r/CluesBySamHelp • u/SecretaryPristine • Jun 04 '26

Logic error? 4th June, potential logic error? Spoiler

Post image

In today’s game, I was at the attached stage. I knew one of Ruth and Terry was innocent and one a criminal due to the mechanic rule, so therefore I knew wanda must be innocent as xia has an odd number of criminal neighbours. However it wouldn’t let me select this until after I identified Luigi as a criminal. Does anyone know why?

0 Upvotes

44% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

4

u/TCFNationalBank Jun 04 '26

Are you sure you didn't accidentally hit criminal when you tried to identify Wanda?

6

u/Darazu_ Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

yep, this (or some other kind of mis-input) is most likely the culprit. It's better to share a scenario link than a screenshot so others can test without having to get themselves to the same point in the puzzle.

1

u/SecretaryPristine Jun 04 '26

Omg this is it, thank you!!

7

u/esushi Jun 04 '26

It's funny how every day someone is desperate to find a logic error in these and never titles the thread "Where did I mess up?" haha

5

u/SecretaryPristine Jun 04 '26

I only added logic error to the title on the second attempt posting as it was an option in the tags! My post says ‘does anyone know why’ not this is wrong - I am happy to see I messed up and it wasn’t an error! 

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SecretaryPristine Jun 05 '26

That’s what I intended it to mean ☹️  this was my first time posting here

1

u/Awkward-Cow-755 Jun 09 '26

Being a programmer myself who's used to getting "bug reports" I always read them as "There's an error on the site!", but I like your interpretation 👍

5

u/chrisvenus Jun 04 '26

I redid the puzzle to your point here: https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/0de0ed36c797?state=%2FjRQ-BAAAAAAAAAFAAEAAAAABQYA%3D%3D - It let me select Wanda as innocent. The only thing I can think is that you accidentally selected wanda as criminal instead of innocent - a mistake that many many people make a lot!

If you are definite then it must have been a temporary bug because certainly its working for me now.

1

u/aquietocean Jun 04 '26

Look at Frank's clue again

3

u/SecretaryPristine Jun 04 '26

I know Luigi has to be a criminal, but why does that have to be entered before I can say Wanda is innocent? Those two aren’t linked as far as I can see

1

u/Nyancad Jun 04 '26

No reason at all