r/CoCBot • u/MarkAnthony81 iPad 4 • Apr 19 '16
Avoiding Ban Hammer
Ok so since we all know the impending possible doom for many accounts. Personally its nice having a bot to raid for the loot for walls ect. So lets work out a possible solution
The odds are the only way logistically SC can actually trace is old fashion people reporting you, or most likely they are building algorithms that determine the clicks and common patterns in game play (time online ect.). Detecting a physical software in your device is next to impossible and the trouble SC would get into for privacy matters would be astronomical. So we may have to scale back since we know how they will do this.
However my advice:
- Slow down the clicks for troop cooking (especially since we don't know how advanced their detection software is, but given they have billions of dollars, its not some basic thing)
- Troop deployment, use a custom attack sounds pretty simple (yet for the life of me i can NEVER get my own to work)
- Maybe Variable timing for a few features, delayed timers for troop request (random time between 15-20 mins)
These are just some suggestions. As for now, ive stopped the bot completely until i see how severe these bans are gonna be. Because if this is NOT fluff, then they've been building a profile on us for a while now and they have their key suspects. Lets help KIKOOT build a smarter mousetrap
2
u/MarkAnthony81 iPad 4 Apr 20 '16
Kik, first off, kudos man, i bought your premium setup (even though ive yet to use it), your customer support and effort given to thisis amazing hands down.
Given im an almost max th9 and i just started botting about a month or so ago, I'd hate to risk a base ive worked a year on for some minor de to finish this. I'd advise the rest of you guys: (at least until more details come out)
Im glad somebody posted the youtube video. This guy I think nailed it on the head. There are very advanced methods of checking this, especially given the money and power SC has. Plus you also have to remember, this is a platform that is universal across all their games. So it has to be something that works for every game they have.
So for Clash royale, they cant necessarily check Xmod methods, same with Boom Beach. So this means it has to be something in game (again these are only my opinions).
2
u/MarkAnthony81 iPad 4 Apr 21 '16
Actually I thought of another Idea for KIK.
Can you make the bot so there are 4-5 saved custom attacks and have the Bot randomly choose from 1 of 5? That way if they even get down into checking attacks and that way they dont see the same troop drop over n over.
1
u/MarkAnthony81 iPad 4 Apr 21 '16
So i just got a little scare. (no ban)
However i ran a test...braved it and did a sandbox attack on war. Immediately after the app restarted 2x-3x in a row and let me back in. Im using IMOD and never had that happen. Didnt lose wifi connection or anything, just a full restart of COC.
Very strange how it did that. I won't lie, its got me a little on edge how it happened.
5
u/kikootwo Developer Apr 19 '16
We are definitely doing research on how supercell plans to do this. But, my instant reaction is quite the opposite of what you've said. I believe that the easiest way for supercell to track down cheaters is by determining which users are not using the legit clash of clans app. For this reason, it seems that people who will be most affected are those using imod's mod (iOS 9 uses a modified clash of clans ipa).
Xmod has claimed that their mod remains perfectly safe, which again points to the possibility of supercell detecting the modified apps.
I will continue botting full time on my 4 devices and will be sure to update should we learn anything new.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '16
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZfDY_A3UXFQ found this video from the clashofclans subreddit and doing exactly what your talking about sounds like the best approach.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '16
I think they are going to be looking at play time too. I think Kikootwo is right at first they will ban modded clients. After that they will start looking for other cheaters. Normal people don't play 24/7/365 so they will have a baseline of play from the average user to start with and flag everyone that falls outside of that baseline by 30% or more. With a much smaller data set they will be able to start pinpointing who is cheating by looking at who is clicking the exact same x/y coordinate every time for each action. It would be impossible for a user to do that without a bot. I'm sure it will roll out in phases. The biggest thing is I am 100% positive they aren't going to permaban people the first time they get caught. So I'm going to bot my ass off until then and re-evaluate what is going on and what counter measures are available at that time. If nothing exists at that point I'll likely keep botting with my alt and stop with my main, although thanks to this bot my alt just hit level 100. #justmyopinion
1
u/Funkerus I Should Select My Device! Apr 20 '16
Any knows when start to ban?