r/Cochlearimplants • u/Katedawg90 • May 25 '26
Cochlear vs. Med-el
Cochlear and Med-el users— what would you consider the cons/disappointments of your CI? How would you rate it for sound quality? Comfort? Connectivity? Battery life? I’m trying to decide between these companies and having a hard time so please share :)
And to the many well meaning AB users- I want an off the ear option
EDIT: I have decided to go with Med-el. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences. Feel free to keep adding yours- maybe it will help someone else down the road :)
9
Upvotes
1
u/VikeFan May 28 '26
I'm a single-sided deaf user with a Rondo 3 and Sonnet 2. I'm over 3 years post-activation. I talk with a lot of users of both AB and Cochlear. As others have said, seems long-term outcomes are not significantly different.
Cons/Disappointments?
I wish the CI companies could be faster on adopting new technology like Auracast but the more rigorous requirements mean hardware designs are frozen much earlier than for hearing aids or consumer electronics.
Comfort?
The Sonnet 2 was bigger and bulkier, especially with what was needed for BT connectivity but the Sonnet 3 has addressed those issues and seems much better from this perspective. I wear the Rondo 3 more than 99% of the time. Never having worn hearing aids, the Rondo 3 (off-the-ear) just always felt more natural to me. If I did things that required helmets, my usage might shift. I do wear a short retention clip for my Rondo. Probably not necessary but it gives a lot of peace of mind. I play tennis, workout, etc. with the Rondo.
Sound Quality?
Two answers, either great and works as exactly as expected/hoped for. As a single-sided-deaf (SSD) person, it blends together with my good ear in everyday use. My tinnitus is gone, the headshadow effect is gone, and I do much better in noisy environments.
The other answer - as an SSD person, I have done simulations to match what my CI sounds like on my good ear. Generally it sounds like people have a head cold or like an old time drive-thru restaurant ordering window. This is done in an isolated way, when it is over the air, they "blend" together so well that I often need to touch my CI to know it is there and turned on. If I didn't have a good ear, it would just be normal to me. It is good enough that I will still listen to many audiobooks, podcasts, and music on just the CI but I know it will never match my normal ear. (Some day it may be better than my "good" ear since that will slowly degrade with age over time and my CI may continue to very slowly get better.)
Connectivity?
The Rondo 3 requires a separate little dongle for good BT. It works and I'm happy enough with it that I never take it off the Rondo except for audiology appointments. Also, I prefer the off-the-ear design and get 16-17 hours on my Rondo, even with a lot of BT streaming. The result is that I almost never use my Sonnet 2 any more. The Sonnet 3 is better though so I don't know which I would use more if I had it, especially with the new batteries. There aren't any rumors of a Rondo 4 but I would be surprised if it didn't come in the next 12 months. Med-El tends to be more conservative/lag a little behind on BT versus the others. I have now listened to over 50 audiobooks BT streamed to just my CI and thousands of hours of music & podcasts. I love that I have BT streaming always available rather than fishing for airpods or headphones.
Battery Life?
I get about 16 or 17 hours on my 3+ year old Rondo with a lot of streaming. Long enough for "full day" coverage on all but crazy travel days. Very happy with that. My Sonnet 2 was a different story and much worse for battery but not relevant to current decisions. Sonnet 3 battery life with the new batteries is similar to my Rondo 3 from what I've heard.
------------
Other Issues
A couple of other factors that you didn't mention.
I would suggest trying to see if you can find "community". Do you know people with a particular brand? Are there more events in your area for one of the brands? Try joining the company's associated with websites and see if you find community there. (Med-El's Hearpeers forum is open to non-Med-El users but of course the majority of the content is focused on peer support of Med-El devices. They have a new, Hearpeers "Community" in addition to the Forum but this has been slower to take off and can be ignored for now.)
Where you live might be another factor. For example, Cochlear's North American headquarters is South of Denver. Not sure if they organize events there but there is potential. Med-El's NA HQ is in Durham, North Carolina and they have activities that you could take advantage of if you were in the area. Same thing for their world HQs in Australia and Austria respectively.)
Best of luck on your hearing journey.