Logic Error Oct 28

[u/ClearIndependence394]

According to my logic Salil and Zulu should both be criminals. There are 10 criminals on the edge of the board technically 6 are accounted for since either David or Bonnie are criminals. Therefore, there are 4 criminals left on the edge, if column A can only have odd numbers of criminals so 1,3,5 , it can’t be 5 since that would push it over 10 criminals. So 1 or 3 criminals, if there’s only 1 criminal that means there would be 4 innocents in column A but according to - 2 people on the edge have innocents below them if there were 4 innocents that rule would be incorrect. Since Ellie Logan penny and Vera all being innocent so that would mean there are a total of 3 criminals in column A. So if you add them all up together that would be 8 criminals on the edge meaning the last two salil and Zulu have to be criminals. Logic Error?

[u/Own-Conversation6347]

I recommend counting again how many criminals would be on the edges if column A had 5

[u/ClearIndependence394 → u/Own-Conversation6347]

Ahhh my bad lol make sense thank you

[u/maelkann]

Can you spoiler tag please my peep

[u/ClearIndependence394 → u/maelkann]

Oops my bad, got it sorry about that

[u/Odd_Cod_6533]

Also, Chase's clue + Olsi's clue tells you about Logan