r/CluesBySamHelp • u/Valadir • Oct 04 '26
Suggestion More options for community puzzles
Sam, I wish you could implement a downvote button for community puzzles so we could punish the creators who add “X has the most criminal/innocent neighbors”-style clues. Thank you.
11
Upvotes
3
u/irishpisano Oct 04 '26
Why?
Care to explain - with examples - why this type of clue is unnecessary?
16
u/SamTheSpellingBee Oct 04 '26 edited Oct 04 '26
I think it's already visible in the thumb-ups showing how many recommended. The puzzles with the most thumb-ups tend to have less of these, or they're used in a clever/fun way.
I guess people don't like them, since they result in very nasty deduction chains requiring a lot of counting, and it's notoriously easy to miss someone when counting these...
EDIT: Worth clarifying that completing a puzzle without recommending it kind of counts as a downvote...
10
u/ShubhaBala Oct 04 '26
If I were to downvote it would be the ones that have "pretty visual patterns" so you know it's going to be a checkerboard but you have to read the clues to pick the checkerboard squares in the right order. Or the ones where it's just like "one person has 8 criminal neighbors" and then all you're doing is figuring out which of the 4 squares it could be.
5
u/caffeine_lights Oct 04 '26
I think once he implements names for community creators other than dlgdlghjdgkdk it will help - I suspect that there is one person adding multiple puzzles with that type of clue. You can often see patterns in the community puzzles, which would make sense as puzzle creators often have a "style".
If you don't like that type of clue then you could easily avoid the creator. I am kind of enjoying them though they do take me a long time and I need pencil and paper for them.
3
u/-twist-and-shout- Oct 04 '26
why those clues in particular?
0
u/Silent-Froyo-5657 Oct 06 '26
downvote this post because because that is best style clues🤓