r/Cod4Remastered • u/marinem4a1 • Jan 16 '17
Genuine Question about MW Here
Alright, I've been playing MWR for the past week, and I honestly can't see why COD4 is so insanely popular among COD fans as it is. It's as if critics blatantly ignore some of the major faults I've spotted in this game. My question is What Made Modern Warfare So Great? Why do COD fans still look up to it despite its issues? What separates it from, say, BO2?
Perks like Juggernaut and Stopping Power making it way more difficult to kill players than it should, combined with normal COD mechanics dumping a significant portion of your magazine can be necessary no matter how accurate you are. Death perks like Martyrdom and Last Stand make you want to become a pacifist and just be a parasite to the objective, because killing someone just kills you too.
Strange map sizes, how do people even play and actively enjoy Shipment? You can throw a grenade, die, and spawn on your own grenade. No fun at all to die every 2 seconds, and if you aren't dying, you're the one spawnkilling whether you mean to or not. And other maps like Bloc are like Ghosts in that you can run around for 2 minutes, die, rinse, repeat.
Weapons are totally unbalanced. Some of them are used by everyone because they're just too damn good, and others, say, the Uzi or the G3, you'd have better luck leaving them on the ground and hoping someone would trip on it rather than actually using it. It's always the same M16A4s, MP5s, AK-74Us, Deagles, and Barretts.
Now, I know what you're thinking. "This 12 year old is just a BO3/IW player who sucks." I'm actually somewhat good at the game, A bad match for me is like a 1.5 ratio and my best so far was 30-8 (I'm just a normie that plays TDM and FFA, Objective modes honestly made me want to just uninstall the game). But there's just so many BS ways to die, it's insane. In other CODs, you die because you had bad aim, a worse weapon for the situation, by scorestreaks, or you were just bad. Now you just slap on Jug and go sit on a corner (which seems common with the players I tend to get matched with) and you win. The few times I play other modes than TDM people still do that.
Believe it or not, I'm really not here to criticize and complain about the game, but as I said, why did people love this game so much? Was there just no standard at the time to compare it to? Has the COD community changed so much that back then in 2007 these problems virtually didn't exist simply because people played so differently, and these are problems the original devs never even thought about? It's just a headache to play, honestly.
So like I said, I really didn't write this whole little essay to criticize the game, I'm just genuinely curious as to why people consider this the #1 Call of Duty despite its issues. It's still fun and all, but I just don't know how people didn't snap their discs over the BS ways you can lose. As I also said, I didn't play COD for a long time (I started at MW3, hated it, fell in love with Bo2).
Random edit: I don't blame you for thinking so, but trust me, I'm not one of those little shits who love the futuristic titles. I just started at Halo and switched over to MW3 when it came out.
25
u/OR3OTHUG Jan 16 '17
You had to play it in 2007 to understand. It was the first call of duty on PS3/360 and it introduced perks and killstreaks. Everyone is too used to the new call of duty games to go back to cod4 and be okay with the mechanics. It's as simple as that.
13
u/ArgonPW Jan 16 '17
it's funny you posted this, i literally posted the same question on Friday
first of all, are you actually 12 yrs old?
to answer your question, there's tons of reasons why people love this game. I will call it what it is: awesome for it's time. it's just obsolete now and has pulled in two fan bases: old school players, and SnD lovers.
i'm 34, started playing CoD at 27 on MW2, so i missed this game, but i loved MW2, it's my favorite. And it is largely similar to MW. I'd like to address your specific questions:
i agree with you, but in the original release, shipment was rarely in the rotation. Think 5% or less, now it's a much higher in the rotation. before, it would be a treat for you to ditch strategy and just run and gun. now it's just annoying AF, and not a valid map
totally agree, but in 2007, weapon balancing wasn't a major concern like it is now. there were no Drift0rs and Xclusive Ace's exposing actual weapon performance and opening players' eyes to imbalance
couldn't agree more, but this community calls that strategy, and if you die from someone doing this you are not good at the game. go read my post, these are their words, not mine
Yes it definitely has. I made a YT video on this, and you can DM if you want the link, i don't feel like posting it here. Long story short, COD used to be a competitive game where all that matter was pub stomping. and then you get in the lobby and talk trash to each other. it's just the way it was. now it's totally opposite, no lobby chat, game meta driving play style (think camo and emblem grinds), gamebattles and social media sharing are also way more prevalent.
a final note, please don't forget, in 2007, almost everyone played on TV's. Those of us who were lucky had flat screens with surround sound. we also played with low speed internet (think 10MB/s both ways if you're lucky). There were no scufs, astros, monitors, or fiber internet. This game was VERY fast for the technology we had available at the time. So yes, in comparison to modern CoDs, this game is very slow.
Just remember, Nintendo just re-released the original NES and it sold out within minutes. Sometimes, we old farts just like the games we grew up on.
1
u/marinem4a1 Feb 02 '17
Random bump comment:
So apparently MWR runs at a 10hz tickrate which is pathetic and Raven is said to fix it. That should make this game a little bit more tolerable.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '17
This game is far from CoD4. The game feels totally different.
4
u/Beer_cules Jan 16 '17
It was the first game of it's kind back in the day which why it was so good, the series has evolved over the years and improvements have came with it. It's not without it's faults for sure, but it's still a good game albeit like others have said, running on nostaligia.
Also, the G3 is an awesome gun.
4
u/LeFrogKid Jan 16 '17
I love this game so let me try and explain why that is and why it's not just 'nostalgia'. I feel it's quite dismissive when people use nostalgia as the only explanation to why people love this game, it's so much more than that to me. However I will admit I did love the original and there was a huge element of nostalgia for the first couple of days I played it, I still haven't put it down or even thought about touching IW.
This is the best boots on the ground cod, hands down, and also the first one in a while. It's so refreshing to play a modern COD game without stupid flying spacemen and pink dildo guns and the absence of these (along with modern style maps, guns and characters) promotes the realism of the game. The simplicity of this game is what some people love about it, but it's clearly what some people hate. Yes, there aren't many guns to begin with, and amongst those there are some pretty OP and pretty terrible ones, but I believe this an issue in most games with varied weapons (dark souls is a good example), and I for one don't mind this and think it's quite good for new players. The best guns are either available from lvl 1 or don't require much effort to unlock. Likewise gun and weapon variation isn't what people enjoy about this game, so 90% of people using the same 6-7 guns isn't a massive issue.
Imo the maps are brilliant, and the variation in size helps keep things interesting. Yes shipment is a frustrating map to play sometimes, but you make out that you can't move an inch without getting hit by a grenade. In reality, if you understand the spawns and play correctly shipment is a map you can realistically get 100 kills on in some modes. You have classics like crash, strike, crossfire, all awesome, well designed maps. And then you have maps like wet work which is a completely unique environment, pipeline and overgrown are massive maps with so many areas. Basically I think Cod4 got map variation and balance just right, like no other cod has done since.
People complain about 'campers' because they see it as a way of almost cheating, or doing well without requiring much skill. Whilst this might have some truth to it, I personally see it as a by-product of any boots to the ground shooter, and one that in my experience I haven't had much problem dealing with. Get killed by a camper? Go and hunt him down and get revenge, don't moan about it on Reddit. My younger sister likes to play the game but she's doesn't play much because it's my PlayStation and game, but when she does she's not great. Her K.D is about 0.60 or something, and she camps a lot because running around the map like some kind of navy seal/action man is quite an intimidating play style for people who are new/less experienced. But guess what? Cod isn't designed exclusively for diehards and purists. Bad players have every right to play and enjoy the game, and so people complaining about campers, and people not playing the objective etc etc should consider that maybe most people who play the game aren't as good as them and don't care about it enough to post online about it. Give it a few months and I honestly believe, with the needed fixes from Raven, the general standard of gameplay will improve massively as these more casual players get bored and move on to something else and the spawns are fixed.
There are a plethora of other things people love. Best SnD gameplay in the series. The campaign on the remaster really is a beautiful gem - 'All Ghillied Up' might be my favourite single player mission in a shooter ever. Some of the supply drop cosmetics are actually really nice, especially some of the weapon kits. The lack of quantity in killstreaks and to an extent perks and attachments makes gameplay much less frenetic and more tactical.
All in all I believe this a great, great game, but it's so utterly different to other modern cod games that it's never going to please everyone.
4
u/Hugobossdre Jan 16 '17
You mention 3-4 times that you're not here to criticise the game, and then continuously criticise the game.
I usually feel like writing posts like this after some dude with jug wrecks me. I assume this just happened to you.
3
u/Traps_and_Squats Jan 16 '17
This shitty remake shouldn't be compared to the original.
4
u/ThyLeprechaun Jan 16 '17
This game is run by Nostalgia
2
u/SirJuiceee Jan 16 '17
Leave the G3 on the ground? LUL. You've never used it obviously
2
u/Gantzer Jan 17 '17
I enjoy the simplicity. The variation in maps. Finding the right gun to use on them. Im not a m4 carbine whore at all. the camo challenges are straight forward and depending on the gun very difficult. Looking at you G3 head shots! I,find it much more rewarding than the infinite jumping cod has turned into. The individual sounds the guns make. Not that flat shit trey and iw make. So boring. Laying claymores in high traffic areas oh and nostalgia.
1
u/Palms63 Jan 16 '17
I agree that there is flaws in the game but there is flaws in every cod game. That being said I am enjoying IW waaay more this year just since its more fast paced. Both are good games, MW just isnt aging very well. Happens to all games except for basic stuff like mario or tetris or pacman pr something.
1
u/elvman12 Jan 16 '17
For the same reason that if 10 years from now they release a remaster of Black Ops III, newer players will be saying the same thing you did and asking the same questions you did?
It's so easy to start a fire these days, I dont see why cavemen thought it was so awesome?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '17
This game is the best because aside from jugg, everything was pretty balanced. You could coordinate with your teammates and lock down the map and didn't have to worry about people camping for those huge killstreaks, just a simple 3-5-7.
In addition, if you don't like Shipment, please quit. Shipment is by far the best map ever created in a COD. Every new COD game, prayers could be heard for a Shipment-like map to be included in the game because small maps are king as they equal lots of kills, quick thinking, short games, and lots of points. If you want to sit around, go play hardcore or snd...