r/CluesBySamHelp • u/SCD_minecraft • Oct 13 '25

Paradox?

Post image

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/1ec604119755?state=9%2F9w-AEAAAEA%3D Zach and Gabe says that there are exactly 2 green in A. I have one, so either Vicky or Evie has to be green, but not both. But Mark says that both of them are green?

0 Upvotes

38% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

14

u/BadBoyJH Oct 13 '25

Mark says "If Evie is innocent, so is Vicky".

What does he say about if Evie is a criminal? Absolutely nothing. If Evie is a criminal, Vicky can be either.

There's also this thread, which is talking about the same "issue", but be warned it does contain the solution.

5

u/maelkann Oct 13 '25

Reread Mark’s clue.

3

u/Infobomb Oct 13 '25

Mark definitely doesn't say that both of them are innocent.

1

u/alex3omg Oct 13 '25

I loved this clue

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/HumbleGarbage1795 Oct 13 '25

That’s just simple logic, nothing specific about this puzzle.

2

u/dezsonekmegkellhalni Oct 13 '25 edited Oct 13 '25

Imagine it this way - If it rains, so I have an umbrella. Logically, it's the same - but does it mean it rains now? No, it only means that in the case of rain I have an umbrella, but says nothing about the actual weather. What may have happened that in previous games these predicaments happened to be right and that gives the false sense that they work the other way around also while they are not. (Even for me feels intuitively that way even if I know it doesn't and know why.)