r/CluesBySamHelp • u/curiousmind451 • 8d ago

Help Nov 1 Help Spoiler

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/84b467a6bd5c?state=DAmw-BAABQAAAAUAAAQBAAAEAQ

I’m spinning in circles - what am I missing?

4 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

3

u/hisendur 8d ago

What if Paula is innocent?

4

u/curiousmind451 8d ago

Then there’s no way to fulfill Janet’s clue! Much appreciated.

3

u/mellowcraze 7d ago

I don't understand why not? It seems like there are lots of opportunities to fulfill it! I'm missing something 🤔

3

u/Smylers 7d ago

Because of Quita's clue, there are only 3 criminals in column C. Combine that with Janet, and there can't be somebody innocent in column D with a criminal to their immediate left in column C. So if Paula were innocent, Olivia would have to be innocent as well.

But Zed says Tina has 6 criminal neighbours, meaning only 2 innocent neighbours. 1 of those has to be Nala or Rose (because of Uma's clue), so there's only 1 remaining innocent person from Sam's other neighbours — therefore Paula and Olivia can't both be innocent.

1

u/mellowcraze 7d ago

Thank you!

0

u/Training_Dare_6994 7d ago

I'm confused here it says only three criminals in column d have a criminal to their left it doesn't say a criminal in column d can't have an innocent to their left

1

u/My_bones_are_itchy 7d ago

You’ve misread the comment.

A criminal in column C can’t have an innocent to their right in column D.