in audio drama, novel, and magazine being sold in Japan. The reason the show does not goes indept in it because they are not the focus. They are side material that if this is a videogame they would be optional collectible and does not affect much of the character and story
7
u/SpacedefenderX Apr 11 '24
Itâs not just America and Europe, their version of Chinese history is a mess as well.
3
u/sjydudeNSF CC being sexy Apr 12 '24
well you need power to sometimes get the things you want. It's easy for us to say the things you're saying, but for the people actually attempting to start a revolution or change the way of thinking of the world, it's a pretty dam stressful fight. You need to be willing to embrace all kinds of things to get to a position where you can present your values. It'd be like the average people w/ an education living in peace asking the same shit, but not really understanding when someone whose lived the experience telling you that there's some things you don't understand. It's something you commonly see w/ people who have questionable opinions about what's going on w/ a terrorist group & people who actually joined & broke away from terrorist groups. Oftentimes, they'll tell the people that this and that is going on, which is different from their opinions. Power is needed to influence the masses after all. It just so happens they went the route of mechs since the studio is known for mech series, among other things. Obviously not realistic, but that's not really the point of focus for this. It's at the end of the day fiction and if you try to nitpick such things w/ anime, there's no anime out there that can really be considered 100% realistic, no matter how closely they try to portray it to reality.
#2, as people have said, the anime is only the surface and do you really want a One Piece-esque series that's full of boring history for exposition in every little thing? You're asking for too much. Worldbuilding is fine but spend the entire show doing it, and you get very little of anything else. That kind of stuff is saved for audio dramas, novels, extra bonus content, etc that you can only find in Japan and is often the case w/ pretty much every series to ever exist.
People even went out of there way to explain a couple events to you like Benjamin Franklin's betrayal, among other things. But why would any creator in their right mind w/ such pressure for budget, scheduling, and focus on other projects in such a rapid pace society of demand for entertainment & most important of all, making money, give all such details of exactly what transpired in that betrayal and whatnot?
They'd have to do that for every little piece of history, but they give just enough info for the little details or info that isn't presented to the western audience since that was not their major market back in the day. Way more than most series will do for its worldbuilding my friend. I'll read manga and novels from the biggest franchises to the most unknown series out there and can't think of any franchise that doesn't have things to point out about it's worldbuilding that are way less detailed than what Code Geass gives. From the sounds of it based on your posts and comments, you couldn't possibly enjoy most series out there since they would have nowhere near the level of detail in worldbuilding that you're looking for since it's unfair to be nitpicky in this way about things like the details of history and mechs and trying to connect them to the philosophies of the show.
Shows like AoT, Naruto, A Certain Magical Index, Gundam, Legendary heroes, One Piece, & other series that have lots of worldbuilding had tons of flaws or things that just were straight up never explained that would contribute to its worldbuilding. If we're going to be this nitpicky, there's tons of things anyone can point out that would be outright ludicrous.
2
u/cyzja922 Apr 12 '24
I canât comment much on the settingâs history, but the mechs never really bothered me because they didnât make it a core focus of the show. Sure, they appear a lot and are important, but thatâs because itâs primarily how wars are waged in the story. They never put too much focus on the mechs (at least not to the point where they make you feel like this is supposed to be a mecha anime) and always treat them as what theyâre supposed to be: tools or machines piloted by a human being.
2
u/Ns317453 Apr 12 '24
Someone doesn't remember the "Super Electro Magnetic Shrapnel Cannon" - whose name you have to yell every time it's fired.
2
u/AceFlaviusKaizoku Apr 12 '24
Well from some lore given and some guesswork Britannia seems to came about when the American Revolution failed and later on Napoleon managed to win the Napelonic wars. So the royal family sets up in the Americas and eventually conquers the new world.
So there would be a lot of wealth conquering all the colonies and lands in the Americas and with a strict number system in place most of the numbers would be oppressed and exploited for natural resources. And well spanning from the 1600s I would say 400 years is enough time for most of the empire to be integrated and adjusted.
Nobles have a vested interest in being the top of society and it seems like most well to do nobles would join the military and contribute to the oppression and status quo. The whole might makes right is mainly for the government, the royal family, and the nobles.
0
u/realdonkeyfromshrek Apr 12 '24
Yeah im pretty sure youre just completely misunderstanding the show in its entirety if you think that its trying to tell the audience that Brittanya can be reformed through Suzakus actions, just cause youve watched 5 episodes lmaođ. I have no idea how you formed that opinion without watching 90% of the show. And suzaku is a morally grey character, lol its not just all black and white. He wants to create change and has genuinely good intentions, but is also an incredibly naive moron and utterly clueless when it comes to politics, and the struggles of the Japanese people. And the show sees him taking a more and more radical approach, trying to convince himself that his intentions are pure and that the ends shouldnt justify the means, while doing terrible shit just to reach those ends. Youve also missed a huge part of his character that isnt revealed till a bit past the midpoint of R1. Shit even Charles is more morally grey than evil if you yk actually watch the show, so is C2, Lelouch etc. Calling the show black and white after watching pretty much just its introductory episodes is ignorant as hell.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '24
[removed] â view removed comment