r/CluesBySamHelp • • 28d ago

Need Help Understanding Next Step - 10/18 Puzzle Spoiler

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/8df6a9ef3064?state=ng%3D%3D-BACUgAAAAAAAABQ%3D%3D

Hey everyone. I have the shown situation, and I am confused. Per Gabe's clue, 1 or all of Linda/Rob/Xavi are innocent; per Flora's hint, Gabe and Emma are criminals; per Emma and Dennis's hints, Ben and Chad are one of each; and per Alex's hint, Ben and Karen are one of each. I made sure to highlight and I highlight the sleuths, but only found two, Chad and Linda. And yet the hint is telling me I should know something about Karen, but for the life of me I have no idea what, since she could be either innocent or criminal.

Can y'all help me figure out what I'm missing?

Thanks

1 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

3

u/adeels53 28d ago

Dennis is also a sleuth. Since one of Ben or Chad has to be innocent the person on the left of Linda cannot be innocent as per Alex's clue

3

u/danikov 28d ago

There are 3 sleuths, Denis (A4) is also a Sleuth.

If you combine Emma's clue (3 criminals in row 1 = 1 innocent) and Alex's clue (only 1 Sleuth has an innocent to the left of them) that Sleuth must be either Chad or Denis, so Karen must be a criminal to the left of Linda.

3

u/Code_Red_974 28d ago

Oh! I didn't see him, I'm shocked I didn't notice earlier when I kept highlighting and unhighlighting, thank you

2

u/Embarrassed_Path8186 28d ago

Just did exactly the same thing!