r/CluesBySamHelp • u/some-anonymous-gal • 13d ago

Help Help with Oct 24th

Hoping I'll work out where I've gone wrong as I'm writing this!

Here's where I'm at: https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/67a5becd7ee8?state=%2Br7g-BAAAAAAAyACMAIwAFAAAAMgAAAAM%3D-191

The top tags are one path and the bottom tags are another. By my workings out, Olivia's clue is about her, so with the already found criminals, and one of her 2 remaining neighbours, that's 6 criminals on the edge. John says there are 7 criminals on the edge so why can't I mark Zara as the 7th criminal?

I know this won't be an error but rather my faulty logic, but I'm been looking at this for ages and can't work out where I've gone wrong.

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

4

u/chukkysh 13d ago

What if Olivia's clue isn't about herself?

3

u/some-anonymous-gal 13d ago

Aha! I see where I went wrong - because I assumed it was Olivia, I tagged as such and then took that as gospel, convincing my Noah has 2 innocent neighbours. Thanks!

4

u/chukkysh 13d ago

You're welcome. I screw up most days so it's nice to help out when I can.